Thanks Paul, yours too!
I believe the Extreme Preset has a bug. I get the exact same score by running it with CF enabled and disabled, and then I get a number twice as high when running everything set to max 1600x900, plus the scores running one card in Extreme Preset are the same ones when running one card everything set to max 1600x900.
It still sees the two cards, but doesn't use Crossfire.
So I guess the scores for the CF setup are the ones on the last attachment.
Anyone out there seeing the same issue with Crossfire?