Windows 7 reinstallation time, couple Q's first

Backdraft said:

If I move my User Profile/ProgramData to another partition as per the guide above, and in the future wipe and reinstall a fresh Windows 7 image (say located on another partition), are there any compatibility issues I should be aware when connecting the old User Profile/ProgramData folder to the new Windows install (ie. say when reinstalling applications again)? I know that many programs store leftover data in User Profile/AppData/ folder(s), so I feel I should be dutily concerned. Or is it just better practice to, whenever reinstalling Windows, to also just start a clean slate with the User Profile/ProgramData folder?

I feel confident only to answer this question of yours, leaving other questions to real geeks to answer

As an example, I use my own computers. Using the method described in tutorial, I have relocated Users and ProgramData on D: on all rigs. After finalizing the installation, I then create a system image of C: using Windows Backup.

Now if I need to restore the image, it is enough to restore this system image of C:, because it already contains all necessary pointers to Users and ProgramData on D:. All applications can and will find necessary files and folders on %userprofile%\AppData and ProgramData, because the system image already has the needed information on Windows environment variables, and all registry entries point to right locations.

I did an image restore last time about a month ago on my desktop computer, without a problem. That's the advantage of using this method, Users and ProgramData are relocated before creating any user accounts thus making new locations "hard coded" to the system.

Please notice when making system images that if your system has a separate 100 MB system reserved partition, you need to image that, too.

Kari

I'm sorry MacGyvr but I disagree. Some users use quite small SSD's as system drives, leaving them too little space for everything. Some others, like myself, have so huge amounts of data on for instance personal user folders, that relocating them is only reasonable alternative. For instance my user folder in this laptop I'm using now is at the moment 208GB; I'd rather relocate the whole folder when installing, and then never need to think that again. Everything I save in my folders and librarries is automatically saved on D:, not taking space on my system drive.

Kari

Kari said:

I'm sorry MacGyvr but I disagree. Some users use quite small SSD's as system drives, leaving them too little space for everything. Some others, like myself, have so huge amounts of data on for instance personal user folders, that relocating them is only reasonable alternative. For instance my user folder in this laptop I'm using now is at the moment 208GB; I'd rather relocate the whole folder when installing, and then never need to think that again. Everything I save in my folders and librarries is automatically saved on D:, not taking space on my system drive.

Kari

How'd you managed that, Kari? 208GB for the "Users", folder?!

I've not moved any folders except those with built-in facility to allow then to be moved (Document, Pictures, etc...), and the "Users" folder on my drive is right now sitting on 11.7GB, bearing in mind that the total personal file count on my computer (mostly pictures and videos), is pushing nearly 520,000 files:

C:\Users

I think maybe that the point MacGyvr was trying to make, and I agree, is that it is not necessary to move the "Programdata" or "Users" folders. If I did so, that would be nearly 12GB I'd be wasting on a data drive.

System drive for system files.

Precisely, system drive for system files, personal files and folders on another drive.

In my case, the size of my user folder includes for instance hundreds of movies and music albums, taking a lot of space even when converted to space saving formats. Alone videos I have filmed myself take about 30 gigs, and Pictures folder is over 20 gigs. AppData is almost 9 gigs, which would simply be unnecessary big to store for instance on a small, 30 to 50 gigs SSD. When the environment variable %userprofiles% has a new value D:\Users, I simply do not need to think of that. My C: is only for Windows, and Program Files alone. What's wrong with that? As a Libraries-feature lover, this way I also have no need to setup Libraries to find certain folders; I'm using default user folders and Libraries (Documents, Music, Pictures and so on) and everything is there by default, without me needing to change a thing.

I'm a little surprised to read your comments. Almost every geek I know has relocated at least some of the personal folders. Why not do it in the simplest possible way, relocating all personal folders at the same time? The method I have described in that tutorial is the only absolutely, completely idiot-proof "do it once and forget" method there is to do that. It makes it easier to use those smaller SSD drives as system drive, without ever needing to think where own docs, pics, music and so on are saved. After restoring an image or restore point, there's no need to recreate junction points or links, no need to re-edit registry, nothing.

