Why Microsoft's muscling of Symantec is good

JMH

Banned
Local time
4:26 AM
Messages
6,448
Here's a scenario we've seen before: Microsoft leverages its domination of the operating system to muscle its way into an adjacent space. Most of the time, that's a bad thing, leading to the disappearance of smaller, more innovative competitors. The company has been rightfully slapped around for that sort of monopolistic behavior by both U.S. and European regulators.

But when it comes to desktop security -- where Microsoft recently began offering free antimalware software via Microsoft Update -- Microsoft deserves kudos, not slaps. Ironically, Microsoft may be doing consumers and IT a favor by taking on Symantec and its lumbering, customer-unfriendly line of Norton security products.

Symantec, which has huge market share and is often the default security program placed on PCs by manufacturers, has taken its customers for granted for years. Shocking as it may seem, Microsoft may be coming to the rescue.

Microsoft's automatic security download

Microsoft Security Essentials (MSE), a perfectly serviceable antimalware application, has always been available free of charge, but compared to paid offerings by Symantec, McAfee, and Trend Micro, its user base of about 30 million is paltry. However, our buddies in Redmond have made it an option in Microsoft Update, which means that users could download and install it with a couple of clicks and no particular thought.

Symantec and Trend Micro have been pretty quiet about this, repeating the usual platitudes about how their products offer much more than the basic protection users get from MSE, how signature-based defenses are too limited, and so on. Security vendors have every right to compete on that basis, and if consumers would rather pay for their products, so be it. In fact, there is some truth to their arguments, and I wouldn't say that MSE is the superior product. But that's not the point.
More -
Why Microsoft's muscling of Symantec is good | The Industry Standard - InfoWorld
 

My Computer My Computer

At a glance

Win 7 Ultimate 64-bit. SP1.Intel i7 -720QM.[1.6GHz Turbo Boost 2.8GHz. 6...8 DDR 3 RAM. 1066MHZATI 1024 MB. DDR3. Radeon HD5650
Computer Manufacturer/Model Number
LAPTOP. HP Pavilion dv7-4010TX .
OS
Win 7 Ultimate 64-bit. SP1.
CPU
Intel i7 -720QM.[1.6GHz Turbo Boost 2.8GHz. 6MB Cache.]
Memory
8 DDR 3 RAM. 1066MHZ
Graphics Card(s)
ATI 1024 MB. DDR3. Radeon HD5650
Monitor(s) Displays
17.3" High Definition Brightview LCD. LED Backlit.
Screen Resolution
1600 x 900.
Hard Drives
640GB
Case
Laptop / notebook.
Mouse
Logitech Anywhere mouse. MX.
Internet Speed
ADSL [ but too slow ]
Don't put much stock in this author. He can't even figure out how to control Norton's scans. I just starting using NIS 2011 and have no trouble finding the settings I need to control NIS. I do remember that when I first tried NIS 2009 it was confusing, but this new version has lots of settings but are well documented. It is good that MS is in the anti-virus game and the more competition the better. I wonder why no one has complained about Windows Defender being installed with Win 7. They do sell programs that do the same thing.
If you can't compete with a good product then just sue everybody else. I found NIS 2011 on sale for $19.99 for 3-PC version and at that price it was a no brainer since in most tests it out performs the free products. I am set for the next year and will see how things shake out in the future.

Jim :geek:
 

My Computer My Computer

At a glance

Windows 8.1 Pro w/Media Center 64bit, Windows...Phenom II X6 1100TCrucial Balistic 8gb DDR3-1866 CL9MSI R6850 Cyclone IGD5 PE
Computer type
PC/Desktop
Computer Manufacturer/Model Number
Home Built
OS
Windows 8.1 Pro w/Media Center 64bit, Windows 7 HP 64bit
CPU
Phenom II X6 1100T
Motherboard
ASUS M5A99X EVO
Memory
Crucial Balistic 8gb DDR3-1866 CL9
Graphics Card(s)
MSI R6850 Cyclone IGD5 PE
Sound Card
On Board
Monitor(s) Displays
ASUS VE258Q 25" LED with DVI-HDMI-DisplayPort
Screen Resolution
1920 x 1080
Hard Drives
Two WD Cavier Black 2TB Sata III, WD My Book Essential 2TB USB 3.0
PSU
Seasonic X650 80 Plus GOLD Modular
Case
Corsair 400R
Cooling
Antec Kuhler H2O 620, Two 120mm and four 140mm
Keyboard
Logitech K120
Mouse
Logitech Marble Mouse USB, Logitech Precision Game Pad
Internet Speed
15MB
Antivirus
Norton IS 2013, Malwarebytes Pro Beta 2
Browser
IE-11, FF-27
Other Info
APC UPS ES 750, Netgear WNR3500L Gigabit & Wireless N Router with SamKnows Test Program, Motorola SB6120 Gigabit Cable Modem. Brother HL-2170W Laser Printer, Epson V300 Scanner
I still cannot figure out if using Microsoft Security essentials is enough to protect a computer from the evils of the internet or do we still need to use a paid virus protector?
 

