New
#31
Sounds like hardware. Does it do the same start problem/black screen with any installation (ie did you try booting a recovery disk or the original recovery disks). If so that rules out software/cloning/usb anomalies.
In my (not very great!) experience, when Motherboards go they tend to just go - rather than slowly fail. Could be the cmos or a faulty connection.
Having said that - had a Sony Vaio once that had some very restrictive firmware either in the bios or on the motherboard. It refused to boot or run when the hard drive was changed. After seeking advice from Sony I was informed that machine would only work with the exact same hard drive (ie same size same sata i) - and that proved to be the case. I bought a reconditioned sata i hard drive the same size and everything loaded fine. Prior to that I couldn't even load the manufacturer recovery disks.
So - if you haven't changed the hard drive, I'd also suggest, as above, trying to boot from a dvd - the recovery disks maybe. And see what happens.