 |
Welcome to Windows 7 Forums. Our forum is dedicated to helping you find solutions with any problems, errors or issues you are experiencing with Windows 7. The Windows 7 forum also covers news and updates and has an extensive Windows 7 tutorial section that covers a wide range of tips and tricks.
Windows 7 - Cpu selection for rig |
01-19-2012
|
#1 | | windows 7 home 32 (and Home Preimium 64 version) as OFF-os, main OS is ubuntu 10-11 |
Cpu selection for rig i'd be using this for
video editing
audio recording/editing
mid-level pc gaming
a lot of files organizing.
main computer.
which would be better the fx amd 6100 95w (why is it only 95w?)
or
the deneb 975 3.6ghz AMD Phenom II X4 975 Black Edition Deneb 3.6GHz Socket AM3 125W Quad-Core Desktop Processor HDZ975FBGMBOX
?
I was set on the 6100 zambezi but then someone said some tech thing I didn't understand and now uncertain.
thanks.
| My System Specs | | System Manufacturer/Model Number ASUS 1001p netbook and dell 14R OS windows 7 home 32 (and Home Preimium 64 version) as OFF-os, main OS is ubuntu 10-11 CPU Intel Atom N450 1.67 ghz Memory 2GB / 4GB / 8gb_kingston_ddr3_1333_pc310600 Graphics Card gigabyte_geforce_440gt_1gb Monitor(s) Displays asus_vs247hp and dell_19" Keyboard microsoft_sidewinder_x4 (excellent keyboard!) Mouse Microsoft 3000 (quality-portable) PSU antec_500w_green Case rosewill_future_gaming_case Hard Drives 500gb in dell laptop.
250 in netbook. Internet Speed ~400kb/s down DSL Other Info I'm VERY interested in building my own rig flatscreens and running ubuntu and windows home premium or prof. I've tripled-booted (mac os rubbish, ubuntu great!, and windows solid). Designing hardware rig: this forum might be a good resource!
Some of these parts are to a rig that is in the process of being built! |
01-19-2012
|
#2 | | Windows 7 Ultimate x64 & Mac OS X 10.7.1 |
the fx amd 6100 is the better processor for you, as it has more cores so can handle multi tasking and editing better... however it isnt a good processor either way, the new range of bulldozer processors are very poor in comparison to intels core i5's which are the same cost but vastly out perform them.
if your building a rig from scratch id go intel. AMD have failed badly on there attempt to rival intels current chips. | My System Specs | | System Manufacturer/Model Number Built by badgers!!! OS Windows 7 Ultimate x64 & Mac OS X 10.7.1 CPU Intel Core i5 2500k Motherboard Asus P8z68 Memory Corsair Vengence 8gb 1866mhz Graphics Card XFX Ati HD6950 2Gb Sound Card Mobo Optical to Yamaha Rx-V667 7.2 home cinema system Monitor(s) Displays Samsung LED 32" TV Screen Resolution 1920x1080 Keyboard Saitek Cyborg V7 Mouse Saitek R.A.T 9 PSU Corsair HX650w Modular Case NZXT Phantom White Cooling Corsair H60 Push/Pull Hard Drives 120gb Corsair Force 3 SSD Internet Speed Too slow! Other Info AMD fusion E350N Home server-Windows Home Server 2011 (also made by badgers!)
