| Windows 7: Dark side of COMODO... |
26 Sep 2009
|
#1 | | Windows 7 Home Premium x32 SP1 |
Dark side of COMODO... Quote: Comodo is a popular name in the software business. Comodo provides multiple free, and excellent, products for home users including, but not limited to, the award winning Comodo Firewall (now bundled with Comodo Internet Security). Comodo has also recently become a big name in multiple front-page controversies including the issuance of its SSL security certificates to known malware distributors/scam websites and a row with Softpedia over the inclusion of a third party toolbar in their software. For those that don't know I will do a quick recap for you:
Comodo has been caught selling its popular SSL certificate to malware distributors/scan websites. Now in Comodo's defense, whenever a malware distributor/scan website which has Comodo's certificate is brought to their attention, they remove it; furthermore the purpose of the SSL certificate, technically, is not to verify the contents of the website but rather to verify how secure it is to buy from (the irony). However the question of why Comodo is repeatedly selling the certificates to known malware distributors/scam websites (there have been cases where a website with the same exact layout, interface, and "product" except different name has been issued a certificate even though their earlier one was revoked) is still a significant one and still an on going issue.
Softpedia, once upon a time, labeled Comodo Internet Security as "malware" because CIS included SafeSurf, an optional third party toolbar considered to be malware by Softpedia. Of course Comodo did not like that, so they tried to get Softpedia to remove the label. Softpedia, standing by their high standards, refused. So in the end the result was (is) Comodo Internet Security was (is) removed from Softpedia's download database. Full article: Paying a price to use free software: the dark side of Comodo products | Headline | dotTech [.org] | My System Specs |
| Computer type PC/Desktop System Manufacturer/Model Number Self Built OS Windows 7 Home Premium x32 SP1 CPU x2 2.6 GHz Motherboard Asus Memory A-Data 2GB DDR2-800 Graphics Card ATI X1250 Sound Card SB 5.1 Live! Keyboard BTC 6300 Mouse Logitech VX Nano PSU Tagan TG-480-U01 Hard Drives WD and Seagate FAP Antivirus None |
26 Sep 2009
|
#2 | | Windows® 8 Pro (64-bit) Mumbai, India |
| My System Specs | | System Manufacturer/Model Number Samsung NP530U4B-S02IN OS Windows® 8 Pro (64-bit) CPU Intel® Core™ i5 Processor 2467M (1.60GHz, 3MB L3 Cache) Motherboard Samsung Electronics Memory 6GB DDR3 System Memory at 1,333MHz (on BD 4GB + 2GB x 1) Graphics Card AMD Radeon™ HD7550M 1GB DDR3 (Ext. Graphic) Sound Card Realtek High Definition Audio Monitor(s) Displays 35.56cm (14.0) SuperBright 300nit HD LED Display Screen Resolution 1366x768 Hard Drives 1TB S-ATA II Hard Drive (5400RPM) with ExpressCache 16GB SSD Internet Speed sucks Antivirus Microsoft Security Essentials Browser Google Chrome (Sync enabled) |
26 Sep 2009
|
#3 | | Windows 7 Ultimate The Southern Hinterlands |

Quote: Originally Posted by Dinesh Comodo sucks. Dont mince words on us Dinesh ... tell us what you really think about Comodo?? | My System Specs | | System Manufacturer/Model Number ASUSTeK Computer INC. CM5675 OS Windows 7 Ultimate CPU Core(TM) i5 CPU 650 @ 3.20GHz Motherboard ASUSTeK Computer INC. CM5675 Memory 6.00 GB Graphics Card Intel(R) HD Graphics Sound Card Intel HD integtrated Monitor(s) Displays Samsung 24' Screen Resolution 1900/1020 Hard Drives (1) INTEL SSD SA2M120G2GC ATA Device (2) ST31000528AS ATA Device Internet Speed 30mb |
26 Sep 2009
|
#4 | | Windows® 8 Pro (64-bit) Mumbai, India |

Quote: Originally Posted by Tews 
