Third party themes are not being applied completely

I'm going nuts trying to figure this out. First, I'm running Windows 7 Ultimate SP1 64-bit on a new Asus G75VW. I've had a few systems that run the same version of Windows, and on all of them I've used the Unsigned Themes Service (UxStyle Core) to use third party themes. My problem is that on my new system the themes are being applied only partially.

On my last system, I used UxStyle Core and it worked perfectly. The themes I used may not have been created perfectly, but I was happy. On my new system I can use 3rd party themes, but most applications (like Photoshop, Notepad++, etc.) and some Windows apps seem to be using the Win 2000 styles for parts of their UI. The best way I can illustrate this is with a screenshot, which I've attached. The Old System screenshot looks good to me, but the New System shot shows how Notepad++ is using the classic style for its open dialog. The same app on my old system (same version exactly) uses the 3rd party theme's styling (Gaia09).

I've uninstalled and reinstalled UxStyle, tried using the Universal Theme Patcher (x86 and x64), manually copied the patched system files from my old system to my new one, ran SFC /scannow to replace patched system files with the originals, etc., etc.

After completely removing UxStyle, and using non-patched system files, some apps STILL use the Win 2000 style for parts of their UI. Out of frustration, I also tried using TuneUp Utilities and WindowBlinds. But no matter what I do, the same thing is happening.

Can anyone please help?

Thanks for replying! First, here's a link to the VS:

Gaia09 VS for Seven 2 by ~jg-visuals on deviantART

Unfortunately, the issue shows up no matter what 3rd party VS I use - I've tried dozens of them.

I apologize for not providing a clearer explanation in the screenshot of what I was talking about. I've attached a new shot that points out the specific UI elements I'm talking about.

I knew that the Adobe apps use their own UI, but even on my old system those same apps used 3rd party theming for buttons & controls in their open/save dialog windows. On my new system, they default to the classic theme styling.

I have a feeling that this is a problem unrelated to 3rd party themes, because if I revert the system to pre-patching and just use the standard Aero theme, the same thing happens.

I ran the utility and it came back with zero issues. I also thought that maybe the Aero theme itself got corrupted somehow (yeah, a stretch), so I copied the one from my old system to the new one, but no luck.

OK, I stopped and started the service per your instructions. No dice.

As far as the screenshot goes, they're from two different laptops. The old one is the laptop where the themes work properly.

I see what you mean about them being different, and that's part of my problem - on the old laptop, most applications would use the Windows open/save dialog with the navigation pane on the left. On my new laptop, the same apps that I have installed on the old system don't use the dialog with the navigation pane. They use this other dialog that only shows the places bar on the left.

Not to beat this thing to death, but I included another shot of the standard Windows Notepad app on both systems. It doesn't seem to be limited to 3rd party apps.

I actually did quite a few operations. Here's the history of my attempts:

1) Ran Universal Theme Patcher (both x64 and x86)
2) Rebooted
3) Applied 3rd party theme = theme worked but the problem showed up
4) Ran UTP again and restored the patched files (x64 and x86)
5) Rebooted
6) Repeated steps 1-3 = theme worked but same problem
7) Ran SFC /scannow from elevated command prompt
8) Rebooted
9) Applied standard Aero theme = theme worked but problem persisted
10) Copied patched themeservice.dll, themeui.dll, uxtheme.dll and explorer.exe files from my old laptop to my new one (from System32 and SysWOW64) - backed up the originals first
11) Rebooted
12) Applied 3rd party theme = theme worked but problem persisted
13) Removed patched files and replaced with the original backups
14) Rebooted
15) Applied standard Aero theme = theme worked but problem persisted
16) Installed Unsigned Themes service
17) Rebooted
18) Applied 3rd party theme = theme worked, but problem still there

After that point I sought your help.