Win7 Won't Take Assigned DHCP IP

[silentwulf]

On my router, I have DHCP assign IPs to the various computers/devices on my network. For example, a laptop is 192.168.1.103, and my server is 192.168.1.102.

I've tried assigning 192.168.1.101 to my Win7 box, but it keeps coming back with 192.168.1.20. I recently reinstalled Windows7 (for a separate issue), and I'm still getting x.x.x.20.

The router assigns this IP via the NIC's MAC ADDRESS. When I check to see what devices are attatched to my router, my router shows the Win7 PC with the .20 IP.

All other nodes (Game consoles, Linux, Mac, WinXP) seem to accept the IP assigned by the router. Why won't my Win7 box?

I have a Netgear WNDR3700, and the Win7 box is hooked directly to the router.

 

[Pusspa]

I dont understand why you are trying to manually assign an IP using DHCP?

 

[zzz2496]

Remove the IP reservation. Once you done that, make sure that Windows 7 box gets an IP from your DHCP server, then you can redo the reservation progess. You said that the .20 is reserved to Win7's box MAC address, you need to delete this reservation before doing everything else...

zzz2496

 

[zzz2496]

I dont understand why you are trying to manually assign an IP using DHCP?

It's a "static" DHCP assignment, you set your computer to auto obtain IP address, and set your router to always give a static IP address to certain computers. So for example, you set so that "laptop" will always receive 192.168.1.99 in the router, and let the "laptop" automatically ask for IP address. This will simplify people that moves from network to network (DHCP enabled), but needs the certainty of having a "static" IP address.

zzz2496

 

[acurasd]

ZZZ2496>>
Just your opinion.

I am fully aware of both static and dynamic IP relationships but what is the main purpose of "Static" DHCP assignment?

 

[WindowsStar]

ZZZ2496>>
Just your opinion.

I am fully aware of both static and dynamic IP relationships but what is the main purpose of "Static" DHCP assignment?

Assigned addresses by DHCP are great for printers, because they need to be the same (static) address all the time.

Edit: Security is another good reason. You can have DHCP on but only give addresses to known MAC addresses.

 

[zzz2496]

ZZZ2496>>
Just your opinion.

I am fully aware of both static and dynamic IP relationships but what is the main purpose of "Static" DHCP assignment?

Let's say I have a laptop that's also a mobile workstation. When I'm at home, I need to be able to access my laptop's web server from, say a development workstation. I need that laptop to have a static IP address at home, but use DHCP while I'm out at a cafe or at the office or at my client's. The simple thing will be to set a Static DHCP assignment to my laptop on my DHCP server, so that I can always enable auto obtain IP address, yet still have a static IP address at home (and dynamic at everywhere else).

zzz2496

 

[acurasd]

I am a little tipsy here. People in wilmington, nc can mix some good drinks... but the only good thing for static dhcps are for mobile laptops that move around alot, Not so much for printers because those usually keep a static ip cause those usually stay stationary.

so i guess that makes sense... wasn't thinking that at the time.

I read alot of people take their laptops to like 20 different sites and they are complaining becuase they have to change their IPs 20 different times, the static dynamic ips would fix that, becuase it would be based on their MAC addresses

 

[WindowsStar]

I am a little tipsy here. People in wilmington, nc can mix some good drinks... but the only good thing for static dhcps are for mobile laptops that move around alot, Not so much for printers because those usually keep a static ip cause those usually stay stationary.

Ahh, but you are only thinking of a home user, coffee shop, or maybe a small business. Let's think about printers on a large scale or enterprise. Static DHCP for a printer make more sense. If someone on another subnet takes a printer to their office and tries to use it, it will not work because the printer will never get an address. They are forced to call the help desk. Now you know a printer had been removed without authorization. Plus maybe you have a network where you don't want someone bringing in their home laptop and using your network Static DHCP will not assign them an address so the network does not work for them. (Note: I know there are ways to get around this but for the average user this stops them).