Windows 7 Forums
Welcome to Windows 7 Forums. Our forum is dedicated to helping you find support and solutions for any problems regarding your Windows 7 PC be it Dell, HP, Acer, Asus or a custom build. We also provide an extensive Windows 7 tutorial section that covers a wide range of tips and tricks.

Windows 7: SSD - To Defrag or not to Defrag

View Poll Results: SSDs should be defragged
True 6 6.59%
False 85 93.41%
Voters: 91. You may not vote on this poll

03 May 2012   #31

Win 7 Home Premium and Win XP/SP3 Home 32 bit (desktop); Win 7 x64 Home Premium (laptop)

Quote   Quote: Originally Posted by Hopalong X View Post
Instead of defragging an SSD it should be allowed to sit idle usually for one hour minimum so the GC (garbage collection) and TRIM will do the cleanup.
Check the manufacturer. Also if you check the manufacturer web site it specifically will say do not defrag.
It also will void the warranty.

Defrag causes excess wear. After defragging the SSD the SSD firmware will put the files right back where it wants them. So the files get moved twice.

No argument intended just pointing out the reason for not doing defrag. Good luck.
Your post got me to check the Plextor warranty and other information (128gb M3 Pro). The warranty is 5 years and there is nothing there or anywhere else about not defragging. So, would you mind documenting your claim for us?

My System SpecsSystem Spec
03 May 2012   #32
Hopalong X

Windows7 Pro 64bit SP-1; Windows XP Pro 32bit

Intel® High Performance Solid State Drive — SSD Frequently Asked Questions
Do I need to defragment my Intel® Mainstream Solid-State Drive (using Windows* Disk Defragmenter* or similar program)?
No. SSD devices, unlike traditional HDDs, see no performance benefit from traditional HDD defragmentation tools. Disable any automatic or scheduled defragmentation utilities for your Intel SSD. Using these tools simply adds unnecessary wear to the SSD.

Also in the owners manual. Warranty I have not found a specific as of yet.

If no mention is made of warranty issue at Plextor okay.
My System SpecsSystem Spec
03 May 2012   #33

Win 7 Home Premium and Win XP/SP3 Home 32 bit (desktop); Win 7 x64 Home Premium (laptop)

There has been increasing note in reviews and discussions like these that the quality of SSDs has improved over time and the initial stricture about wearing them out, such as by defragging, seems to have become less of an issue, if one at all. It's not my field, but that's what I keep seeing.
My System SpecsSystem Spec

03 May 2012   #34
Hopalong X

Windows7 Pro 64bit SP-1; Windows XP Pro 32bit

O&O is one of the top makers of after market defrag software.

Here is their input on the subject.>
My System SpecsSystem Spec
04 May 2012   #35

Win 7 Home Premium and Win XP/SP3 Home 32 bit (desktop); Win 7 x64 Home Premium (laptop)

Thanks for that link. It's getting harder to justify buying an optimizer - not that I have - when all the software can do with SSDs is use what's already there in Win 7 - TRIM.
My System SpecsSystem Spec
04 May 2012   #36
Hopalong X

Windows7 Pro 64bit SP-1; Windows XP Pro 32bit

I did not suggest buying anything.
O&O sells a defrag software and they are telling the would be users to not do so on SSD's.

After reading up on your Plextor besides TRIM it does have a "cleanup" of some sort in the firmware which some manufacturers call GC/garbage collection.
The system needs to sit idle for an hour plus for TRIM and "GC" to work.
Once a week or month or when it seems to be getting sluggish should be sufficient.
Should be no guarantee.

Good luck and enjoy your SSD.
My System SpecsSystem Spec
05 May 2012   #37

Windows 7 Ultimate x64

My vote is that YES, there is a good reason to defrag a SSD drive. While many of the benefits it carries aren't applicable to the nature of SSDs, as you get no gain in speed, there is one benefit: file system recuperation.

Suppose you accidentally delete a file, and want to un-delete it. All programs work by reading the remaining directory entries, then guessing where it was stored on disk all remaining parts. A well known assumption is that the file will be contiguous on disk, and if it's actually not, parts of a recovered file might be corrupted or the file not recoverable or usable at all. By defraging your disk, you assure that the main recovery method remains valid.
Also, if a catastrophic system failure blows up some system areas of the filesystem, recovery software will have an easier time and greater success chance of a proper recover with a fully defragmented system.
My System SpecsSystem Spec
05 May 2012   #38
Hopalong X

Windows7 Pro 64bit SP-1; Windows XP Pro 32bit

Just shoot me.
My System SpecsSystem Spec
05 May 2012   #39

Windows 10 Pro/ Windows 10 Pro Insider

I own 5 SSDs from 3 different manufacturers. None recommend defragging SSDs. There is a reason Windows turns off defrag for SSDs. SSDs write data different than a spinning hard drive. Most, if not all, defragmenting programs are programmed for spinning hard drives and will look at an SSD and think it needs defraging when in fact it does not. Defreag will help a spinning hard drive by putting the data in fewer locations so it can be found easier. SSDs have no moving parts and therefore do not need defragging. Intel's tool box will turn off defrag, Windows will turn it off. There is a reason that happens.
My System SpecsSystem Spec

 SSD - To Defrag or not to Defrag

Thread Tools

Similar help and support threads
Thread Forum
Windows Disk Defrag- Defrag Larger than 64mb?
-Windows Disk Defrag doesn't defrag files larger than 64mb, and performance decreased over time (as well as my VelociRaptor HDD getting Very Noisy!)! - I do like that WDD makes several passes to defrag/consolidate (Manual only, as my buggy ESS AV didn't like auto-defrag!)! I have tried several...
Performance & Maintenance
Auslogics Disk Defrag vs IObit Smart Defrag
Which Defragger do you think is better, because I am trying to decide between the two, but can't decide on one or the other.
Auslogics Defrag vs Win7 built-in Defrag?
Auslogic's Disk Defrag is a free utility. Does anyone know how it compares to Win 7's built in defrag utility? Is it worth downloading over what's already there?
Performance & Maintenance
Does Puran Defrag 7.3 Free work with Windows 7 Defrag disabled ?
I normally set the Disk Defragmenter Task Schedule to DISABLED, and leave the Windows Disk Defragmenter defragsvc set to DISABLED. Will Puran Free be able to safely and fully operate under these conditions, or should I change defragsvc to MANUAL. I occasionally create a Macrium FULL image...
Windows Disk Defrag Doesn't Defrag
Disk defrag stops analyzing at 62% and doesn't go any further. So I downloaded Defraggler and ran it. It worked but it wouldn't defrag down to 0% fragmentation, It still shows 4% after defrag.
Performance & Maintenance

Our Sites

Site Links

About Us

Find Us

Windows 7 Forums is an independent web site and has not been authorized, sponsored, or otherwise approved by Microsoft Corporation. "Windows 7" and related materials are trademarks of Microsoft Corp.

© Designer Media Ltd

All times are GMT -5. The time now is 01:50.
Twitter Facebook Google+