2011 Macbook 2.4ghz Core2Duo, 4gb ddr3, 120gb Ocz Vertex SSD |
01-19-2012
|
#3 | | Main - Windows 7 Pro SP1 64-Bit; 2nd - Windows Server 2008 R2 |
You can see a good overall ranking of raw CPU power here: PassMark Software - CPU Benchmark Charts | My System Specs | | System Manufacturer/Model Number Self OS Main - Windows 7 Pro SP1 64-Bit; 2nd - Windows Server 2008 R2 CPU Main - Core i7 2600K; 2nd - Core i7 920 Motherboard Main - Asus P8Z68-V Pro/Gen3; 2nd - Gigabyte GA-EX58-UDR3 Memory Main - 16GB Corsair Vengeance; 2nd - 12GB Corsair Vengeance Graphics Card Main - XFX Radeon 6870 1GB; 2nd - XFX Radeon 4870 1GB Sound Card Both: Onboard Realtek Azalia Monitor(s) Displays Main - Hann 25" + I-INC 25" + Acer 23"; 2nd - Upgrading Soon Screen Resolution Main - 1920x1080 (All Three Monitors); 2nd - Upgrading Soon Keyboard Main - Razer Reclusa; 2nd - Old MS Keyboard Mouse Main - Logitech MX Revolution; 2nd - Old MS Mouse PSU Main - OCZ 600W Modular; 2nd - OCZ 600W Case Main - Thermaltake Element G; 2nd - NZXT something or other Cooling Main - Corsair H80; 2nd - Prolimatech Megahalems Hard Drives Main - (1) Crucial M4 128GB (Boot)
Main - (1) Seagate 2TB 64MB Cache (Data)
Main - (1) Seagate 2TB 64MB Cache (Data Backup)
2nd - (1) Intel X25-M SSD 80GB (Boot)
2nd - (3) Seagate 1TB 32MB Cache (Data Backup)
2nd - (1) Seagate 320GB (Because) Internet Speed 20Mbps Time-Warner Cable |
01-19-2012
|
#4 | | Windows 7 Ultimate X86 SP1 |
While I like AMD I too would say get an Intel i52500k since you could overclock the crap out of it. They will handle memory a lot better than any AMD chip can at the moment as well.
95W is AMD's attempt at lower-powered chips and higher max temps. | My System Specs | | System Manufacturer/Model Number Brittechnologies II OS Windows 7 Ultimate X86 SP1 CPU i5-2550K differing speeds depending on the day Motherboard ASUS P8X68-V PRO/GEN3 Memory 16GB G.Skill Sniper 2133MHz, 4X4GB Graphics Card ASUS ENGTX460 DirectCU/2DI/1GD5 GeForce GTX 460 Sound Card Onboard Realtek 5-1 Monitor(s) Displays Samsung P2570HD Screen Resolution 1920x1080 Keyboard Old Dell USB From 10 yrs Ago Mouse Gigabyte m6900 wired PSU Corsair HX650W Case Inwin Dragon rider Cooling Hyper 212 EVO w/two Noctua fans @1300 RPM Hard Drives TBA Internet Speed 8-19 Mbs down, 3-4 Mbs up Comcast Cable Other Info 5 fans, LG Bluray/R/RE, ASUS DVD/R/RW |
01-19-2012
|
#5 | | Win 7 premium 64bit/Win Pro XP 32bit /Ubuntu 12.04 |
get a i5 it's stronger then amd cpu's and beats a phenom ii x6 | My System Specs | | System Manufacturer/Model Number me OS Win 7 premium 64bit/Win Pro XP 32bit /Ubuntu 12.04 CPU AMD Athlon II X4 640 Processor (4 CPUs), ~3.1GHz|(O.C)3.4GHz Motherboard M5A78L-MLX Plus Memory 4096MB RAM DDR3 Graphics Card XFX HD 6870 1GB Sound Card Logitech Speakers (VIA High Definition Audio) Monitor(s) Displays 21inch monitor vga Screen Resolution 1280x1024 Keyboard Microsoft USB Comfort Curve Keyboard 2000 (IntelliType Pro) Mouse HP 1000dpi desktop mouse PSU CORSAIR CX600 600w Case AZZA Orion 202 EVO Cooling 4fans and cool master hyper TX3 cpu cooler Hard Drives 500gb hdd 7200rpm Western Digital Internet Speed 5.6mb down/ 0.55up yeah dsl i know it sucks Other Info just a dude who loves tech |
01-20-2012
|
#6 | | windows 7 home 32 (and Home Preimium 64 version) as OFF-os, main OS is ubuntu 10-11 |

Quote: Originally Posted by badger906 the fx amd 6100 is the better processor for you, as it has more cores so can handle multi tasking and editing better... however it isnt a good processor either way, the new range of bulldozer processors are very poor in comparison to intels core i5's which are the same cost but vastly out perform them.
if your building a rig from scratch id go intel. AMD have failed badly on there attempt to rival intels current chips.
