Windows 7 Forums

Welcome to Windows 7 Forums. Our forum is dedicated to helping you find support and solutions for any problems regarding your Windows 7 PC be it Dell, HP, Acer, Asus or a custom build. We also provide an extensive Windows 7 tutorial section that covers a wide range of tips and tricks.


Windows 7: Ed Bott confirms Upgrade clean install w/o prior OS

27 Oct 2009   #1
gregrocker

 
Ed Bott confirms Upgrade clean install w/o prior OS

Finally, some answers to Windows 7 upgrade questions

Better late than never. We had these hashed out in the sticky on the first night!



Following Brink's tutorial, I used the Upgrade disk to do a formatted clean install from boot, which activated first time. I wanted to confirm that the installer is reading a previous OS from the boot mode on the disk.

So I zeroed HDD on a laptop and tried to install from boot, but this time the key was rejected and activation was refused after it went online - I had to do the old VIsta "upgrade over upgrade" (repair install) again from the desktop to get it to take the key and activate. *edit: see Paul Thurrot's fix here: http://www.winsupersite.com/win7/cle...rade_media.asp

I think this means that it obviously can't read the prior OS on HDD when zeroed, but can read a previous OS on formatted HDD, probably as it is scanning the drive early on BEFORE formatting.

As far as why the "upgrade over upgrade" works as a last resort, perhaps MS allows the "upgrade over upgrade" to activate just with the presence of a prior OS (the first upgrade) and not prior activation because such a "Repair Install" is also needed to fix the OS. So they liberalize the activation by allowing any working Upgrade key.


My System SpecsSystem Spec
.
27 Oct 2009   #2
pparks1

Windows 7 Ultimate x64
 
 

There was a typo in the link to the winsupersite that you posted, so I have reposted the link here;
http://www.winsupersite.com/win7/cle...rade_media.asp
My System SpecsSystem Spec
27 Oct 2009   #3
gregrocker

 

Quote   Quote: Originally Posted by pparks1 View Post
There was a typo in the link to the winsupersite that you posted, so I have reposted the link here;
http://www.winsupersite.com/win7/cle...rade_media.asp
Thanks, fixed it!
My System SpecsSystem Spec
.

27 Oct 2009   #4
Barman58

Windows 10 Pro x64 x2 Windows 10 Enterprise x64, Ubuntu
 
 

Reading through the comments was fun

The particular one I liked was from Brandon LeBlanc pointing to his blog of the 24th September ....

Moving to Windows 7 FAQ - Windows 7 Team Blog - The Windows Blog

Late again Ed
My System SpecsSystem Spec
27 Oct 2009   #5
Nosmo

Win 7 32 bit , Win xp Sp3
 
 

gregrocker,
I am still not 100%on some of this 'Upgrade' inner workings.. From your tests it seems that the Win 7 installer can sniff out evidence of a prior install, somewhere on the computer, even on another drive or partition. You mention I believe formatting and it still saw enough to allow activation.

So how are users with upgrade keys booting and installing on virgin drives that have never had an OS, and being able to activate and have their upgrade key accepted when entered at the beginning or end of the install process.


I have difficulty in believing MS designed it this way. Are they just allowing any key to work for now and then in 6 months , some users will get de activated.
My System SpecsSystem Spec
27 Oct 2009   #6
pparks1

Windows 7 Ultimate x64
 
 

I think that everybody is just worrying too much about this.

I think for once, Microsoft made a change that made things a little easier on the consumer. I think they kept it quiet as to be a nice surprise when it finally hit the marketplace.

I think Microsoft has found that if they make the cheaper versions "just work" in most cases....that people who would have otherwise just downloaded a hacked version of it, might instead just pay the money and get legit.

The important part to Microsoft is that you purchased something, they made a profit and you have a legit key. And really, with the domination of the marketplace by Microsoft...how many people out there really aren't qualified or otherwise entitled to an upgrade version of Windows.