My Computer My Computer

At a glance

MS Win7 home premium 64bitIntel i3 5302 x 2G
OS
MS Win7 home premium 64bit
CPU
Intel i3 530
Motherboard
Gigabyte GA-H55M-S2H
Memory
2 x 2G
Monitor(s) Displays
Acer T230H
Hard Drives
1Tb-SATA2-32Mb
Case
Awyun mid tower
Keyboard
Microsoft comfort curve keyboard 2000 v1.0
Mouse
Microsoft optical
I still cannot figure out if using Microsoft Security essentials is enough to protect a computer from the evils of the internet or do we still need to use a paid virus protector?

Hi there

Forget Corporations or small Work place computers -- Security on those systems is a different topic entirely.


For HOME users it really depends on what you do and how you use the Internet.

Some people work their whole lives and NEVER get a Virus -- I for example have NEVER been infected with any computer nasty except making "User" mistakes or installing stuff incorrectly. I confess that I have used some torrents in the past too --especially during the early days of W7 before its "Official Release".

Others just seem to get caught every time they use a Computer, while I suppose the majority are in between.

MSE seem by all accounts to work perfectly well and is getting better by the day -- IMO who is better able to protect Windows than the manufacturers of Windows itself.

For Home use MSE should just about put an end to paid for HOME computer protection.

Sensible USER precautions in any case are far more effective than any Software so whatever you install you should use your computer SENSIBLY.

I find an almost 100% way of preventing infection is to only access the Internet via a Virtual Machine including downloads etc.

If the download checks out OK -- run of course the security program - in my case MSE on the VM as well - and it works then transfer it to the REAL machine -- if it doesn't then just ditch the whole Virtual Machine and start again.

Even a small Laptop is capable of running a Virtual Machine as well as the Host OS.

This method I know won't work for games and video applications -- but I'm not a gamer. It DOES work for Audio however for those that source music from "other places".

Cheers
jimbo
 

My Computer My Computer

At a glance

Linux CENTOS 7 / various Windows OS'es and se...Intel i7 Intel i58GB, 16GBOn Motherboard
Computer type
PC/Desktop
Computer Manufacturer/Model Number
Custom built, several laptops HP/ASUS
OS
Linux CENTOS 7 / various Windows OS'es and servers
CPU
Intel i7 Intel i5
Memory
8GB, 16GB
Graphics Card(s)
On Motherboard
Sound Card
Realtek HD audio
Monitor(s) Displays
Apple Cinema display, Samsung LCD
Screen Resolution
1920 X 1080
Hard Drives
4 X 1TB SATA
Mouse
Toshiba wireless laser
Internet Speed
> 20MB up
This is my opinion. Thank you Microsoft for getting into the security business and doing it so well. I think in a short time it will get even better.
 

My Computer My Computer

At a glance

Windows 10 Pro. 64/ version 1709 Windows 7 Pr...Intel i7-6800K @ 4.3Corsair Platinum 16 gig @2400EVGA GTX 1070 OC
Computer type
PC/Desktop
Computer Manufacturer/Model Number
Home made Desktop
OS
Windows 10 Pro. 64/ version 1709 Windows 7 Pro/64
CPU
Intel i7-6800K @ 4.3
Motherboard
ASUS X-99 Deluxe II
Memory
Corsair Platinum 16 gig @2400
Graphics Card(s)
EVGA GTX 1070 OC
Monitor(s) Displays
Asus 27" LED LCD/VE278Q
Screen Resolution
1920-1080 or 1280-720 HDMI
Hard Drives
INTEL SSD 730-240 Gb Sata 3.0/
PSU
EVGA Platium 1200W
Case
Phanteks Luxe Tempered Glass 8 fans/ one radiator
Cooling
XSPC/ Water Cooled CPU
Keyboard
Das 4 Professional
Mouse
Logitech M705/MX Anywhere 2-S
Internet Speed
100 mbits
Antivirus
Microsoft Security Essentials/ Malwarebytes Premium 3.0/ SAS
Browser
I.E. 11 default/Firefox/ ISP Time Warner Cable/Spectrum
Other Info
LG BluRay Burner/
Sound system-KLipsch-THX/
Icy Dock ssd Hot Swap bays.
Regardless of whether prefer MSE or Norton theres a couple things about this article in regards to Norton that made me scratch my head and say ... HUH??