that's just opinion. you dropped money on intel, so you support that. I am focusing on amd (likely) and therefore read up on the positive reviews of amd. your input is pure opinion and it's toxically misleading b/c you present it as fact. Many people doing high-end computer tasks that speak the best of amd. | My System Specs | | System Manufacturer/Model Number ASUS 1001p netbook and dell 14R OS windows 7 home 32 (and Home Preimium 64 version) as OFF-os, main OS is ubuntu 10-11 CPU Intel Atom N450 1.67 ghz Memory 2GB / 4GB / 8gb_kingston_ddr3_1333_pc310600 Graphics Card gigabyte_geforce_440gt_1gb Monitor(s) Displays asus_vs247hp and dell_19" Keyboard microsoft_sidewinder_x4 (excellent keyboard!) Mouse Microsoft 3000 (quality-portable) PSU antec_500w_green Case rosewill_future_gaming_case Hard Drives 500gb in dell laptop.
250 in netbook. Internet Speed ~400kb/s down DSL Other Info I'm VERY interested in building my own rig flatscreens and running ubuntu and windows home premium or prof. I've tripled-booted (mac os rubbish, ubuntu great!, and windows solid). Designing hardware rig: this forum might be a good resource!
Some of these parts are to a rig that is in the process of being built! |
01-20-2012
|
#7 | | windows 7 home 32 (and Home Preimium 64 version) as OFF-os, main OS is ubuntu 10-11 |

Quote: Originally Posted by Britton30 While I like AMD I too would say get an Intel i52500k since you could overclock the crap out of it. They will handle memory a lot better than any AMD chip can at the moment as well.
95W is AMD's attempt at lower-powered chips and higher max temps.
I saw a vid and I think amd overlocked a consumer level chip at over 8ghz, setting a guiness world record. | My System Specs | | System Manufacturer/Model Number ASUS 1001p netbook and dell 14R OS windows 7 home 32 (and Home Preimium 64 version) as OFF-os, main OS is ubuntu 10-11 CPU Intel Atom N450 1.67 ghz Memory 2GB / 4GB / 8gb_kingston_ddr3_1333_pc310600 Graphics Card gigabyte_geforce_440gt_1gb Monitor(s) Displays asus_vs247hp and dell_19" Keyboard microsoft_sidewinder_x4 (excellent keyboard!) Mouse Microsoft 3000 (quality-portable) PSU antec_500w_green Case rosewill_future_gaming_case Hard Drives 500gb in dell laptop.
250 in netbook. Internet Speed ~400kb/s down DSL Other Info I'm VERY interested in building my own rig flatscreens and running ubuntu and windows home premium or prof. I've tripled-booted (mac os rubbish, ubuntu great!, and windows solid). Designing hardware rig: this forum might be a good resource!
Some of these parts are to a rig that is in the process of being built! |
01-20-2012
|
#8 | | windows 7 home 32 (and Home Preimium 64 version) as OFF-os, main OS is ubuntu 10-11 |

Quote: Originally Posted by Britton30 While I like AMD I too would say get an Intel i52500k since you could overclock the crap out of it. They will handle memory a lot better than any AMD chip can at the moment as well.
95W is AMD's attempt at lower-powered chips and higher max temps.
thx for explaining the 95w significance. so lower watter --> lower heat (less overheating)??? | My System Specs | | System Manufacturer/Model Number ASUS 1001p netbook and dell 14R OS windows 7 home 32 (and Home Preimium 64 version) as OFF-os, main OS is ubuntu 10-11 CPU Intel Atom N450 1.67 ghz Memory 2GB / 4GB / 8gb_kingston_ddr3_1333_pc310600 Graphics Card gigabyte_geforce_440gt_1gb Monitor(s) Displays asus_vs247hp and dell_19" Keyboard microsoft_sidewinder_x4 (excellent keyboard!) Mouse Microsoft 3000 (quality-portable) PSU antec_500w_green Case rosewill_future_gaming_case Hard Drives 500gb in dell laptop.
250 in netbook. Internet Speed ~400kb/s down DSL Other Info I'm VERY interested in building my own rig flatscreens and running ubuntu and windows home premium or prof. I've tripled-booted (mac os rubbish, ubuntu great!, and windows solid). Designing hardware rig: this forum might be a good resource!
