Windows 7 Forums
Welcome to Windows 7 Forums. Our forum is dedicated to helping you find support and solutions for any problems regarding your Windows 7 PC be it Dell, HP, Acer, Asus or a custom build. We also provide an extensive Windows 7 tutorial section that covers a wide range of tips and tricks.

Windows 7: Could This Software Be TOO GOOD TO BE TRUE? Need Your Honest Opinion.

27 Jul 2011   #1

Windows 7 Pro x64 SP1 & Windows 8 & 8.1 Pro x64
Could This Software Be TOO GOOD TO BE TRUE? Need Your Honest Opinion.

Hello. I have a question to ask you that I CANNOT RESOLVE THIS ON MY OWN and I "could" (MAYBE OR MAYBE NOT) ultimately have a software security issue. I am too much on the fence!!!!!

I have installed software as a matter of a free find online, a free version for a good red eye remover. I have the well reviewed Picasa 3 that I recommend for general photo editing, but it is terrible regarding the red eye removal component. I have had several times using it to fix the red eye issues. I used a few other programs that I went ahead and had to install that were reputable and they made a mess of the process or didn't even work well like Picasa 3 -- left part of the red eye in the image. I bet it may be JUST this ONE image I am having issues with, but if there is one with issues correcting red eye; there are bound to be more.

I did some Googling and found a program that is supported by CNet called Red Eye Remover (version 2):;contentBody;5d

Now usually anything that comes from CNet editorial reviews is "typically" trustworthy. Even the user reviews (2 at this time) are giving it very good reviews. (I also notice that CNet has reviewed many of this software company's OTHER products and given it good reviews likewise with users too.) Now, I notice the parent homepage for this software is called VicMan Software. . Yah, first thing I thought is WOW!!! ALL FREE!!! (At the same moment, I also believe that you get what you pay for... ...and... ...if it is too good to be true, it probably is!) They offer MANY decent FREE products that you would normally have to pay for -- DEFINATELY!!! Some of their software programs look pretty advanced, even if they are component parts typically on fully featured on loaded software packages or suites you pay for.

I did download and installed the needed product Red Eye Remover. I used it and it works EXCELLENTLY!!! It solved fixing the red eye in ALL my images!

Now... ...I get that gut feeling after I am done using it, is if I SHOULD keep it on my system or not?!?!? Yah, you got what you wanted out of it, but now the worry begins! I do have WOT installed on several of my browsers that I typically depend on for "safe" websites. I see any product by VicMan Software shows an orange indicator or warning about their software on WOT. I have read the reviews on WOT for this web source. Please see link: . Again, most of these reviews are positive. One poster reports his findings in a matter-of-fact method. Please see link: .

I see VicMan Software website has a forum that appears to be official in some capacity. Please see link: . Also read the "about" here too: . It appears they may be going into the cloud too, please see: in reference from .

So I uninstalled Red Eye Remover v.2 for safely sake. However, I never had an issue while I used it for a few days. It might be a totally clean program or the rest of their program(s). The setup installer EXE tested "negative" for malware per Norton Internet Security and a fully system scan before and after the installation proved "negative" too. I would love to have them, but it all seems to good to be true too!!!

I have provided a lot of links. You can do your own research too.

So what is your conclusion?? Trust or not to trust??? Give your rationale for your inclinations. I am asking for your opinion by looking at the evidence I have provided, if you do or do not trust this program or programs from this developer regardless if you had or not have any prior experience from this developer. Would YOU use their software at face value? know your response is only an educated guess and you will not be held liable for your comments, but I am looking for your best assumptions from what I have provided above.

Please reply.

Thank you!

My System SpecsSystem Spec
27 Jul 2011   #2


Individual user comments can be chancy. Lots of people don't even know what they're looking at and seeing.
The downchecks on the site and it's contents could well be from ignorance.
Cnet has been around for a while, has access to all the same info you do and a reputation to protect.
If they're recommending, off the top of my head, at first blush, without spending half an hour digging into it, I'd not be worried.
Your meeting your responsibility to have good malware/virus etc etc protection should complete the security loop.
There ain't much i life that's a sure thing, you have to evaluate the odds.
My System SpecsSystem Spec
27 Jul 2011   #3

Win7 H.Prem. 32bit+SP1

Windows Live Photo Gallery is free & works for me.
My System SpecsSystem Spec


 Could This Software Be TOO GOOD TO BE TRUE? Need Your Honest Opinion.

Thread Tools

Similar help and support threads
Thread Forum
Too good to be true?
I'm a little concerned about Microsoft Security Essentials getting more and more adverse comments, so I have been looking at alternatives. On ebay amongst many others is Trend Micro Titanium Maximum Security 2013 one year/three pc's cloud edition which is selling for 3.99 (261228847829). What is a...
System Security
Need An Opinion On Anti-Viral Software
For years my family used Trend Micro and Webroot(together) on our computers. My father then bought a new computer, and got a free trial of Symantec and stuck with them. I bought a lap top and installed Webroot & Trend Micro BUT they both ended up being very resource heavy and would slow down my...
System Security
$2 Norton Anti-Virus - Too good to be true?
norton anti-virus - Google Search So, are those $2 results just useless? Or would it just need 5 years of updates once you installed it? Curious...
System Security
Sandboxie seem too good to be true?
Is it me, or does Sandboxie just seem too good to be true?
Beware of student downloads looking too good to be true
There are all sorts of posts from students that believe they have upgrade licenses and are installing successfully, booting to blank drives etc. It seems these guys got full installs not upgrades. The student windows 7 version available thru is the FULL VERSION. The...
Installation & Setup
Hardware KVM vs. software switches? Your opinion?
Hi there, as currently my hardware "portfolio" here is growing, I now see that I need a kind switch, because I don't want to use several mice and keyboards. What I now found out, that those are called "KVM switches" and are often hardware. Yet there is also software. I need one for 1. my...
Hardware & Devices

Our Sites

Site Links

About Us

Find Us

Windows 7 Forums is an independent web site and has not been authorized, sponsored, or otherwise approved by Microsoft Corporation. "Windows 7" and related materials are trademarks of Microsoft Corp.

Designer Media Ltd

All times are GMT -5. The time now is 03:02.
Twitter Facebook Google+ Seven Forums iOS App Seven Forums Android App