Is MSE as good as the free Avast or Avira?

[tony22]

Recent postings here from some users seem to indicate that the current version of MSE is quite good. I was thinking of using either Avast or Avira, but if MSE really is as good at detection and removal then I thought I'd give it a try first. Anyone try all three recently? The reports I've found online still seem to show MSE as not quite as good.

Nevermind. I did more searching and found more info. I'm going to try MSE, SpywareBlaster, and MAMB (which I already use).

 

[zigzag3143]

Recent postings here from some users seem to indicate that the current version of MSE is quite good. I was thinking of using either Avast or Avira, but if MSE really is as good at detection and removal then I thought I'd give it a try first. Anyone try all three recently? The reports I've found online still seem to show MSE as not quite as good.

Nevermind. I did more searching and found more info. I'm going to try MSE, SpywareBlaster, and MAMB (which I already use).

Good move. Strictly from a BSOD perspective MSE causes much less than Avira, or Avast.

 

[A Guy]

Here are a few comparisons. The 2nd includes more up to date data. I personally us Avast with no issues.

Microsoft Security Essentials vs Avira vs avast! vs AVG: A comprehensive comparison to help you decide which (free) anti-malware security software you should use | Freeware Reviews | dotTech

Avast vs AVG vs Avira vs Microsoft Security Essentials Review Of Free Antivirus Software » TechLogon Technology News | Tech News Help And Tutorials

A Guy

 

[tony22]

Ah. I had seen the first link but not the second. Thanks A Guy.

Leaves me wondering, though. For as highly as MSE is recommended here, it seems like the majority of info out there places it behind the other two. Do Avast and Avira lead to so many stability issues or other problems that they outweigh their capabilities?

 

[Petey7]

If you go to the link below you will see some tests with some differing results. Even through both test are done by the same people, the two test use two different methodologies and ratind systems. In the October 2011 test, MSE did better than both Avira and Avast. In the December test, Avira and MSE did well (with Avira being the better of the two) and Avast did poorly. It is also a matter of personal preference. In over two years of using MSE I have only had one virus successfully infect my computer, but keeping regular back-ups of my computer allowed to fix the problem in under an hour. Also, when it comes to real world scenarios, the results are generally going to be different from what happens in a controlled envorinment.

AV-Comparatives - Independent Tests of Anti-Virus Software - Removal-Tests

 

[tony22]

Good info Petey7. This comparison seems to be based on Removal capabilities, where even in the other reviews posted by A Guy MSE does well. It appears to be the detection phase where MSE is not as strong.

 

[Petey7]

I've always had MSE detect something when it first tries to install itself. Even in the one case the a virus did make it's way on to my computer, MSE popped up with a message saying severe threat detected, but then the virus apparently ended the processes for MSE. MSE is known for the fact that its heuristic based detection being weaker than many other AVs, but this is by design to help insure that no false positives occur. The main thing to remember is that no AV is perfect, and no AV will protect your computer completely. This is why we also recommend having an on-demand scanner, such as MBAM, doing backups, and having system restore turned on. That way if something does get past your main AV, you have a backup plan ready.

EDIT: Just wanted to add, if you prefer Avast or Avira, both are fine AVs. Use which ever you like, and recommend which ever you like to others. Its mostly a matter of what you think works best for you.

 

[Borg 386]

Asking for an opinion on a AV is going to get you a lot of different answers, as everyone has their own preferences & beliefs on which on works best. In the end you will have to make the choice on what you think is better & what you're comfortable using.

MSE does work well in the fact that since it was written by MS, it integrates smoothly with Windows. That's not to say it's 100% protection, nothing is. Make sure to keep your AV defs updated.

To this date, the best AV out there is....common sense and cautious surfing habits.

It also helps to run Malwarebytes and other on demand scanners (Such as MSERT) on a regular basis.

And of course, a Firewall is a must have item nowadays.

 

[tony22]

To this date, the best AV out there is....common sense and cautious surfing habits.

