ORICO 4 Bay slot Raid Question

Page 1 of 2 12 LastLast

  1. Posts : 43
    Home Premium 7 64x
       #1

    ORICO 4 Bay slot Raid Question


    I just got an ORICO 4 Bay slot i want to setup some hard drives for RAID Redundancy. Whats the best RAID to set it up as if one drive fails/dies I can just swap it out with another drive so I don't lose any data.
      My Computer


  2. Posts : 1,992
    10 Pro x64
       #2

    Did you just buy 4 drive bay hotswap rails for your pc and your going to set them up with the motherboard or is this a separate nas box? I can not find much info with what you have provided on the model of product you have decided to use and what it supports. That being said you should look into RAID much before you attempt it. Redundancy is not a backup so don't treat is as one (just a freindly warning). RAID 1, 5, and 10 are the most common i'd say. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Standard_RAID_levels
      My Computer


  3. Posts : 77
    Windows 7 Ultimate x64
       #3

    you'd configure it as raid 5.
    that being said, cheap raid boxes like that are the opposite of safety.
    if the box dies, your data is gone.
    you're putting yourself in a scenario where data loss happens 1x in 10 years. same as single drive.

    just drop the manufacturer an email asking how to recover from controller failure in say 3-5 years, see what they say.

    if you want safety: onboard raid 1 (cheap) or a proper hardware controller + enterprise drives (1500$+).
      My Computer


  4. Posts : 9,600
    Win 7 Ultimate 64 bit
       #4

    countzero said:
    you'd configure it as raid 5.
    that being said, cheap raid boxes like that are the opposite of safety.
    if the box dies, your data is gone.
    you're putting yourself in a scenario where data loss happens 1x in 10 years. same as single drive.

    just drop the manufacturer an email asking how to recover from controller failure in say 3-5 years, see what they say.

    if you want safety: onboard raid 1 (cheap) or a proper hardware controller + enterprise drives (1500$+).
    Horse feathers! This forum and especially other forums I'm on are littered with posts from people losing data from failed drives. Drives can, and do, catastrophically fail with no hope of data recovery of any kind (controller PCBs aren't the only things that fail) or data can only be recovered with expensive professional data recovery (and even that is no guarantee).

    I've said it before and I will say it again; RAID is not a backup. RAID (except for 0) is redundancy that will protect you from data loss if one or two drives, depending on the type of RAID, should fail and allow the computer to keep chugging along without interruption until the dead drive can be replaced. However, drive failure isn't the only way to lose data.

    Data can be lost due to viruses and other malware, natural disasters (flood, fire, etc.), user error (accidental deletions, etc.), theft, equipment failure (such as a power surge or a failing PSU fries all the internal HDDs), etc., things RAID CANNOT protect you against. Only separately located backups that get connected to the computer only when updating the backup will protect you.

    But don't take my word for it. Sean Webster, over on the Overclock. net Forums, runs the forums' storage forum, works with all types of drives professionally, and has forgotten more about drives than all of us here combined will ever know. Here is a snippet of what Sean has to say about RAID not being a backup:

    First off, data is not backed up up unless it is in 3 or more separate locations! (with one being offsite)

    Backup is a pretty simple topic. You have your precious data such as photos, videos, documents, music, and even just program files and game saves on your PC and you don't want to lose it right? Well, if so then you should always backup of your data in some sort of way.

    There are two categories of backup: system backup and file backup. A system backup is when you copy everything verbatim on the OS hard drive onto an external storage medium, including the operating system, applications and data. If the drive fails, the computer can be restored to its former state.

    File backup copies only data files onto an external storage medium. If the drive fails, the OS and applications have to be re-installed.

    I like to do a mix of both of these to cover my butt in case of anything. You will see what I do exactly in the following steps.



    RAID is not designed to replace a proper backup solution, it's there to protect against drive failures with minimal to no down time. I don't understand why some people think that just because different RAIDs such as RAID 5 or RAID 6 can take a drive loss and still maintain data integrity that their data is backed up. It simply is not. Data needs to be in multiple places to actually be backed up, not just a single RAID volume in a single PC/location.


    RAID arrays do NOT protect against:
    • Boot Sector Corruption
    • Human error (deleting files by mistake)
    • RAID controller/software failure
    • Fire, flood, or other calamity such as an EMP in your PC...
    • Theft, hacker attack, or other offensive action
    • Multiple disk failures and Unrecoverable Read Error
    • Data corruption
    • Virus'
    Ok, he stretched it a bit with EMP (hence the stuck out tongue emoticon) but, otherwise, the point should be pretty clear. Another gentleman on the same forums (don't tell him I called him a gentleman) who goes by Lord Zeb is a Mac computer repairman. He has shared numerous horror tales of customers who have lost all their data to failed drives, including some arrays, simply because they didn't have a proper backup scheme in place.

