Windows 7 Forums
Welcome to Windows 7 Forums. Our forum is dedicated to helping you find support and solutions for any problems regarding your Windows 7 PC be it Dell, HP, Acer, Asus or a custom build. We also provide an extensive Windows 7 tutorial section that covers a wide range of tips and tricks.

Windows 7: Ownership of foreign files - XP vs 7P access issues

19 Apr 2016   #11

Windows 10, Windows 8.1 Pro, Windows 7 Professional, OS X El Capitan

Quote   Quote: Originally Posted by tns1 View Post
Had I instead first added the BUILTIN entities under XP, and then initiated a copy FROM 7P, would I have achieved the exact results?
Yes. As I’ve mentioned, copying a file doesn’t copy the permissions with it. This means if you randomly copy any two files from two distinct locations to the same location, the copies will have identical permissions, regardless of what the original files’ permissions where.

Quote   Quote: Originally Posted by tns1 View Post
Since these files were initially 'copied' to XP (downloaded or transfered from media), using the same acct, are sitting in the same location, and were never post edited, why do they not have the same access properties?
My answer to the ‘why’ version of this question is no different to the ‘how’. I don’t know, and I don’t have an answer to this.

Quote   Quote: Originally Posted by tns1 View Post
WRT modifying access permissions, is a cut & paste different from a copy & paste, or move operation?
If you move a file to a new location, if any, the explicit permissions assigned to the object will follow it to its new location, unlike a copy operation which does not. In this instance, cutting and pasting is similar to a move operation.

Quote   Quote: Originally Posted by tns1 View Post
If this is all basic stuff, is there a summary tutorial or set of exercises I could read?
By no means would I consider the topic of NTFS permissions basic, especially when the reality is that many users, even seasoned gurus, do not know how to use the feature, with many favouring tools such as as a substitute for learning all there is to know about Windows’ distinctly involved permissions system. Although in saying that, I should be careful about exaggerating it's difficulty. NTFS permissions is not too difficult of a concept to grasp, and it shouldn't be. But far too many people often like to get the facts wrong, sparing correctness for simplicity, reusing the misleading jingle—“you need to take ownership of that/those file(s) to access them”—which only demonstrates their misunderstanding of how access control is enforced under Windows, and thereafter misleading people to believe that the reason for their access issues is solely based upon ownership.
Quote   Quote: Originally Posted by tns1 View Post
After reading similar posts, this seems to be a common ownership problem that causes much frustration.
If you wish to learn to properly deal with access denied issues under Windows, erase everything you know about permissions, ownership, etc., and start here. Even better than reading, explore the consequences of certain permission configurations by testing out some different situations on your own, and you will very quickly appreciate the security model Microsoft has chosen for their industry-dominating operating systems.

My System SpecsSystem Spec
19 Apr 2016   #12

Windows 7 pro 64-bit sp 1

I wouldn't worry about ownership of a file on either system and in fact I would leave that be. Just because your user is the same name on each system doesn't mean that you will be the owner on the other system, if you change it. The inverse is true actually since all user accounts have a unique identifier which likely differs on each system. As a result if you where to change ownership of a file on one system the other system will report that the owner is unknown hence my recommendation not to change it. Now a way around that would be to change your identifier on one system to match the other however that will break your profile unless you change every registry entry and every system file that references it. The best thing that you can do would be to grant your account access to the files/folders in question on both systems. Now if it where me I would create another partition and store the files on that partition granting yourself access within each system. An alternative would be to have that partition be fat32. That would bypass the permissions issue since fat32 doesn't use ntfs permissions.
My System SpecsSystem Spec

 Ownership of foreign files - XP vs 7P access issues

Thread Tools

Similar help and support threads
Thread Forum
Issues Transferring Ownership Of Old HDD Via USB Enclosure
So ive been having a very frustrating week trying to get info off of my old drive. Im currently running Windows 7 Ultimate x64 on my new SSD. What happened was about 2 weeks ago I started noticing signs of my drive failing. I had most everything backed up but not my app data and other user folders...
Hardware & Devices
Permission not granted to access files even after taking ownership
I have a 250gb hard drive from an old PC that has ALOT of pictures ,videos, and music stored on. The PC was running Window XP. It died and I removed the hard drive and bought an enclosure to install it in. I have it hooked to a newer PC running Windows 7. At 1st when I pulled up the folders with...
General Discussion
Ownership issues, restricted access and pure frustration.
Hello, so I'm currently writing on a laptop which is owned by a company. It's my dad's laptop and he asked me to install certain programs he needs for his work which are on multiple CDs. Even before he asked me I tried installing an antivirus and I couldn't because the access was denied. I let...
General Discussion
Windows files, folders and drive ownership issues!
So I formatted my system today and did a clean install of Windows 8 and now my USB storage drive says cannot access. I remember vaguely adding permissions or taking ownership to the files when I was on Win 7 but dont remember what it is I did exactly. I was trying to hide my files from other users...
General Discussion
Took ownership, but still no access??
I got a problem, after i click take ownership, nothing happens i still doesn't have access to that file
General Discussion

Our Sites

Site Links

About Us

Find Us

Windows 7 Forums is an independent web site and has not been authorized, sponsored, or otherwise approved by Microsoft Corporation. "Windows 7" and related materials are trademarks of Microsoft Corp.

© Designer Media Ltd

All times are GMT -5. The time now is 22:19.
Twitter Facebook Google+