New
#21
My personal preference is Asus, Gigabyte and Intel. I've owned multiple boards from all of them and have had good track records. The only one I ever had a problem with was a gigabyte, and after about 7 years, one of the IDE controllers onboard simply crapped out. I put in an IDE card and it went a few more years before I retired the box.
With any product, I look at the reviews. But I don't put much faith in the reviews that give it 1 star and say "Absolutely garbage, etc". Especially with something like hard drives. It seems some people have tons of bad hard drive after hard drive after hard drive. But yet, I simply cannot remember the last physical hard drive that actually failed on me. And I've gone through lots of hard drives over the years at work as well as at home. They are often replaced as they became too small, or too slow.
I've used Biostar mobos without problems. Friends of mine are currently using MSI boards on new Sandy Bridge setups without any issue. I've had other friends who used DFI boards. While I have heard of ASRock, I don't know anybody personally who has used one.