New
#21
If I may
Guys if I may chime in here,
I have ran into this same sort of thing more than once installing XP and may apply here, you may have a stick of flaky ram I have had this happen and as a diagnostic step removed the ram and tried one stick at a time and then have the installer complete no problem.
I know what your thinking why was it working before and why did the in place upgrade work well that's a good question it must be the way the installer accesses ram during the install process but I have had it happen to me on a working machine so just food for thought maybe run memtest just to see as long as I have been working on computers I have seen a lot of weird stuff.