Quote: Originally Posted by Dinesh Comodo sucks. Dont mince words on us Dinesh ... tell us what you really think about Comodo?? The AV engine is very poor in terms of on-access protection. The firewall will keep throwing pop ups at you every 15-20 secs wanting your action. When i tried to update Comodo internet security, it was stuck at 30% for a long time. The Interface is complex. NOT RECOMMENDED. | My System Specs | | System Manufacturer/Model Number Samsung NP530U4B-S02IN OS Windows® 8 Pro (64-bit) CPU Intel® Core™ i5 Processor 2467M (1.60GHz, 3MB L3 Cache) Motherboard Samsung Electronics Memory 6GB DDR3 System Memory at 1,333MHz (on BD 4GB + 2GB x 1) Graphics Card AMD Radeon™ HD7550M 1GB DDR3 (Ext. Graphic) Sound Card Realtek High Definition Audio Monitor(s) Displays 35.56cm (14.0) SuperBright 300nit HD LED Display Screen Resolution 1366x768 Hard Drives 1TB S-ATA II Hard Drive (5400RPM) with ExpressCache 16GB SSD Internet Speed sucks Antivirus Microsoft Security Essentials Browser Google Chrome (Sync enabled) |
26 Sep 2009
|
#5 | | Windows 7 Home Premium x32 SP1 |

Quote: Originally Posted by Dinesh 
Quote: Originally Posted by Tews 
Quote: Originally Posted by Dinesh Comodo sucks. Dont mince words on us Dinesh ... tell us what you really think about Comodo?? The AV engine is very poor in terms of on-access protection. The firewall will keep throwing pop ups at you every 15-20 secs wanting your action. When i tried to update Comodo internet security, it was stuck at 30% for a long time. The Interface is complex. NOT RECOMMENDED. Another thing... They still don't fix issue with their HIPS implemented in Defense+ module. This HIPS can give not clearly information about running actions in your system for example in Conficker aka Kido case (Information from OA vs information from Comodo Defense+: Wilders Security Forums - View Single Post - Downadup/ Conficker worm versus HIPS
This issue is well known Comodo stuff for months but they do nothing with it... | My System Specs | | Computer type PC/Desktop System Manufacturer/Model Number Self Built OS Windows 7 Home Premium x32 SP1 CPU x2 2.6 GHz Motherboard Asus Memory A-Data 2GB DDR2-800 Graphics Card ATI X1250 Sound Card SB 5.1 Live! Keyboard BTC 6300 Mouse Logitech VX Nano PSU Tagan TG-480-U01 Hard Drives WD and Seagate FAP Antivirus None |
26 Sep 2009
|
#6 | | Windows® 8 Pro (64-bit) Mumbai, India |

Quote: Originally Posted by Creer 
Quote: Originally Posted by Dinesh 
Quote: Originally Posted by Tews
Dont mince words on us Dinesh ... tell us what you really think about Comodo?? The AV engine is very poor in terms of on-access protection. The firewall will keep throwing pop ups at you every 15-20 secs wanting your action. When i tried to update Comodo internet security, it was stuck at 30% for a long time. The Interface is complex. NOT RECOMMENDED. Another thing... They still don't fix issue with their HIPS implemented in Defense+ module. This HIPS can give not clearly information about running actions in your system for example in Conficker aka Kido case (Information from OA vs information from Comodo Defense+: Wilders Security Forums - View Single Post - Downadup/ Conficker worm versus HIPS
This issue is well known Comodo stuff for months but they do nothing with it... Good find. | My System Specs | | System Manufacturer/Model Number Samsung NP530U4B-S02IN OS Windows® 8 Pro (64-bit) CPU Intel® Core™ i5 Processor 2467M (1.60GHz, 3MB L3 Cache) Motherboard Samsung Electronics Memory 6GB DDR3 System Memory at 1,333MHz (on BD 4GB + 2GB x 1) Graphics Card AMD Radeon™ HD7550M 1GB DDR3 (Ext. Graphic) Sound Card Realtek High Definition Audio Monitor(s) Displays 35.56cm (14.0) SuperBright 300nit HD LED Display Screen Resolution 1366x768 Hard Drives 1TB S-ATA II Hard Drive (5400RPM) with ExpressCache 16GB SSD Internet Speed sucks Antivirus Microsoft Security Essentials Browser Google Chrome (Sync enabled) |
26 Sep 2009
|
#7 | | Windows 7 x64 HP, Windows 7 HP, Windows 7 Ult Weatherford, Texas |
Everybody has their own preferences. I use Comodo's firewall and Defense Plus, but not their AV on two machines, and Windows 7 firewall on the other. All are running MSE for AV.