1)
What's worse, the program insists on doing background scans whenever it feels like it, no matter that it's in the middle of my work day and a terrible time to slow my PC. Digging around for settings to change that is unconscionably difficult.

True, Norton does do automatic scans.
Idle Time scans it called, and for good reason. it does quick scans whenever the PC is at idle.
If its in the process of doing so, moving your mouse is all it takes to cancel it.

What program is he using? Not the Norton Im using at any count.

2) Perhaps I have simply been very lucky.
But as far as customer service Ive only needed to contact them 1 time.
After rebuilding a new PC, Norton wouldn't activate as I had used all 3 activations.
I called them up, and 10 minutes later I was up and running without issue.

This may have been a stroke of luck for me, but that was my experience with them.



As far as MSE goes and the Windows update...

Good move on Microsofts part IMHO. If the machine has no protection at all, its offering to protect them free of charge.
It is not being forced on you, and you still have a choice to use it or a 3rd party.

I fail to see a issue with this.
 

My Computer My Computer

At a glance

Windows 7 Home Premium 64bitIntel Core i7 2700k8GB Mushkin Redline Ridgebacks @1866EVGA GTX570 SC
Computer Manufacturer/Model Number
Custom (Self Build)
OS
Windows 7 Home Premium 64bit
CPU
Intel Core i7 2700k
Motherboard
eVGA P67 SLI
Memory
8GB Mushkin Redline Ridgebacks @1866
Graphics Card(s)
EVGA GTX570 SC
Sound Card
XiFi Titanium HD
Monitor(s) Displays
LG W2453V
Screen Resolution
1920x1080
Hard Drives
Intel 320 80GB -- Intel X25-V 40GB --WD Black 1TB x2 -- WD Blue 640GB
PSU
Seasonic x750
Case
Corsair 600T SE White
Cooling
eVGA Superclocked CPU Cooler
Keyboard
Saitek Cyborg
Antivirus
Kaspersky
Browser
IE
Other Info
LG BD/DVD
Very good article, Jan. Thanks for the post.

I agree with Jimbo's assesment. MSE is really all one needs for home use. However, I do not like the fact that it does not have an email scanner.
 

My Computer My Computer

At a glance

Windows 7 Ultimate 32 bitIntel(R) Pentium(R) 4 CPU 3.00GHz2.50 GB RAMNVIDIA GeForce 7600 GS
Computer Manufacturer/Model Number
Home built
OS
Windows 7 Ultimate 32 bit
CPU
Intel(R) Pentium(R) 4 CPU 3.00GHz
Motherboard
ASUS P4P800-VM Motherboard Chipset: Intel 865G + ICH5
Memory
2.50 GB RAM
Graphics Card(s)
NVIDIA GeForce 7600 GS
Sound Card
SoundMax Integrated Digital Audio (Chip)
Monitor(s) Displays
ViewSonic VX 1962 wm
Screen Resolution
1680 X 1050
Hard Drives
Seagate Barracuda 7200.10 80 GB
ST380215A ATA Device 18.6 GB
Western Digital "My Book" external hard drive 750 GB
Cooling
Fan based
Keyboard
Microsoft Comfort Curve Keyboard 2000 v10 USB
Mouse
Logitec optic USB
Internet Speed
3.01 Mb/s download 0.64 Mb/s upload
I still cannot figure out if using Microsoft Security essentials is enough to protect a computer from the evils of the internet or do we still need to use a paid virus protector?

