The results are in!
I am running SergioGarcia's theme and might I say...the pic he posted doesn't do it justice!
What I really like:
Open Dialog (The orange menu bar...was breath taking)
Caption Buttons (Again the silver is incredible)
Aero Peek Button (It has the perfect reflection on it...first thing that popped out on me)
Explorer (From the buttons to the panes...I love it)
What I didn't like
Orange rectange around the explorer address bar and search (It felt a little out of place...if it was the same as the start menu's rectangle around the search bar...)
The red arrow buttons (to go up and down a page)
The edges around the Start Menu
Gotta love em' huh? The icons on the Superbar (when opened) are overlapping the bar itself
The position of shutdown and search in the start menu (mentioned above)
The border between the window list area and the system icons area on the Superbar (there is a line there
The font and colors of the address bar and search bar in IE
Overall I am giving Garcia's theme an A+. As he knows very well...I am a very harsh crtic of graphics...and I know this rating will make him very happy