Since I've been using Comodo for a few years, I'm comfortable with the interface, more so that with the Windows firewall. (The number of alerts popping up is probably more a function of Defense Plus than the firewall. Interesting article on taming this - How to Tame Comodo Defense+ Without Disabling It)
I've been trying out the Windows 7 firewall, and without the Windows 7 Firewall Controller, I didn't see any alerts and no popups asking about blocking outgoing, benign programs like MS Media Player, which I do want to block. (default Windows firewall settings).
Like I said, different strokes...
I'm going to give On Line Armor's free version a shot on one of my machines to see if there's a better solution. | My System Specs | | System Manufacturer/Model Number Gateway, Toshiba Laptop, and Home Brew OS Windows 7 x64 HP, Windows 7 HP, Windows 7 Ult CPU Intel I3, Cerelon, Pentium 4 @ 3Ghz Motherboard Intel, Intel, Asus Memory 8G, 3G, 3G Graphics Card On-board Intel, On-board nVidia, nVIDIA card Sound Card on-board, on-board, SoundBlaster Monitor(s) Displays Hannspree HF237, Toshiba, SyncMaster 931B Screen Resolution default (all) Keyboard standard wired (all) Mouse standard wired (all) PSU 300w, unk, 650w Case black, black, grey Cooling air (all) Hard Drives 1T internal, 320G internal, 160G internal, 1T networked Internet Speed 6M down, 768K up Other Info Home LAN through Linksys hub to 4 port and wireless switch/router. Networked HP 2600n. Wife's computer running Windows 7, and spare laptop running Ubuntu "Karmic Kola" (9.10). |
27 Sep 2009
|
#8 | | Windows 7 Ultimate x64 SP1 Somewhere on the 3rd rock from the sun. |
Comodo (and anyone else that partners with Ask) will not be on my machines anymore. Been well over a year an a half since I allowed anything partnered with Ask, and I will keep it that. | My System Specs | | Computer type PC/Desktop System Manufacturer/Model Number The Beast Model V OS Windows 7 Ultimate x64 SP1 CPU Core i7 965 EE @3.6 GHz Motherboard eVGA x58 Classified3 Memory 3 * 4GB Mushkin Enh Redline CL7 DDR3 1600 MHz (PC3-12800) Graphics Card eVGA 560 Ti 448 Core Classified + eVGA GTX260 SSC (PhysX) Sound Card Realtek HD Audio (on-board) Monitor(s) Displays 2 * Acer X213Wbd Screen Resolution 2 * 1680 x 1050 Keyboard Logitech G15 Keyboard Mouse Logitech Performance Mouse MX PSU ThermalTake BlackWidow TX TR2 850 W Case ThermalTake Level 10 GT (Black) Cooling Corsair H100 CPU | 2 * TT 140mm TriLED | 2 * Antec TriCool Hard Drives 1 * Intel Cheryville 520 180 GB SATA III SSD |
1 * Intel X-25M G2 80 GB SATA II SSD |
2 * Seagate 1 TB 32MB Cache 7200.12 SATA II Mech. Internet Speed Cable - 35 Mbit down / 12 Mbit up advertised (30 / 6 act.) Antivirus M$Se / MBAM Pro / WinPatrol Pro Browser Chome(dev) / Canary / Firefox Minefield / Opera Next / IE 10 Other Info Wacom Bamboo Touch |