Kari

Kari said:

Precisely, system drive for system files, personal files and folders on another drive.

In my case, the size of my user folder includes for instance hundreds of movies and music albums, taking a lot of space even when converted to space saving formats. Alone videos I have filmed myself take about 30 gigs, and Pictures folder is over 20 gigs. AppData is almost 9 gigs, which would simply be unnecessary big to store for instance on a small, 30 to 50 gigs SSD. When the environment variable %userprofiles% has a new value D:\Users, I simply do not need to think of that. My C: is only for Windows, and Program Files alone. What's wrong with that? As a Libraries-feature lover, this way I also have no need to setup Libraries to find certain folders; I'm using default user folders and Libraries (Documents, Music, Pictures and so on) and everything is there by default, without me needing to change a thing.

I'm a little surprised to read your comments. Almost every geek I know has relocated at least some of the personal folders. Why not do it in the simplest possible way, relocating all personal folders at the same time? The method I have described in that tutorial is the only absolutely, completely idiot-proof "do it once and forget" method there is to do that. It makes it easier to use those smaller SSD drives as system drive, without ever needing to think where own docs, pics, music and so on are saved. After restoring an image or restore point, there's no need to recreate junction points or links, no need to re-edit registry, nothing.

Kari

Sure, moving the entire "Users" folder all at once does indeed make some sense because you move one folder once. But alot of what's in "Users" is of no real value to a user in terms of personal files and such. And using your method to move the entire "Users" folder, or moving each recognized user-folder individually to another drive or partition, has no bearing on the outcome of what happens when an image is created and later used to restore the system.

Just as the %USERPROFILE% info is stored in the reigstry, so to is the information pertaining to the locations of Documents, Pictures and other user folders. No junction points or links are involved. All my user folders where moved to other drives using the built-in facilities, leaving "C:\Users" in it's original location, and if or when I need to restore from a backup image, they will all still be pointing to the locations I have specified.

Moving your Documents, Pictures, Videos, etc completely out of "C:\Users", even if that folder itself has been moved, is also a good idea, because it separates physically your personal files from system files. For example, my own Documents folder points to "F:\Documents", Pictures to "F:\Pictures", Videos to "K:\Videos". That way, if for whatever reason I am not able to access "C:\Users", I know that at least I'll still be able get to my own stuff.

Each method I suppose has merrit. I like to seperate the stuff that I want and the stuff I don't need...

I just fail to see the point that instead of doing one simple extra step when installing, using two minutes of extra time, you want to do that manually for every folder and every user you want to relocate. Doing it once as I do, it's done. All future user profiles and folders are automatically created on that new location. No need to then manually modify the settings to those folders this new user wants to relocate.

Might be that I'm missing something here, I just feel odd that you say it's OK to relocate Documents, or Pictures, or Videos, doing it manually, but it's not OK to relocate the whole user folder automatically, even before the accounts are created.

Kari

Kari said:

I just fail to see the point that instead of doing one simple extra step when installing, using two minutes of extra time, you want to do that manually for every folder and every user you want to relocate. Doing it once as I do, it's done. All future user profiles and folders are automatically created on that new location. No need to then manually modify the settings to those folders this new user wants to relocate.

Might be that I'm missing something here, I just feel odd that you say it's OK to relocate Documents, or Pictures, or Videos, doing it manually, but it's not OK to relocate the whole user folder automatically, even before the accounts are created.

Kari

As I said, both methods have merit. It's just that yours doesn't fit my usage patterns.

I'm the only user on Prometheus, and will always be the only user. The only people around who may want to use it can either access what I allow them to over the network, or they can get their own computer.

So my my point of view, moving the whole "C:\Users" doesn't make alot of sense. If I need to do any checking of something that may require another user account, then I use Windows 7 inside of a virtual PC, because it's quicker than having to stop what I'm doing to log off, login to another account, then back again (quicker even that using "Switch User"). I get to continue doing what I'm doing without losing focus on my current work...