    I personally use a set of four backup HDDs for every HDD in my computer. Two of each set are stored onsite in a drawer away from my computer at home (I connect the onsite HDDs to my computer only while updating a backup) and the other two are kept offsite in my safe deposit box at my credit union. I swap out the onsite and offsite HDDs no less than once a month, depending on how much data I have added or changed since the previous swap.

    Since the offsite HDDs will not have data that was added or changed after they were put in the safe deposit box, I also have a Carbonite.com account, primarily to fill that gap. If my computer and onsite backups get destroyed or otherwise lost, I could recover all my data from Carbonite should I lose my but, since it would take several weeks to several months to download it all (to my ISP's great dismay), I can quickly recover most of my data from the offsite HDDs and the remaining data from Carbonite, making a full recovery taking only a day or two at most. Of course, should the unthinkable ever happen, such as meteor strike takes out my home and my credit union while I'm lucky enough to be out of town, I can still recover all my data from Carbonite (and my ISP can just build a bridge and get over it).

    I keep duplicate backup HDDs in each location since even backup drives can fail (and I have had it happen). Also, since I don't use RAID (an interruption in operation is just a minor annoyance for me, not a catastrophe like it would be for, say, a business), it takes but a few minutes to disconnect a failed drive and temporarily replace it with one of the backup drives in a dock until I can get the failed drive replaced under warranty or with a new one. Getting a replacement takes only two or three days at most (of course, I could have one overnighted in but why spend more than I have to).

    I use Macrium Reflect Free (here is a good tutorial on how to use Macrium Reflect) to image my C: drive (OS and programs only) and save the images to one of my data drives (for convenience), which then gets backed up.

    I use a folder/file syncing program called FreeFileSync to back up my data drives. FreeFileSync has a feature called versioning that saves deleted files to another folder or drive (I use a dedicated drive for that and also back it up) to protect me from accidental deletions and other user errors.
      My Computer


  5. Posts : 19,383
    Windows 10 Pro x64 ; Xubuntu x64
       #5

    Go with a RAID5
      My Computer


  6. Posts : 77
    Windows 7 Ultimate x64
       #6

    @Lady Fitzgerald

    quite a rant you've got going there.
    i never said that raid is a backup. i said that little raid boxes give a false sense of security.
    they loose data once in 10 years. i didn't mention that hardware raid can also loose data. but safety wise there are 1-2 orders of magnitude between the two, because real controllers can mount their predecessors arrays.
    i've got like 300 accumulated years of 3ware, lsi raids going, never lost a byte.
    still, my livelyhood is stored on redundant hardware raid 5 arrays. likelyhood for data loss is > once in 3000 years for my setup.
    also got LTO-6, but i'm too lazy to carry the tapes off-site. i will live.

    can we be friends again now?
      My Computer


  7. Posts : 20,583
    Win-7-Pro64bit 7-H-Prem-64bit
       #7

    This is the only thing I use raid on
      My Computer


  8. Posts : 9,600
    Win 7 Ultimate 64 bit
       #8

    countzero said:
    @Lady Fitzgerald

    quite a rant you've got going there.
    i never said that raid is a backup. i said that little raid boxes give a false sense of security.
    they loose data once in 10 years. i didn't mention that hardware raid can also loose data. but safety wise there are 1-2 orders of magnitude between the two, because real controllers can mount their predecessors arrays.
    i've got like 300 accumulated years of 3ware, lsi raids going, never lost a byte.
    still, my livelyhood is stored on redundant hardware raid 5 arrays. likelyhood for data loss is > once in 3000 years for my setup.
    also got LTO-6, but i'm too lazy to carry the tapes off-site. i will live.

    can we be friends again now?
    I never said we weren't friends. Friends can (and often do) disagree. You should see some of the arguments I have had with friends.

    I'm sorry if I misinterpreted your post. It appeared to me you were promoting RAID as a backup.
      My Computer


  9. Posts : 77
    Windows 7 Ultimate x64
       #9

    kidding all the way....
      My Computer


  10. Posts : 25,847
    Windows 10 Pro. 64/ version 1709 Windows 7 Pro/64
       #10

    I don't use Raid but like everything else their is a time and place Raid is good.

    This forum uses Raid. If my memory serves me right it's Raid 10 on it's server just encase a drive drops off the others will keep the forum up and running.

    I have never asked John what type of backup method he uses.

    I'm only a small time home user so I really don't have a need for Raid.
    When I get in the mood I just do complete Backups using the built in Windows 7 backup method and to be doubly sure I also use Macrium Reflect.
      My Computer


 
Page 1 of 2 12 LastLast

  Related Discussions
Our Sites
Site Links
About Us
Windows 7 Forums is an independent web site and has not been authorized, sponsored, or otherwise approved by Microsoft Corporation. "Windows 7" and related materials are trademarks of Microsoft Corp.

© Designer Media Ltd
All times are GMT -5. The time now is 09:30.
Find Us