Woot, I got it to work now
in S3(STR) with NO Error.....at first I thought updating the Bios to the latest would solve the problem, I updated to the latest F13 and still the same Error 12 HAL.
Simply by changing the "Allow hybrid sleep" from ON to OFF (Under Balance Plan) solves the problem
, no error and everything shutdown and can wake/resume by double clicking of the mouse!
I hope this is useful for those who are also experiencing the same problem!