The big HDD poll!

Samsung for me.

After installing several hundreds of HDD's in peoples system's and my own, I can say a few things about HDD's.

1. Maxtor = cr*p 80% of them never make it past the 2nd yr, and too much of them were DOA. Further more they are noisy, and energy inefficient.
Performance is good.

2. WD has been on a downhill slope in the race with Maxtor, until last year.
Same story, too many failing disks.
The new generation seems to be a lot more solid, and a lot quieter and energy efficient. If they are build to last, is yet to be proven.
Performance is excellent.

3. Seagate is a strange brand. Some series perform excellent and last long, other series are utter cr*p. The problem is you don't know in advance which series will do good. They are generally very quiet, and averagely energy efficient.

4. Hitachi is a solid, quiet, energy efficient, good lasting quality, but a bit of an underachiever. They clearly chose for durability over speed.
They do have some noisy series but most are very quiet.

5. Fujitsu. Very durable, quiet and efficient, but like Hitachi it is slow.

6. Samsung: My personal favorite and number one in any discipline.
I have clients that still have the drive I build into their system 7 yrs ago.
Samsung has the highest MTBF and I have yet to see one fail within 5 yrs, they are very quiet, very fast, averagely energy efficient, they do get quite warm, but they can take it. Some 1TB models have an annoying high frequency noise when booting, but they quiet down to almost unhearable after the bios post.
And last but not least, they are the cheapest disks around.


Nuance:

DOA's are not uncommon among any brand.
Normally one in every ten thousand disks will fail at first boot.
One in every ten thousand will fail before the 2nd yr is over.

But I had four of my own ten Maxtor's fail right after the first year, and another two were DOA.
And about 15% of my clients Maxtors failed right after the first year.
About 10% of those were DOA.

None of my clients ever had a Samsung fail within 5 yrs.

So, I guess I'm a bit biased.

Corpsecrank said:

Interesting to hear that samsung works so well. Most of the hitachi drives I see fail are in laptops I should have mentioned that.

But a DOA I can forgive in most cases. At least there was no data on the drive and it can easily be replaced.

What really ticks me off is having a drive for just past the 30 day mark and then having it fail because when you send it back you always get a refurbished unit in return. After 30 days they are no longer obligated to replace the unit with a new one they can send a repaired drive which is never as good and does not have a full warranty.

For exactly that reason I buy HDD's and most of my hardware in a local shop with nice people that know me, instead of online.

I get the hardware for just a little more than the online price, and if it fails within a period of 24 months I get a new one, not refurbished, no sending to factory, and no hassle.

I'm willing to pay the extra 5% for such great service, and to keep my local retailer alive.

WD and samsung for me.

WD since seagate drives started dying on me. 5 DOA in 9 months

am i the first hitachi deathstar user?

it's nothing fancy, but it does the job, and will continue doing so for years to come...

(i hope )