Windows 7 Forums
Welcome to Windows 7 Forums. Our forum is dedicated to helping you find support and solutions for any problems regarding your Windows 7 PC be it Dell, HP, Acer, Asus or a custom build. We also provide an extensive Windows 7 tutorial section that covers a wide range of tips and tricks.

Windows 7: NAS woes - why Windows 7 had me then lost me

17 Jan 2010   #1

Windows 7
NAS woes - why Windows 7 had me then lost me

Although I'm not an IT expert I am tech-literate having been an electronics engineer (microprocessor systems) and a user of MS OS's from Dos 3.<something>... thats atenure of over 20 years from a time when IT was not mainstream and there was a reason why I would spend a lot of my time studying the manuals and datasheets so the PC add-in cards I designed would work.

Fastforward to 2009:
I successfully (and in hindsight - gratefully) resisted the upgrade from XP to Vista however, in November 2009 when the HDD on my (home/personal) Dell Inspiron died I decided to clean install Win 7 professional 32 bit flavour - especially as the press had been remarkably good. First impressions were very good - fast and simple install... easy to setup home network and Internet etc. etc. Being a disaffected MicroSoft user (I have spent a great deal of my life fixing drivers, messing around with non-intuitive application software - in short a lot of time being unproductive with the so-called productivity tools) I felt myself warming to them with the positive experience I was having with Win 7. At last an OS that was doing (no more or no less) than what I expected from it. Indeed, I rushed out (figuratively speaking) and bought a copy for my wife's PC whilst I was in the MicroSoft happy place I'd never seen before. But it has been short-lived... normal service has been resumed. It started when I tried to connect a NAS drive to my homegroup network... I was not expecting any issues as the drive had been working without problem on the XP/Vista networked PC setup legacy I had... and now, all of a sudden, I feel like I am back in the late eighties again.

Despite the power of the Internet I am unable to find a solution to my woes... and - having sifted through the may forums containing similar issues with different manufacturers etc. - so are many others with their NAS connection problems too. I've descended into the depths of the security settings, reformatted the drive to the less-secure FAT32... even bought a new NAS chassis to put the Samsung disk into as I felt the Freecom enclosure could be problematic... but still I have only reached partial satisfaction:
  • I can configure the drive via its IP address.
  • I can FTP to and from the drive.
  • I can see it listed on the network... but when I try and connect to it Win 7 tells me "<my drive> is not accessible. You might not have permission... blah blah blah. The network address is invalid"
I was able to connect to it once - this gave me a foolish sense of hope and optimism that I was just on the cusp of a solution. This was from the time prior to my wife's PC being upgraded from Vista. I managed to do this with a checky trick suggested in one of the forums; I created a short-cut in Vista and dropped it on my Win 7 desktop... it worked... hoorah! Well, at least until the re-boot... a repeat of the process did not yield the same result... Whilst I was in a cheeky frame of mind I thought I'd drop the short-cut into IE 8 to see what it would do with it... suspense filled the air... but not for long... I was astonished when it trashed all my applications (I don't know why - they had done nothing to IE 8!) and I had to revert to a previously known good state (to be fair, I think this is a good feature in Win 7).

And so to where I am today - the brief honeymoon is over and I am now returning to my disaffected state with MS. I find it astonishing that something as simple as hooking up a NAS has reverted to complexity and despair itself... on the plus side, I have discovered that I can control my PC from my iPod Touch whilst trying to solve this (and it works).

So, once again I am miffed... it appears that to use MicroSoft products you need to first take the advanced degree in MicroSoft... will they ever learn that consumers want something good, simple and functional? I expect a little flirting with the technology but I am now beyond nice-guy... Grrr... Come on Google, come on Apple - come on anybody else - hurry up and slay the dinosaur - they've been bland, boring and stealing my life for long enough.

Alas no response is required to this post... it's sent to let those who are feeling the same why I do that you're not alone... don't despair... it doesn't really matter... life is far more precious... I've wasted enough of my life on this and many other accumulations of MS related problems... this time I'll just take the easy (less sophisticated and satisfying) route of swapping the USB cable over between the PC's I want to backup once a week... I reckon the effort involved is likely to be a lot less and my emotional well-being will return to normal levels.

My soul is healed.

No MicroSoft staff were harmed in the production of this posting.

My System SpecsSystem Spec
17 Jan 2010   #2

Windows 7 Ultimate RTM

Before you give up, you might want to review this posting on Technet that may help you solve the problem:

Problems with folder sharing. Four PC's; PC's 1,2,3 can all access shared folder contents on PC 4; with any other as target, remaining three can see shared folder but not open it.

Good luck.

Jim Pickering
My System SpecsSystem Spec

 NAS woes - why Windows 7 had me then lost me

Thread Tools

Similar help and support threads
Thread Forum
Windows 7 Library Woes
I have recently purchased a new internal hard drive for my desktop computer, and have moved my Photos, Music and Videos across to it. I've redirected the windows libraries to the appropriate folders on the new drive. All is working fine, apart from the fact that when viewing a library and arranging...
General Discussion
Windows 7 woes
I am not really sure where to post this, but my .dmp files are pointing to a driver issue, so this is probably as good a place to start as any. Approx 3 months ago, I purchased the hardware to build a new system, and did my homework first to make sure it would all be compatible. I got all the...
BSOD Help and Support
Windows 7 Wireless Woes
Hello, I have: - 2 desktop PCs (1 wired, 1 wireless) Wired: Win7 x64 Wireless: Win7 x64 (Realtek 8185L)* - a Netgear WGR614v5 router The router connects to a DSL modem for internet. My wired PC was upgraded from WinXP to Win7 a few months ago and has been perfectly fine. But...
Network & Sharing
Windows 7 Woes
Hi guys, I have been lurking these forums for a while and this I must say is one of my favourite sites. Now, Since a lot of you are using an RTM version, I just wanted to ask if most of you see the same issues as I do with 7 1) I often see a lot of Hive issues in the event viewer...
General Discussion
Lost Dual Boot Screen?...Lost Windows 7
I have Vista Home Premium 64 bit and I downloaded 64 Bit RC Windows 7 and did a clean install on another partition of my hard drive. Dual boot was working for about 4 days then all of a sudden it doesnt come up any more. The partition is still there with Windows 7 installed on it but its not...
General Discussion

Our Sites

Site Links

About Us

Find Us

Windows 7 Forums is an independent web site and has not been authorized, sponsored, or otherwise approved by Microsoft Corporation. "Windows 7" and related materials are trademarks of Microsoft Corp.

Designer Media Ltd

All times are GMT -5. The time now is 14:31.
Twitter Facebook Google+ Seven Forums iOS App Seven Forums Android App