Can't change Network Location to Home

I recently received a new modem and can not change my network location without going into the registry. Every time I try and change the location through Network and Sharing Center it gives me the following error.



I have tried this thread to change it from public to work by going into the registry, but the info is incorrect as the 1 value is for work, not home.

I'll also note that when I leave a homegroup and try to change the network location to Home, it will give the same error.