That's actually been my mode of operation for many many years. Using online info to keep track of the latest threats, a bit of caution, and common sense I've only been hit maybe 4 times in the last 10 years. Between backups, restore points, and MAMB the recoveries have been painless. I used Norton and some other products before that but didn't like the way they slowed things down. With lots of RAM and faster processors I decided to revisit adding something more proactive.

 

[JMH]

Nevermind. I did more searching and found more info. I'm going to try MSE, SpywareBlaster, and MAMB (which I already use).

Nice choices.
Well done!

FYI...
Further Security.

*Firewall. {The inbuilt Windows Firewall is considered appropriate}

*Router / firewall
Router security

* It is important to update programs & scan regularly.

* Exercise caution with what you click on.
Avoid engaging in activities such as file sharing, warez cracks, adult content, online gambling or other high-risk behaviors.

 

[tony22]

FYI...
Further Security.

*Firewall. {The inbuilt Windows Firewall is considered appropriate}

Loaded and running.

*Router / firewall
Router security

Same for same

* It is important to update programs & scan regularly.

* Exercise caution with what you click on.
Avoid engaging in activities such as file sharing, warez cracks, adult content, online gambling or other high-risk behaviors.

That's the plan.

 

[A Guy]

As long as we're suggesting things, Secunia PSI is a must have IMHO. Scans for insecure and end of life applications. A great addition.

Free Computer Security - Personal Software Inspector (PSI) - Secunia

A Guy

 

[noobvious]

In the two years I've had this computer,the Windows firewall, MSE, Hitman Pro, and Superantispyware have kept me safe. I don't do any torrenting, either.

 

[DwDanwoof]

I think that will help to know
AV-Comparatives - Independent Tests of Anti-Virus Software - Removal-Tests

 

[koolkat77]

my rating:
1) MSE
2) Avira
3) Avast (cause I never used it)

 

[DwDanwoof]

Mine is
1)Webroot Complet
2)MSE
3)Noting else then 1 and 2

 

[indianacarnie]

I've used Avast free for years now with no problems. Tried MSE for a bit, but ....... what can I say ..... just didn't "feel" safe. No Blue screen's ever on my win7x64 machines. With Avast I also run Malwarebytes and SuperAntiSpyware. This combo has kept me clean and surfing for ........ lol ..... a while now. *Blush* I do go to the occasional Adult Site and Avast has detected all attempts at infection, so far at least.

I also use Secunia after hearing it recommended here about a year ago and could not be happier with it.

 

[FranzB]

I've used Avast free for years now with no problems. Tried MSE for a bit, but ....... what can I say ..... just didn't "feel" safe. No Blue screen's ever on my win7x64 machines. With Avast I also run Malwarebytes and SuperAntiSpyware. This combo has kept me clean and surfing for ........ lol ..... a while now. *Blush* I do go to the occasional Adult Site and Avast has detected all attempts at infection, so far at least.

I also use Secunia after hearing it recommended here about a year ago and could not be happier with it.

Just wait till you hit on a really hot one and get all flustered and push the wrong buttons

 

[GamePlanner]

Mine is
1)Webroot Complet
2)MSE
3)Noting else then 1 and 2

How can we compare webroot complete with this free antivirus
I think its one have to die hard fan of webroot to buy such expensive internet security with nothing special in it.

Regarding avast avira and mse avast have many features in compare to avira and mse.
Avira have good detection and mse have good removal.
If you choose any one with good firewall and on demand scanner like hitman pro and malwarebytes your machine will be safe.

However if i had to go with one i will definitely choose avast because of its extra features as well as it will not give you annoy popups like avira nor it will slow down browsing speed like mse.(its strange but its true that mse slow downs browsing speed a bit}

 

[noobvious]

However if i had to go with one i will definitely choose avast because of its extra features as well as it will not give you annoy popups like avira nor it will slow down browsing speed like mse.(its strange but its true that mse slow downs browsing speed a bit}

It doesn't slow down browsing for me.