:/ If you look at the picture, display 2 (the widescreen) is set as my primary and display 1 (the full screen) has an unchacked box offering me to set it as primary. It seems that selecting which is primary is not really my solution in this particular dilemma.
I just recently built this computer and my foresight wasn't keen enough for me to recognize that with my case and video card, the HDMI inset would be slightly obscured. To make a long story short, HDMI (widescreen/ display 2) is inserted into my mother board while my DVI (fullscreen/ display 1) is inserted into my video card. So I'm not sure the ports on the card solution applies here as well.
Sorry to make matters worse...