Hauppauge WinTV-HVR-1850 |
Optimus STAV-3400 AV Receiver |
Bose 301 Series III Speakers (Main channel) |
Bose 161 Speakers (Surround) |
Optimus 3 way 100-W speaker (Center) |
Logitech Clearchat PC Wireless Headset |
Koss ProDJ 100 Headphones |
Microsoft LifeCam Studio |
Motorola Droid BIONIC |
ASUS Transformer Infinity 64GB |
27 Sep 2009
|
#9 | | Windows® 8 Pro (64-bit) Mumbai, India |

Quote: Originally Posted by johngalt Comodo (and anyone else that partners with Ask) will not be on my machines anymore. Been well over a year an a half since I allowed anything partnered with Ask, and I will keep it that. Once i installed nero and NOD 32 detected it as a trojan. then after more research i found out that it was the Ask toolbar within nero which was detected as a harmful item. | My System Specs | | System Manufacturer/Model Number Samsung NP530U4B-S02IN OS Windows® 8 Pro (64-bit) CPU Intel® Core™ i5 Processor 2467M (1.60GHz, 3MB L3 Cache) Motherboard Samsung Electronics Memory 6GB DDR3 System Memory at 1,333MHz (on BD 4GB + 2GB x 1) Graphics Card AMD Radeon™ HD7550M 1GB DDR3 (Ext. Graphic) Sound Card Realtek High Definition Audio Monitor(s) Displays 35.56cm (14.0) SuperBright 300nit HD LED Display Screen Resolution 1366x768 Hard Drives 1TB S-ATA II Hard Drive (5400RPM) with ExpressCache 16GB SSD Internet Speed sucks Antivirus Microsoft Security Essentials Browser Google Chrome (Sync enabled) |
27 Sep 2009
|
#10 | | Windows 7 Ultimate x64 + x86 + Windows 8 x64 Newport, South Wales, UK |
I am also against the inclusion of the Ask toolbar - which is why I never choose to install it | My System Specs | | Computer type PC/Desktop System Manufacturer/Model Number Real World Computing (Me + a little help from Acer) OS Windows 7 Ultimate x64 + x86 + Windows 8 x64 CPU AMD Phenom II X6 1035T 2.6 GHz Motherboard Aspire M3400 Memory 4Gb PC10600 DDR3 1333 MHz Graphics Card NVIDIA GeForce 315 512MB Sound Card OnBoard - Realtek High Definition Audio Monitor(s) Displays Philips 32" HDTV, (HDMI) + 26" TV (VGA) Screen Resolution 1920 x 1080 @60Hz + 1360 x 768 @60Hz Keyboard Microsoft Wireless 800 or Stock Acer, (depends where I sit) Mouse Microsoft Wireless 800 or Stock Acer, (depends where I sit) PSU Stock (400W) Case Acer M3400 Cooling Stock Hard Drives 500 GB Seagate ST3500418AS SATA II
1 TB Hitachi HDS5C1010CLA382 SATAII
1 TB Samsung Spinpoint F1 HD103SI SATA II (external)
Plus various other (client ) HDDs as needed Internet Speed Temporaray 3G Dongle Antivirus Avast Browser Chrome Other Info USB Capture + Webcam(s) Bamboo Digitizer tablet
Also run Acer AspireOne 530h Netbook, Dual Core Atom + 1GB (Win7 Ult x86) Plus various test systems for new projects Dark side of COMODO... problems? All times are GMT -5. The time now is 05:41 AM. | |