Hey guys, I'm back with an update. When I installed the new motherboard (again, same model, new unit) and booted up my computer, everything worked fine on Window's side. I didn't have to reinstall Windows 7, I'm not even sure if I needed to reactivate it (I can't recall exactly, but if I did have to reactivate, then it was a seemless clicking "activate windows" button and that was it). Unfortunately, the replacement motherboard I got was also defective (bad PCIe x16 slot), but I it's good to know that there was/will be no problem with getting my Windows 7 working with the new motherboard