MSE has the best benchmark for free versions and it's only up to the first version with version 2 out soon..

run it along side malwarebytes anti malware
enable UAC and windows firewall
enable router firewall if you have one
 

My Computer My Computer

At a glance

Windows 7 Ultimate
OS
Windows 7 Ultimate
customer-unfriendly line of Norton security products.
I'd say, at their default settings, they work exceptionally well. If you want to change a setting, it is described in detail.
taken its customers for granted for years
Years ago they ignored the customer. In 2008, they re-wrote the program after years of customers complaining about bloat and resource usage and each version since has been lighter than the last. Since then, many things have changed due to user feedback and a few months ago, they started Norton Product Ideas - Norton Community.
Then there's the never-ending feature bloat. Norton keeps getting bigger, using more disk space and other system resources.
In mine and others' experiences, it uses less resources than MSE.

Raymond.CC Antivirus Performance Benchmark Test
Now that I've been automatically upgraded to the latest version of Internet Security
Automatically, as in, you chose to upgrade?
it keeps telling that some system files are using a lot of disk resources. So what? The files in question are part of Windows and I couldn't turn them off if I wanted to.
Edit: Misread the above quote :o.

Like almost everything else in Norton, you can turn the whole thing off or parts of it off (you can even set this setting to log only). You can exclude files through Settings or when you receive a pop-up. You can set the "Resource Threshold Profile For Alerting" to Low, Medium or High. You can turn off the "Use Low Resource Profile On Battery Power". threshold You can set what it alerts for. CPU, Memory, Disk and/or Handles. Now that they have (generally positive) feedback from the community, they may develop it further. Have any ideas to suggest? Allow Performance Monitoring Alerts to be Configur... - Norton Community
What's worse, the program insists on doing background scans whenever it feels like it, no matter that it's in the middle of my work day and a terrible time to slow my PC. Digging around for settings to change that is unconscionably difficult.
It does background tasks when the computer is idle. You can set the idle timeout from 1-30 minutes. Norton will enter Silent Mode (suppresses all alerts [which, due to user complaints, can be turned off permanently in Norton 2011] and background activities) if it detects an application running full screen (you can turn that off). Norton will enter Quiet Mode (suppresses background tasks) if a disk burning task or a Media Center TV recording task is detected (you can turn either of those off). You can specify any other program that will enable Quiet Mode when running. You can right-click the Norton tray icon and manually turn Silent Mode on for one hour, two hours, four hours, six hours, or one day. You can turn off all but one of the background tasks: idle quick scan, which, depending on the system, can take less than a minute.
 
Last edited:

My Computer My Computer

At a glance

Arch Linux 64-bit
OS
Arch Linux 64-bit
MSE has the best benchmark for free versions
Which benchmark?
Ditto. Several independant groups have tested MSE and several other AVs to see which is best. MSE usual ranks well, but so does Norton and a couple others. Which one specifically are you refering to?
 

My Computer My Computer

At a glance

Windows 7 Professional SP1 64-bitIntel Core i5-2450M @2.5 GHz6 GB DDR3 1333MHzIntel HD 3000
Computer type
Laptop
Computer Manufacturer/Model Number
Toshiba P775-S7100
OS
Windows 7 Professional SP1 64-bit
CPU
Intel Core i5-2450M @2.5 GHz
Memory
6 GB DDR3 1333MHz
Graphics Card(s)
Intel HD 3000
Monitor(s) Displays
Built-in 17.3" LED; 22" Insignia NS-L22Q-10A
Screen Resolution
1600x900; 1360x768
Hard Drives
750 GB Hitachi
1TB Seagate FreeAgent External
Internet Speed
Verizon DSL Speed(Down/Up): 3360 Kbps / 800 Kbps
Antivirus
MSE and MBAM Pro
Browser
IE10
I'm using Norton 360, it's awesome.
 
Last edited:

My Computer My Computer

At a glance

Windows 8 Professional 64-bitIntel Core i3-21004GBGeForece GTX 550 Ti
Computer Manufacturer/Model Number
Custom
OS
Windows 8 Professional 64-bit
CPU
Intel Core i3-2100
Motherboard
ASRock Intel Z68M/USB3
Memory
4GB
Graphics Card(s)
GeForece GTX 550 Ti
Screen Resolution
1680 x 1050
PSU
750w

My Computer My Computer

At a glance

Windows 8 Professional 64-bitIntel Core i3-21004GBGeForece GTX 550 Ti
Computer Manufacturer/Model Number
Custom
OS
Windows 8 Professional 64-bit
CPU
Intel Core i3-2100
Motherboard
ASRock Intel Z68M/USB3
Memory
4GB
Graphics Card(s)
GeForece GTX 550 Ti
Screen Resolution
1680 x 1050
PSU
750w
MSE is a quality piece of freeware and in my view all the average home pc user needs, **** symantec anyone who views their software as reliable or effective needs to get off the crack pipe.
 

