Windows 7 Forums

Welcome to Windows 7 Forums. Our forum is dedicated to helping you find support and solutions for any problems regarding your Windows 7 PC be it Dell, HP, Acer, Asus or a custom build. We also provide an extensive Windows 7 tutorial section that covers a wide range of tips and tricks.


Windows 7: portable external HDD Vs. Desktop external HDD?

29 Nov 2010   #1
imeem

Windows 7 Home Premium 64-bit
 
 
portable external HDD Vs. Desktop external HDD?

What's the difference between portable external HDD and Desktop external HDD? I notice desktop external HDD cost more.

What's the point of different size of external HDD 2.5" and 3.5 "?


My System SpecsSystem Spec
.
30 Nov 2010   #2
zigzag3143

Win 8 Release candidate 8400
 
 

Quote   Quote: Originally Posted by imeem View Post
What's the difference between portable external HDD and Desktop external HDD? I notice desktop external HDD cost more.

What's the point of different size of external HDD 2.5" and 3.5 "?
Size, speed, cabling, cache, etc.


Do you want to use it in a laptop or desktop?


Ken J
My System SpecsSystem Spec
30 Nov 2010   #3
Bill2

Windows 7 x64 pro/ Windows 7 x86 Pro/ XP SP3 x86
 
 

External hard drives come in two sizes, 2.5" and 3.5".

The 2.5" are the portable ones that can be easily carried around (they have relatively small capacity and a small enclosure) and are usually USB powered. The downside is they are not unbreakable (you need to take decent care of them), also usb power becomes an issue if you have many other usb powered devices connected to the same computer. If the drive is underpowered, it'll behave wierdly.

Desktop external hard drives are normally 3.5" hard drives mounted in a relatively larger enclosure, sometimes with integrated fans (that helps keep them cool).These drives are designed with storage capacity in mind and can go upto 2 tb or even 3 tb nowadays. They often come with a separate, independent power supply.

2.5" is also the size of internal hard drives of notebooks, while 3.5" ones fit internally in desktops.
My System SpecsSystem Spec
.

30 Nov 2010   #4
imeem

Windows 7 Home Premium 64-bit
 
 

Quote   Quote: Originally Posted by zigzag3143 View Post
Quote   Quote: Originally Posted by imeem View Post
What's the difference between portable external HDD and Desktop external HDD? I notice desktop external HDD cost more.

What's the point of different size of external HDD 2.5" and 3.5 "?
Size, speed, cabling, cache, etc.


Do you want to use it in a laptop or desktop?


Ken J
I'll be using it on a desktop and a laptop to store stuff. Most likely I won't be moving it outside my house.

How good/bad are the external HDD with the software included?
My System SpecsSystem Spec
30 Nov 2010   #5
DirtyElf

Windows 7 64-bit Home
 
 

if it were up to me i would get a BARE drive and format it the way I want it.. i have a WD mybook and it has all this crap software built into it via a virtual disc... try as i may i cant get rid of it.. its stored in the firmware of the drive
My System SpecsSystem Spec
30 Nov 2010   #6
whs
Microsoft MVP

Vista, Windows7, Mint Mate, Zorin, Windows 8
 
 

The quality of external hard drives seems to be very good. I have 7 drives of different manufacturers (both 2.5. and 3.5"). None have failed in appr. 3 years - knock on wood. For very critical data (e.g. images) it is always an advantage to alternate between drives. That gives you extra security.
My System SpecsSystem Spec
30 Nov 2010   #7
mjf

Windows 7x64 Home Premium SP1
 
 

I have 4 ext HDDs
Portable:
(1) WD Elements 500GB,portable 2.5",5400rpm, USB powered, extremley small
(2) WD Elements 7500GB,portable 2.5",5200rpm, USB powered, extremley small
Desktop:
(4) Seagate Expansion 500GB,desktop, 3.5",7200, mains powered
(5) WD Elements 1TB, desktop, 3.5", 7200, mains powered.

All have sata drives inside with usb converter.
(4)&(5) are faster as you would expect but heat can be a problem. Both can hit 50C+ and I have a small fan for cooling on hot days. These are normal sata drives in a confined space. Any built in power management doesn't seem that great to me. I turn them on and off when needed.
I question their long term reliability if left running for long periods in warm ambient temps. I'd go for an extra internal with good cooling if powered on all the time and accessed frequently.

I like the little portables. Yes a bit slower but I find them great for backups - like an overgrown USB flash drive. If you also have a notebook - perfect. They seem to run quite a bit cooler and seem to have better power management (???).

Pricewise - not much of a difference where I'm from. WD 1TB recently on sale for $87.