It's been documented and it's been discussed. Ed Bott says it works, Paul Thurrott says it works, I've seen it work, Brink has documented that it works. It just works. And just like the double vista install method, it's going to continue working as well.
My System SpecsSystem Spec
27 Oct 2009   #7
Nosmo

Win 7 32 bit , Win xp Sp3
 
 

I spent some time on this site the other day.
Windows XP Genuine Advantage Validation Issues (Windows XP) Forum
People who have had their computers working fine for 3 and 4 years are now
being rejected in MgA Validation. MS has tightened up severely in the last few months and it is amazing to see how many users still have pirated keys.

I just wonder down the road why MS would allow users that have no OS to upgrade, install an upgrade key , have it activated. Not like MS at all.

My System SpecsSystem Spec
27 Oct 2009   #8
gregrocker

 

Well they claimed they were foreclosing with Win7 the method no-prior-OS upgrades are achieved via the Vista "upgrade over upgrade" trick.

I believe this works because it sees the first install underneath and allows activation based on a prior qualifying install.

Technet has said this is because this method of upgrading is also used to Repair the computer and therefore needs to allow the simple presence of an OS to pass flag to activating a valid Upgrade key. Elsewise, no prior OS = no flag passed.

But having Paul THurrot's registry fix that does the same thing being widely disseminated surely challenges them, so I am keeping all of my prevous disks and keys backed up in case of a WGA challenge in the future.

That said, I agree with everything pparks1 says about MS contentment with a purchase of the new OS, enough to ease the hoops purchasers need to jump through.
My System SpecsSystem Spec
27 Oct 2009   #9
Barman58

Windows 10 Pro x64 x2 Windows 10 Enterprise x64, Ubuntu
 
 

I always use full install disks so it is not a real issue for me personally but some method of repair/reinstall is I think a necessity.

Also as the function is already coded into the disks in circulation I don't know how MS can tell if the workarounds have been used to get to the stage that activation is possible - unless there are already checking mechanisms which tag this and are currently being ignored, through their choice
My System SpecsSystem Spec
Reply

 Ed Bott confirms Upgrade clean install w/o prior OS




Thread Tools




Similar help and support threads
Thread Forum
Upgrade from XP to Win, clean install on new HD
Greetings, Thanks for all the great info here - very helpful! Getting ready to upgrade from XP Pro to Win 7 Home Premium. In the process, have installed a new, much bigger harddrive to better handle Win7. So, currently, on the same machine I've got my original drive with XP Pro installed,...
Installation & Setup
clean install with upgrade
Is it possible to do a clean install with upgrade version of home premium or ultimate? Meaning format everything first and then use the Windows 7 upgrade dvd to install it from scratch?
Installation & Setup
upgrade or clean install or the two
Bonjour Stiil awaiting my pre ordered Windows 7 For now i think i will try to upgrade from my Vista 64 bits home premium (working well) to Windoews 7 home premium 64 bits because i don't want to reinstall all my softs But if after it seems to have problem with upgrade can i use the same Dvd and...
Installation & Setup
Upgrade or Clean Install?
What is the received wisdom on upgrading from Vista to W7? I have always been in favour of clean installing but is there any advantage in reformatting and clean installing in this instance?
Installation & Setup
Clean Install via Win 7 Upgrade
Great forum. Just found it via Google. Question: I'm currently running Vista Home Premium 32-bit. I'm going to buy Windows 7 Home Premium 32-bit upgrade. I want to do a clean install on a new hard drive I just bought. I'm going to put the current Vista hard drive on SATA 1 The new hard...
Installation & Setup
RC Upgrade ran better & used less HD than Clean Install
I first did a Vista Premium upgrade to Win 7 RC. Loved it. No conflicts...even XP legacy software ran well (unlike with Vista). Didn't even need compatibility mode. Then I thought I'd try a clean install. Install went smoothly, but than my HP C4280 choked a few times before it installed. I...
Installation & Setup


Our Sites

Site Links

About Us

Find Us

Windows 7 Forums is an independent web site and has not been authorized, sponsored, or otherwise approved by Microsoft Corporation. "Windows 7" and related materials are trademarks of Microsoft Corp.

Designer Media Ltd

All times are GMT -5. The time now is 17:19.
Twitter Facebook Google+ Seven Forums iOS App Seven Forums Android App