My Computer My Computer

At a glance

Windows 7 Ultimate SP1 RC X64Core Two Duo 2.88 ghzDDR2 4.0 GbsNvidia
Computer Manufacturer/Model Number
Intel
OS
Windows 7 Ultimate SP1 RC X64
CPU
Core Two Duo 2.88 ghz
Motherboard
Intel DQ series
Memory
DDR2 4.0 Gbs
Graphics Card(s)
Nvidia
Monitor(s) Displays
Acer 24' & Acer 19'
Hard Drives
1tb (Internal) & WD 500gb (External)
Case
Intel Tower Case
Keyboard
Apple Wired Keyboard
Mouse
Microsoft Wheel Optical Laser

My Computer My Computer

At a glance

Windows 7 Professional SP1 64-bitIntel Core i5-2450M @2.5 GHz6 GB DDR3 1333MHzIntel HD 3000
Computer type
Laptop
Computer Manufacturer/Model Number
Toshiba P775-S7100
OS
Windows 7 Professional SP1 64-bit
CPU
Intel Core i5-2450M @2.5 GHz
Memory
6 GB DDR3 1333MHz
Graphics Card(s)
Intel HD 3000
Monitor(s) Displays
Built-in 17.3" LED; 22" Insignia NS-L22Q-10A
Screen Resolution
1600x900; 1360x768
Hard Drives
750 GB Hitachi
1TB Seagate FreeAgent External
Internet Speed
Verizon DSL Speed(Down/Up): 3360 Kbps / 800 Kbps
Antivirus
MSE and MBAM Pro
Browser
IE10
What Microsoft ought to do is give windows away, they retain the rights to the source code, but the operating system should be free of charge... all of it's built in features as it stands right now, and then offer the rest of it's other products for a price via windows update. They would make a hell of a lot more money if everyone who could afford a computer didn't ever have to worry about the operating system not working, and the entire issue this thread is based on would be nullified.
 

My Computer My Computer

At a glance

Windows 8 Professional 64-bitIntel Core i3-21004GBGeForece GTX 550 Ti
Computer Manufacturer/Model Number
Custom
OS
Windows 8 Professional 64-bit
CPU
Intel Core i3-2100
Motherboard
ASRock Intel Z68M/USB3
Memory
4GB
Graphics Card(s)
GeForece GTX 550 Ti
Screen Resolution
1680 x 1050
PSU
750w
Don't put much stock in this author. He can't even figure out how to control Norton's scans. I just starting using NIS 2011 and have no trouble finding the settings I need to control NIS. I do remember that when I first tried NIS 2009 it was confusing, but this new version has lots of settings but are well documented. It is good that MS is in the anti-virus game and the more competition the better. I wonder why no one has complained about Windows Defender being installed with Win 7. They do sell programs that do the same thing.
If you can't compete with a good product then just sue everybody else. I found NIS 2011 on sale for $19.99 for 3-PC version and at that price it was a no brainer since in most tests it out performs the free products. I am set for the next year and will see how things shake out in the future.

Jim :geek:


Windows Defender is disabled or uninstalled when you run MSE.

"Q: Is Microsoft Security Essentials designed to replace Windows Defender?
A: No but if you are running Microsoft Security Essentials, you do not need to run Windows Defender. Microsoft Security Essentials is designed to disable Windows Defender in order to manage the PC’s real-time protection, including anti-virus, rootkits, Trojans and spyware"
 

My Computer My Computer

At a glance

Windows 7 32-bitIntel Core i54GBnVidia 512MB shared
Computer Manufacturer/Model Number
Lenovo
OS
Windows 7 32-bit
CPU
Intel Core i5
Memory
4GB
Graphics Card(s)
nVidia 512MB shared
Monitor(s) Displays
Lenovo Laptop, Acer
Screen Resolution
1600 x 900
Case
ThinkPad
Keyboard
Lenovo Enhanced Performance Keyboard
Mouse
Microsoft Wireless Mouse 5000
Internet Speed
Fiber - Work
Back
Top