Some of these parts are to a rig that is in the process of being built! |
01-20-2012
|
#9 | | windows 7 home 32 (and Home Preimium 64 version) as OFF-os, main OS is ubuntu 10-11 |
HEY!! Something actually USEFUL instead of some person blabbing and misconstruing their opinion as fact. Thanks!
okay...
AMD FX-6100 Six-Core - 5,731 159.99
Intel Core i5-2310 @ 2.90GHz - 5,890 $184.99
obviously the i5 ranked slightly higher. I am pretty certain I will do the 6100 if I go amd, uncertain about intel though. Still not sold on it. Nevertheless. VERY helpful benchmarks for comparison. thanks profdlp! | My System Specs | | System Manufacturer/Model Number ASUS 1001p netbook and dell 14R OS windows 7 home 32 (and Home Preimium 64 version) as OFF-os, main OS is ubuntu 10-11 CPU Intel Atom N450 1.67 ghz Memory 2GB / 4GB / 8gb_kingston_ddr3_1333_pc310600 Graphics Card gigabyte_geforce_440gt_1gb Monitor(s) Displays asus_vs247hp and dell_19" Keyboard microsoft_sidewinder_x4 (excellent keyboard!) Mouse Microsoft 3000 (quality-portable) PSU antec_500w_green Case rosewill_future_gaming_case Hard Drives 500gb in dell laptop.
250 in netbook. Internet Speed ~400kb/s down DSL Other Info I'm VERY interested in building my own rig flatscreens and running ubuntu and windows home premium or prof. I've tripled-booted (mac os rubbish, ubuntu great!, and windows solid). Designing hardware rig: this forum might be a good resource!
Some of these parts are to a rig that is in the process of being built! |
01-20-2012
|
#10 | | windows 7 home 32 (and Home Preimium 64 version) as OFF-os, main OS is ubuntu 10-11 |
this may change, but although I've been learning/researching about computers for quite some time, this is the first rig I build from scratch. so....advanced overclocking isn't much of a concern (but that may change). From what I've heard the 6100 amd and intel can overclock well.
This IS a clutch purchase because it will decide the mobo and whatnot.
Finally, the tone of some responses/replies were helfpul and objective others were just spewing opinion I am not interested in a which is better amd v intel thread. I genuinely just want to make the best decision purchase. It's taken me many many months to save up and get these parts (a part every 1-2 months). I've doubted this at times and just thought about using the old laptop or if I move I wondered what I'd do with the rig (bring it likely, possibly sell) anyways I really want to build this and it's taken awhile and once I decide on mobo or cpu then it will be easy to get the remaining parts. In a sense the mobo or cpu is the only choice left for components.
I also feel this thread is lacking impartiality because well it sounds like most replies are from people with intel chips. If more amd people responded, might be helpful. All newegg reviews i read of amd are exceptional.
at least I know 6100 if I get amd, but may read a bit more. helpful benchmarks thanks!
Last edited by johntkucz; 01-20-2012 at 06:51 PM..
Reason: wanted to add last paragraph
| My System Specs | | System Manufacturer/Model Number ASUS 1001p netbook and dell 14R OS windows 7 home 32 (and Home Preimium 64 version) as OFF-os, main OS is ubuntu 10-11 CPU Intel Atom N450 1.67 ghz Memory 2GB / 4GB / 8gb_kingston_ddr3_1333_pc310600 Graphics Card gigabyte_geforce_440gt_1gb Monitor(s) Displays asus_vs247hp and dell_19" Keyboard microsoft_sidewinder_x4 (excellent keyboard!) Mouse Microsoft 3000 (quality-portable) PSU antec_500w_green Case rosewill_future_gaming_case Hard Drives 500gb in dell laptop.
250 in netbook. Internet Speed ~400kb/s down DSL Other Info I'm VERY interested in building my own rig flatscreens and running ubuntu and windows home premium or prof. I've tripled-booted (mac os rubbish, ubuntu great!, and windows solid). Designing hardware rig: this forum might be a good resource!
Some of these parts are to a rig that is in the process of being built! Cpu selection for rig problems? All times are GMT -5. The time now is 01:13 PM. |  |