HD Audio over HDMI solutions please???

A cheap audio card http://http://www.tigerdirect.com/ap...731&CatId=2771 Why would something like this not work? I also have a HTPC. I have a cheap video card also. A Geforce 210. It does the HD video just fine, and my sound card similar to the one I linked does the audio. It is True HD sound, and video. Way more inexspensive than the card that you are reffering to. And between bothof them I spent $80. I think... It is amazing sound through my Yamaha receiver. I also Play my Blu-Ray movies in this rig. A good all in one Media center is XBMC. It is free and is set up for HD. If you have a HTPC than you should check it out. Hope this helps you.-Tom

Thanks for the suggestions,

The PSU is a Corsair HX520 Modular one. (i forgot to mention that and it runs my 8800GT just fine along with a Huappage HD satellite tuner card, 3 hard drives, and two optical drives).

I just never had ATI cards before, always been an Nvidia man, so I dont understand how they compare.

I would rather the video card handle the video and audio from the PCI-E bus rather than adding in a seperate sound card and keep the audio digital rather than analogue.

There are several cards (Including Nvidia!) that do both. I believe nvidia GT430 does both. I think the main thing you have to ask yourself is how good a job you want it to do on games. Like I stated before I have a Nvidia Geforce 210 and it does great job on the HD video on a 46" Sharp LED display. I get my HD sound from my mobo.

I would think your PSU would be big enough. I also have always been a Nvidia man myself. I personally would stick with them. Personal preference though. All of the video cards we have mentioned do digital HD sound. DTS and such. No analog. I hope all of this will help you out. If I have plz add rep!!

Tomrdiedrich said:

There are several cards (Including Nvidia!) that do both. I believe nvidia GT430 does both. I think the main thing you have to ask yourself is how good a job you want it to do on games. Like I stated before I have a Nvidia Geforce 210 and it does great job on the HD video on a 46" Sharp LED display. I get my HD sound from my mobo.

I would think your PSU would be big enough. I also have always been a Nvidia man myself. I personally would stick with them. Personal preference though. All of the video cards we have mentioned do digital HD sound. DTS and such. No analog. I hope all of this will help you out. If I have plz add rep!!

Thanks for the replies,
In trying to stick with Nvidia, the GT 430 (and with passive cooling varieties) seemed a good choice but upon reading reviews, I think it would struggle to reach decent/playable FPS on games I own like Crysis, C.O.D Black OPS, Farcry 2, F.E.A.R 2 etc.
What about a GTX 460? Is that going too far for Noise levels and wattage requirements?
There seems to be more options going down the ATI route but I hear such bad reliability with the drivers.

Tomrdiedrich said:

If you are going to be playing those games you mentioned, the gtx460 is not the right card. Ati Radeon 5850 is a far better card for about the same price. The gtx460 will play those games but not on high settings. I am currently going through the same search right now myself and have come to realize to get the same power from a nvidia card you have to be ready to pay a whole bunch more! Radeon card just are more powerfull for quite a bit less. Myself do to the size restraints of my case I am going with the MSI5770 hawk. It is a real tough Radeon card with good components. That is the most powerful card my case can fit. It has DTS and HD sound support also. Check it out!

You may be pushing the power envelope with these cards though. I am running a 750w Themaltake. Most of these cards suggest a minimum of a 500w psu. So depending on you system it may/may not be big enough. If you filled out the sys spec page we could help you better. If I hafd the room I would with out a doubt go with the Radeon 5850. It smashes the performance of the GTX460.

(System Specs now populated)
Yeah a 5770 is tempting. The HTPC case i intend to use is an ANTEC fusion Remote Max (full size ATX) so I could probably fit what I like in there, except I want to keep noise and temps down.
To this end, I dont want to upgrade my PSU, or need any better performance than the 8800GT 512mb that I have. I've been quite happy (very impressed in fact) on all those games even if not maxed out on setings. Have stayd aroung the 720P resolutions band though not 1080P.
So, I could go for a 5770 but I reckon a passive Sapphire Radeon HD 5670 ultimate would do me adequately and would of course be silent into the bargain.
What I do worry about is how all modern cards seem to have 1 gig of memory these days and how this might starve me of system RAM. My system only sees 3.5gig of RAM as it is.??????

The system still uses your full 4gb of RAM. It is using that .5 you see missing. I would not worry about starved RAM. I just recently upgraded my RAM to 8gb from 4gb. My current card the nVidia 210 only has .5gb of RAM. And I play 1080p movies all the time. Not once has my video studdered, paused, or had any difficulty with playback. I also never had any issues with having enough RAM either. What do you plan on running while you are watching your movie? I cannot think of on instance where having 4 would be a issue. You are watching a movie. Not running tons of applications. 1GB OF VIDEO ram IS QUITE A BIT. Not to mention if you get vid card with GDDR5 RAM. That stuff is blistering fast. Even GDDR3 is real fast.

Point being if your current card plays your games fine then there are tons of cards out there that will play your HD video with HD sound. And they will do a great job at it. If you go with nVidia stay above a GT230 and you will be fine. If you upgrade to a Radeon 5770 it will blow your socks off. A card like that is 10x the card your current card is. You are not asking alot and there are hundreds of choices! Pick a price range. Figure out what you want(wich sounds like you have), and pull the trigger. Don't look back and enjoy! Good Luck.

Thanks for the advice