Windows 7 Forums

Welcome to Windows 7 Forums. Our forum is dedicated to helping you find support and solutions for any problems regarding your Windows 7 PC be it Dell, HP, Acer, Asus or a custom build. We also provide an extensive Windows 7 tutorial section that covers a wide range of tips and tricks.


Windows 7: RAID 0 vs SSD cached HDD for video editing

08 Oct 2012   #1
Late951

Win 7 Professional x64 - SevenForums optimised !
 
 
RAID 0 vs SSD cached HDD for video editing

Hello World, this is my first post to the forum as a recent Win 7 convert.

I have recently built a video editing PC and I am in the process of re-jigging the storage to suit the video editing task.

My plan is:
1 x SSD for the OS & apps.
1 x SSD for my 'small' data i.e. docs & every day stuff
2 x 1TB HDD in RAID 0, backed up via weekly schedule to an Internal SATA III 2TB drive.
The SSDs get backed up nightly to a 1TB USB2.0 external drive.

The goal there is separate read/write paths for the OS, routine apps & video apps.

Most of my video clips tend to be 4GB+

Question 1: performance wise, how well does a SSD cached single HDD, compare with a RAID 0 2 HDD setup? I am less concerned with reliability since my backup arrangements provide a low fuss recovery plan in the event of a RAID corruption.

For what it is worth I have 4 6Gb/sec SATA ports & 4 3Gb/sec SATA ports available with SSD caching available for one pair of 6Gb ports.

Question 2: Has anyone else run Win 7 x64 on a 64GB SSD ? My OS, page file & Apps = 44GB so I am contemplating putting that on my 64GB SSD and the small data on the 128GB SSD - I have about 100GB of 'small' data. I don't anticipate a lot of new applications being installed.

PS - Thanks to the forum key players for the great tutorials, I found those very helpful in eliminating unecessary services & start ups over the past few days.


My System SpecsSystem Spec
.

10 Oct 2012   #2
Late951

Win 7 Professional x64 - SevenForums optimised !
 
 

Update....

As there wasn't much response here I looked further afield in some video editing sites and the expert opinion for the video application is pretty much in favour of the RAID approach to video storage.

That being said I have ordered 2x1TB Western Digital Caviar Blacks (7200RPM/SATA III/64MB) for the RAID pair in RAID 0. Hopefully the extra price premium for the 5yr warranty on the Caviar Blacks will reduce the number of RAID failure issues. In any case they will be backed up to a non RAID 2TB Seagate internal drive.

I have transferred the OS & apps to my 64GB SSD, it is 50% full.
My non video files / general data now occupies about 90GB of the 128GB SSD.
These two drives backup to an external 1TB USB 2 drive.

This arrangement seems to work pretty well with independent read/write pipes for OS activity, application data and video data. I haven't installed the RAID pair yet but I look forward to seeing how well that handles video data transfer.
My System SpecsSystem Spec
12 Oct 2012   #3
Late951

Win 7 Professional x64 - SevenForums optimised !
 
 

I went ahead and installed the RAID 0 array to my system. That wasn't exactly straight forwards but it is do-able as I documented here.

Hardware RAID installation after Windows 7 OS install

Now that's done I thought I should post some benchmarks for the different disks running in my system. It turns out there are differences worth considering. the 128GB SSDs are considerably faster at writes than the 64GB drives. The Seagate Barracuda is faster than the Caviar Blacks in Stand alone AHCI mode. The Caviar Blacks in RAID 0 are 40% faster than the Seagate Barracuda in AHCI for video writes.

If I were doing it again with this knowledge in hand I would have bought 2x128GB SSDs rather than 1x64 and 1x128. I would consider a pair of Seagate drives for the RAID array...my only concern with that option is that the Seagate drives are only a 1yr warranty vs the 5yr WD Caviar Blacks.

Based on the results I'd also say that using a 128GB SSD dedicated to being a video file temporary workspace would be even better than the RAID setup. Ie Edit the video files to & from the SSD and copy the source & edited files to the higher capacity storage disk when done.

This is the Samsung 830 64GB SSD (Win 7 OS Disk) C:

This is the Samsung 830 128GB SSD (Main data disk) D:

This is a WD 1TB Caviar Black disk pre RAID R:-932GB

This is the pair of WD Caviar Black disks in RAID 0 R:-1770GB

This is the Seagate Barracuda 2TB in AHCI. E:


Attached Images
     
My System SpecsSystem Spec
.


12 Oct 2012   #4
UnknownReverent

MS Windows 7 Professional 64-bit SP1
 
 

How big is the SSD? It would have been better to do a cache rather than raid, in my opinion.
My System SpecsSystem Spec
Reply

 RAID 0 vs SSD cached HDD for video editing




Thread Tools





Similar help and support threads
Thread Forum
Windows 8- Graphics Performance- Photo Editing/Video Editing
My question narrows down to what would be a better OS to use for Photo Editing and or occasional video editing. The software used for Photo Editing would be Adobe Lightroom 4.0 and Adobe Photoshop. All software versions using latest build- approved system requirements would meet critieria with...
Music, Pictures & Video
How Much Ram For Editing Video?
Ok so here is my system specs: Intel Core I5 Quad Core @ 3.30ghz 64Bit Windows 7 Home. ATI Radion HD 6450 1gb dedicated. Ram 6GB DDR3. ( x2gb stick, and x1, 4gb stick) so i know i need more ram for video editing but what should i upgrade to 8gb and add another 2gb in or max out to 16gb. ...
Hardware & Devices
Video editing
I do a fair bit of video editing and I have recently upgraded the ram to 8gb and gone to win 7 64bit. I built the pc a few weeks back and have yet to add a card. It appears gaming is the main priority and wonder if anyone has any first hand experience with a good card.
Graphic Cards
Video Editing
I am running Windows 7 Home Premium 64 bit and have found that I now need a program for video editing that is capable of merging FLV, AVI files and yes I know the two cannot be merged together in any one single file. Any suggestions would be appreciated.:D
Software
Video Editing ?'s
I've recently started various multimedia activities...recording, editing, publishing audio, photos, and videos. I'm a Film & Digital Media student at University of California, Santa Cruz and everything there related to media is Mac-based. I know Windows, I trust Windows, Windows is logical, Windows...
Music, Pictures & Video
Video Editing
I have a small video clip I took with my Kodak C743 camera. It is too dark and I would like to lighten it . This I can do in Windows Media Player but it does not let me save my changes. I can't see them putting those tools in there if we can't use them. I must be doing something wrong but I don't...
Browsers & Mail

Our Sites

Site Links

About Us

Find Us

Windows 7 Forums is an independent web site and has not been authorized, sponsored, or otherwise approved by Microsoft Corporation. "Windows 7" and related materials are trademarks of Microsoft Corp.

Designer Media Ltd

All times are GMT -5. The time now is 20:07.

Twitter Facebook Google+



Windows 7 Forums

Seven Forums Android App Seven Forums IOS App