Windows 7 Forums
Welcome to Windows 7 Forums. Our forum is dedicated to helping you find support and solutions for any problems regarding your Windows 7 PC be it Dell, HP, Acer, Asus or a custom build. We also provide an extensive Windows 7 tutorial section that covers a wide range of tips and tricks.

Windows 7: HD: Reliability Of Different Brands/Models ?

16 May 2015   #1

Windows 7 64bit
HD: Reliability Of Different Brands/Models ?


Regarding a new 1 TB External HD.

There seem to be a zillion different reliability surveys out there.
You folks are the real experts, so let me ask here:

Is there any consensous as to which Brand and Model is considered "the best" regarding reliability for
an external 1 TB (or 1.5 TB perhaps) HD.

Really confusing knowing which to get.

My Seagate, with very minimal use, lasted only about 3 yrs.
Was only used for backing up, (once every week or two) and unplugged the rest of the time.
Quite disappointing.


My System SpecsSystem Spec
16 May 2015   #2


Yep, I have had bad luck with the last 2 Seagates I have bought, one was a 2TB and the other 3TB. The 2TB lasted about 14 months, the 3TB (both only used as a backup) only lasted about 8 months, then fried itself, yet I have 2 WD 1TB that have lasted with no probs for 3-4 years, and 1 has games installed on it.

Next week I am buying 2 new HDD's both WD a 3TB & 4TB, then 2 weeks later a Samsung 120GB 850 Evo, for my windows drive as I only use about 75GB as it is, all my other stuff is on other drives.
My System SpecsSystem Spec
16 May 2015   #3

Microsoft Community Contributor Award Recipient

Windows 7 Home Premium SP1, 64-bit

Quote   Quote: Originally Posted by Robert11 View Post

Is there any consensous as to which Brand and Model is considered "the best" regarding reliability for
an external 1 TB (or 1.5 TB perhaps) HD.
In a word, no.

There is a semi-authoritative study from Backblaze regarding failure rates for the thousands of drives they maintain in their data centers, but as I recall it pertains to drives of larger sizes--2 TB on up. For what it's worth, Seagates were clearly at the bottom, with Hitachi at the top. Western Digital in second place.

There is a similar study from Google, but it's probably 10 years old and outdated.

You will find endless comments to the effect of "I've been using brand X and never had a problem" or "I'd never use another brand Y because 3 of the 5 I've owned failed within 2 years", etc. Such comments are purely anecdotal and do you no good at all.

I'd instead think of stuff like:

Ease of RMA directly to the vendor if the drive was DOA or failed within 30 days
Ease of return directly to the manufacturer if the drive failed at a later time
Warranty length to the extent you'd even consider returning a drive that had your personal data on it.
Speed (this wouldn't be a primary concern for me)
Google for anecdotal evidence of possible design defects or other shortcomings in your candidates

Google to get a general idea of the manufacturer's attitude toward customer service. Some are so disdainful and difficult to deal with that I'd never buy anything from them, despite the products being attractive from a price and performance standpoint. If you have to deal with customer service for ANY reason, you may wish you had bought another brand.

Expect them all to fail at the worst possible time and situate yourself in such a way that it doesn't matter beyond a bit of aggravation and the cost of a replacement (read: multiple backups).
My System SpecsSystem Spec

16 May 2015   #4
Mellon Head

Win 7 Pro x64/Win 10 Pro x64 dual boot

In addition to wholeheartedly agreeing with ignatatsonic's advice, I would just add that I all drives will fail. It's a question of when. Backup, backup, and backup again.
My System SpecsSystem Spec

 HD: Reliability Of Different Brands/Models ?

Thread Tools

Similar help and support threads
Thread Forum
Can i Mix RAMs with different Brands?
Hi, I am planning to upgrade my PC RAM. I currently have a 2 GB RAM. Details below ADATA A3U1333C2G9-R DDR31333(9)2GX8U-DIMM 10242456 Can i add a crossair RAM with 1333 Hz?
Hardware & Devices
Using 2 monitors with 1 GPU. OK to use different 2 GPU brands for each
My video editing software renders much faster with compatible GPUs. I recently upgraded to a nVidia GTX 560 Ti which improved rendering 16%. I've like using two monitors but the second monitor drags down rendering performance of what it could be. I was wondering if using my old GIGABYTE Radeon HD...
Graphic Cards
Good SSD Brands to buy?
Im looking for an SSD, At least 60Gb, mainly just for the OS because i heard it speeds up your computer, Are there any recommended brands for SSD's that you guys would be willing to share? Thanks.
Hardware & Devices
Anyone recommend brands of motherboard
Anyone recommend a brand of motherboard they usually go with, AMD AM3 that support amd phenom II x6 cpus? I was looking at this ASrock 870 extreme3 I hear people with good reviews but not very great at O.Cing but I like Japanese made Items that's probably why im siding with them and its only 99-109...
Hardware & Devices
how do the brands stack up?
i suppose this is more of an opinion. i was just wondering how the different computer brands stack up to each other in terms of reliability. just take each of them as an all-in-one type of computer and see how they stack up ya know. right now im using an acer and ive had it for about 3 years...
General Discussion

Our Sites

Site Links

About Us

Find Us

Windows 7 Forums is an independent web site and has not been authorized, sponsored, or otherwise approved by Microsoft Corporation. "Windows 7" and related materials are trademarks of Microsoft Corp.

Designer Media Ltd

All times are GMT -5. The time now is 02:27.
Twitter Facebook Google+