CPU-Z pics: A-Data vs Corsair mem in my rig: pls advise

@ VulcanSoulPatch,

To clearify, 1- If you're going to run 8gig of RAM by populating all RAM slots, than yes, you might not be able to run at "1600" however like everyting in life there are trade off's. In this case you have more memory, but lower frequency. Now, to be honest, 8gig at 1066 or 1333 isn't going to be that much slower than 4gig at 1600. Benchies may see it, but real world probably won't.

One word of caution I will put out is matching your memory. You will very well want to make sure your memory is matched. That's why most manufactures sell kits...becaus they're matched!!!

If you really want to get a grasp on memory and tweaks and stull like that visit here - The Corsair Support Forums - Powered by vBulletin. They have a wealth of knowledge. In fact, a lot of stuff I've mentioned, I got from them. I'm also a registered member there.

Again, I've never heard of A-Data but I can vouch for Corsair and their tech support, customer service, and their forums.

Hope this helps.

Thanks sygnus and NoN. I have checked to see if I can by the exact same model number as what I have. I read that it was OEM mem that Corsair sold to system builders, so I was only able to find it at one place sold in singles: TechNPS. They only have 4 ratings on ResellerRatings, and the last one was bad, but it could be worth a shot for the matched mem. Only downside is I would have to pay both tax and shipping since they are in Nor Cal, which bumps the price up to ~$190 for 2x2GB. Every other place that I have found that sells them list exorbitant prices in addition to being OOS. Not sure why that is. I am guessing I could try to find a more modern set, but I realize that I won't be able to take advantage of any higher bandwidth or tighter timings they may have (weakest link theory, right?).

OK, onto the good stuff. I went ahead and enabled XMP mode in my BIOS. First thing I noticed was that when disabled the memory was in 1066 mode, and enabled it jumped to the 1600 mode that was anticipated. Here are the results:


As you can see, the frequency has now jumped from ~545MHz up to ~800MHz, which was to be expected. The CAS has increased to 9-9-9-24, also as expected. The only disconcerting thing is that the tRFC is now way up at 88 clocks, tho I don't know if that is to be worried about too much.

And now, the best part, the new winsat mem bench:


Nearly 19GB/s... niiiiiice. Well, at least to me.

So, given this info, now where do we stand? I know sygnus and Wishmaster have supported the Corsair since the beginning, so I am guess this will only strengthen their position. Rhammstein, does this change your thoughts on the A-Data? Or is the idea of adding 4GB more and not being able to hit 1600 make the A-Data a better investment?

VSP

sygnus, regarding the matched sets... were you referring to making sure I buy 2 matched 2GB sticks, or that the 2x2GB that I buy be matched with the 2x2GB I already have? If it is the former, than I could get these for almost $50 less AR. Like I mentioned, I most likely won't be able to take advantage of the lower CAS, but they are cheaper than the CAS 9s available.

BTW, know anything about the difference between the CMD and CMP prefixes on the Dominator memory (last two items at the bottom of the page)? Does it indicate the version or manufacture date or anything?

VSP

@ Non - CAS7's are expensive compared to CAS9; all things being equal of course.

And bear in mind that even those sticks say 1333MHz; he still may be limited to 1066MHz or lower, if he fills all DIMM slots with memory. That's because some motherboards cannot run the memory at full frequency with all DIMM slot populated. And some users manual will have some cryptic way of saying this, or not. Example – My manual says my motherboard says in can support up to 24GB of memory. In the next bullet it says can support DDR3 2200/1333/1066/800 memory modules.

Now, we can infer that that means the board supports up to 24GB running at 2200MHz…well???

Read the owner's manual!

PS, I kept saying I've never heard of A-Data, well now I have - A-Data DDR3-2200+ DRAM XPG Plus 2.0 review. Nice sticks!

VulcanSoulPatch said:

sygnus, regarding the matched sets... were you referring to making sure I buy 2 matched 2GB sticks, or that the 2x2GB that I buy be matched with the 2x2GB I already have?

Get a matched kit. Example, if you want 8gig, get a 4x2 kit, not two 2x2 kits!

VulcanSoulPatch said:

BTW, know anything about the difference between the CMD and CMP prefixes on the Dominator memory (last two items at the bottom of the page)? Does it indicate the version or manufacture date or anything?

I can't say I do. Visit Corsair's website here - F.A.Q. - The Corsair Support Forums

VulcanSoulPatch said:

As you can see, the frequency has now jumped from ~545MHz up to ~800MHz, which was to be expected. The CAS has increased to 9-9-9-24, also as expected. The only disconcerting thing is that the tRFC is now way up at 88 clocks, tho I don't know if that is to be worried about too much

Your memory is running in peak performance. Don't worry about the 88 clocks thing. As for the A-Data sticks, remember I said you could "manually" set them to see if they'll run at the same speed as the Dominators. It's just that you can't do them "Auto" like you did with the Doms. i.e. set them to XMP because they son't support it.

Good luck.

Gotcha, well I am stuck with 2x2GB of whichever I choose now. For a premium (and I do mean PREMIUM), I can purchase another 2x2GB from the builder and it would most likely be the same stock. For the Doms the fee would be ~$235 ATM. This is not desirable at all. So, if I want to run 8GB total, I will have to add a 2x2GB kit to what I already have, since I can't flat out refuse and get refunded the money for the mem they included with the system. Would be nice, since all told it would reduce my cost to <$100 over what I already paid them to get the extra 4GB of memory at today's prices.

BTW, what do you think about the new winsat mem score I posted above?

VSP

Thanks for the FAQ link. D = Dominator, P = Dominator "but with something added"...
Sounds mysterious. Will have to look into that more later.

VSP

I would have to agree with what Rhammstein is saying about saving a dollar or two. If A-Data is a reputable company and have quality RAM for a respectable price, save a dollar or two and go for it.

However you need to know that the Corsair Dominators are in a different class than those A-Data sticks, just as the Corsair Dominators are in a different class than the Corsair XMS3 memory sticks.

So, if you interested in tweaking/overclocking/performance, the dominators have the edge there. If that's not you cup of tea, the A-Data's will work just fine. In that respect, Rhammstein is correct; it all comes down to budget and performance needs.

BTW, the article I pointed when I said I now heard of A-Data says they make good RAM, at least the sticks the article is talking about. If they were a "cheap" company, I don’t think those would be under review

sygnus21 said:

PS, I kept saying I've never heard of A-Data, well now I have - A-Data DDR3-2200+ DRAM XPG Plus 2.0 review. Nice sticks!

Good luck on your decision.