I strongly support the previous poster - Buy the bare bones units - NO SOFTWARE BACKUP rubbish.
My System SpecsSystem Spec
30 Nov 2010   #8
imeem

Windows 7 Home Premium 64-bit
 
 

So i should go for one that doesn't need any software. Should I go for a usb powered one or an one that requires an power outlet?

The only time I will be plugging the external HDD in is when I need to use it, after i'm done with it, i'll just unplug it.
My System SpecsSystem Spec
30 Nov 2010   #9
essenbe
Microsoft MVP

Windows 7 Enterprise X64/Windows 10 Enterprise X64/Windows 10 Pro X64/Linux Mint
 
 

I have two seagate portable hard drives and two Rosewill external enclosures with 3.5" 1TB Samsung Spinpoints in them. I love both. The enclosures to me are more like desktops. The seagate portables are just that, portable. They run off USB power and are not much larger than your wallet. They are great for taking whatever you want with you. The rosewills are great too. Another advantage is If my computer HD goes out, I can take the Spinpoints out of the enclosure and install it in the computer in 5 minutes.

EDIT: most of the hard drive come with backup software on them. I have never seen any of that software I want to use. Withe the Seagates, I reformatted them and got rid of it.
My System SpecsSystem Spec
30 Nov 2010   #10
imeem

Windows 7 Home Premium 64-bit
 
 

Quote   Quote: Originally Posted by essenbe View Post
I have two seagate portable hard drives and two Rosewill external enclosures with 3.5" 1TB Samsung Spinpoints in them. I love both. The enclosures to me are more like desktops. The seagate portables are just that, portable. They run off USB power and are not much larger than your wallet. They are great for taking whatever you want with you. The rosewills are great too. Another advantage is If my computer HD goes out, I can take the Spinpoints out of the enclosure and install it in the computer in 5 minutes.

EDIT: most of the hard drive come with backup software on them. I have never seen any of that software I want to use. Withe the Seagates, I reformatted them and got rid of it.
So if I have to get the HDDs with software preloaded in them (because the ones i'm looking at is at my price range and 7200 rpm), i can reformat the drive to get rid of it?

Do i even have to use the software to back up my computer? Can't I just use the windows 7 one?
My System SpecsSystem Spec
Reply

 portable external HDD Vs. Desktop external HDD?




Thread Tools




Similar help and support threads
Thread Forum
Portable OS - Carry your OS on an External Drive
How to Create a Portable OS on an External Drive Objective The objective is to create an OS installation on an external USB attached media with which you can carry your OS to any system. I have tested the procedure with Windows 8 and Zorin, an Ubuntu based Linux distro. In such a...
Tutorials
Seagate Portable External Hard Drive Slim not detected by PC
Hello I need urgent help with resolving this as I am trying to get the harddrive showing up or at least recover files. I was using it at school first and my computer froze so I shut down the computer and restarted without safely removing the hard drive, at first the PC wouldnt reboot because I...
Hardware & Devices
Best external to external hard drive synchronized backup plan?
So I want to clone one external 2TB with another. So one drive is the main use one and another the backup one. So I copy everything over to backup and i store the backup at another house and then I start using the main: deleting and adding/editing files. What is the best software or whatever to...
Hardware & Devices
Copied 600K files from external to external, Merge Folder?
I just spent like 18 hours copying 600K files, 1.33 TB, from a USB 2.0 ext. drive to a 1.36 TB USB 3.0 partition, but at the very end I got a handful of prompts to replace folders that already existed in the newly created folder, asked me to merge the original folder with the one just copied on the...
General Discussion
External HDD On Desktop Startup
Hi.I have windows 7 home premium 64bit,My music and photos are on an external hdd,Working well. The only small niggle is when I start up the desktop the ext hdd brings up the auto open box on screen every time I start the pc,It's not causing any major prob I just click on the red cross and it...
General Discussion
Making an internal optical drive an external portable one
Don't want to buy an expensive external optical drive so am trying to think of how to make a SATA or IDE internal optical drive into an external one for emergencies. Anyone know if I can get adaptors for the power and data connections? Have Googled but no luck. Oops found some build...
Hardware & Devices


Our Sites

Site Links

About Us

Find Us

Windows 7 Forums is an independent web site and has not been authorized, sponsored, or otherwise approved by Microsoft Corporation. "Windows 7" and related materials are trademarks of Microsoft Corp.

Designer Media Ltd

All times are GMT -5. The time now is 09:27.

Twitter Facebook Google+



Windows 7 Forums

Seven Forums Android App Seven Forums IOS App