Comodo Leak Test: What's your score?

[gforce23]

I've been hitting all kinds of firewalls (including the Win7 firewall) with Comodo LeakTest suite and the scores make for some interesting results. Here's the Win7 firewall in its default state on a "home" network.

In comparison, the paid version of Online Armor scored 320, Kerio 80 and Rising F/W 180. IIRC, the Windows XP firewall scored 50 which isn't bad for something that offers uni-directional monitoring, let alone advanced features like HIPS.

Is anyone using the latest firewalls (or ISSs) from Norton, Avira and the rest?

The test suite is available out here. Your A/V might give you a warning about a file named coat.dll but that file is necessary to test any leaks in your security setup and is rather harmless.

 

[Creer]

Here is my result:

Only DWPF v3 running.

One test failed: FileDrop (in DW case this test is not harmful/vulnerable - allows to create file in Windows\system directory)

 

[neoasr]

hey i god virus in clt.zip file with avira

 

[Creer]

hey i god virus in clt.zip file with avira

This file well known and is clear, it's FP.
Download it from here:
http://download.comodo.com/securitytests/CLT.zip

 

[Flik]

My results running W7 firewall with Windows 7 firewall control.

I blocked anything that popped up while running the test.

 

[Creer]

Keep in your mind guys that this test is mainly about HIPS protection then about FW, there is only few test which testing FW in this Comodo Leak Test.
As we know, built-in windows firewall does NOT have HIPS module, so this is why yours scores are not perfect.

 

[Flik]

Keep in your mind guys that this test is mainly about HIPS protection then about FW, there is only few test which testing FW in this Comodo Leak Test.
As we know, built-in windows firewall does NOT have HIPS module, so this is why yours scores are not perfect.

Ah ha, thanks for the explaination.

 

[Creer]

Keep in your mind guys that this test is mainly about HIPS protection then about FW, there is only few test which testing FW in this Comodo Leak Test.
As we know, built-in windows firewall does NOT have HIPS module, so this is why yours scores are not perfect.

Ah ha, thanks for the explaination.

You are welcome.

 

[neoasr]

again i got virus with avira

 

[Creer]

again i got virus with avira

As I said before it's False Positive FP

 

[Zahl]

This is on NIS 2010 default settings. No other security apps running. I also had to add a few AV exceptions for some tests to run. Norton went nuts lol
Doesn't look that great though

190/340

 

[Creer]

This is on NIS 2010 default settings. No other security apps running. I also had to add a few AV exceptions for some tests to run. Norton went nuts lol
Doesn't look that great lol

190/340




Edit- I don't understand why I have so much trouble posting images here..
Link= Imageshack - firewalltest

In first case you added .th image which means thumbnail that is why it is so small. When you are on site Imageshack - firewalltest click left click on image which you just added and then copy this image adress (http://img199.imageshack.us/img199/9013/firewalltest.jpg ) and add here on forum in

code.
Or simply add attach here from your hard disk.

About your results... yes indeed norton looks not well.

 

[Zahl]

Thanks I did try that too but its like if you select Insert Link even if you delete it, it sticks sometimes. I'll do it manually from now on though thanks.
And yes, it doesn't look too great

 

[neoasr]

zonealarm pro firewall

 

[Barman58]

Comodo Pro



Not surprising that it passes it's own test but have had the same sort of result with every other test I run

External scans show my system not to exist!

 

[Dinesh]

You sure its a false positive?

 

[gforce23]

Comodo FW and D+ in safe mode:

 

[Creer]

Dinesh, yes I'm sure, this is well known test, some of the vendors AV software added it to their signatures. The other possible reason is that CLT simulate some behaviors in system which could be recognize as harmful but they don't at all.

 

[Dinesh]

Thanks Creer.

 

[hackerman1]

hi !

Comodo´s FREE firewall in safe mode & Defence+ in safe mode: 340/340.