Hard Drive Question

wangster

New member
Local time
4:35 PM
Messages
34
Which drive would perform better?

A) Drive with 5,400 rpm but 64 MB cache
B) Drive with 7,200 rpm but 32 MB cache
 

My Computer

Computer Manufacturer/Model Number
Custom Built
OS
Windows 7 Ultimate x64
CPU
Intel Core i5 750 @ 2.67 GHz
Motherboard
ASUS P7P55D
Memory
8 GB - G.Skill DDR3
Graphics Card(s)
Sapphire Radeon HD 4670
Sound Card
VIA Onboard HD Audio
Monitor(s) Displays
LG W2252TQ
Hard Drives
250 GB Western Digital RE3 (X2) - Raid0
1 TB Western Digital RE3
PSU
Raidmax RX-730SS
Case
Rosewill Destroyer
It really depends on what you're doing, but I doubt you'll notice that much of a difference. If anything I'd go with the bigger cache I guess. Although if uses large files that'll fill up in like 1/10 of a second. If you really want to improve drive performance you've got to switch to the new SSD's which have readspeeds over 200Mb/s and write speeds of anywhere from 70-170 Mb/s.

What most people around here are doing is getting an 80MB Intel X-25M ($220) and then also getting a set of 1TB convential drives for data storage. You could always go for an SSD other than the Intel series and get something a bit smaller. The smallest I would go with a block for an operating system and programs is about 32GB. That won't give you much room for large programs but it will be enough space for a 64-bit installation of windows with all the normal programs, drivers, etc. You'd store all of your other stuff on the conventional drives. If you have the cash, do something like this:

Kingston 64GB SSDNow V
2 x 1.5 TB Seagate Barracuda

Total Comes to $350

Now you can boot up to two operating systems off your SSD, preferably one. All your system actions will be executed extremely fast because they're running off an SSD. I.E. Explorer, Firefox, etc. Anytime you want to use a huge program or game, you can just install and run it off one of the higher end conventional drives which will still run well they're just not as fast. You could get away with one of the larger drives, or you could just use it as a backup disk.
 

My Computer

Computer Manufacturer/Model Number
Apple Macbook Pro (April 2009)
OS
W7 Ult. x64 | OS X
CPU
Intel Mobile Core 2 Duo 2.93Ghz [T9800 Penryn]
Motherboard
NVIDIA nForce 730i Rev. B1 [Mac-F2268EC8 (U2E1)]
Memory
4096MB Samsung DDR3 Dual Channel [PC3-8500F 1066Mhz]
Graphics Card(s)
NVIDIA GeForce 9600M GT 512MB [G96M Rev. C1]
Sound Card
SB X-Fi Surround 5.1 USB | Onboard Realtek (Disabled)
Monitor(s) Displays
Acer x223wbd 22" | Apple Anti-Glare 17" (Disabled)
Screen Resolution
{Current} 1440x900 {Acer} 1680x1050 {Apple} 1920x1200
Hard Drives
{Internal}
Seagate Momentus 320GB 2.5" 7200RPM [ST9320421AS]

{Externals}
LaCie 320GB USB 2.0 HDD [301284UR]
LaCie 750GB USB 2.0 FW400 eSATA HDD [301314U]
LaCie 1TB USB 2.0 HDD [301304UR]
PSU
Magsafe
Case
Aluminum/Unibody (MBP52)
Cooling
2 x 6000 RPM Fans
Keyboard
Logitech G-15v2 [PN 920-000379]
Mouse
Logitech G-9 [PN 910-000338]
Internet Speed
12Mbps/2.5Mbps w/ 24Mbps Speed Boost [Comcast]
Other Info
Logitech X-540 Speakers [PN 970223-0122]
Sennheiser PC-151 Headset
I actually bought a WD RE3 drive for my data drive. Paid $50 more than the Caviar Black. So I'm considering returning the RE3 for a different drive to use for my data, and spend the $50 somewhere else. I like the 5 year warranty that comes with the Caviar Black (just because I've had a few drives that fail a few months after the 3 years) but I noticed the Green has 64 MB cache but is 5,400 RPM.
 

My Computer

Computer Manufacturer/Model Number
Custom Built
OS
Windows 7 Ultimate x64
CPU
Intel Core i5 750 @ 2.67 GHz
Motherboard
ASUS P7P55D
Memory
8 GB - G.Skill DDR3
Graphics Card(s)
Sapphire Radeon HD 4670
Sound Card
VIA Onboard HD Audio
Monitor(s) Displays
LG W2252TQ
Hard Drives
250 GB Western Digital RE3 (X2) - Raid0
1 TB Western Digital RE3
PSU
Raidmax RX-730SS
Case
Rosewill Destroyer
The 7,200 caviar blacks are about 20-30MB/s faster than the green drives. And the power rating difference between the 2 drives is only about 4-5 watts..so really not much as far as a PC goes.
 

My Computer

Computer Manufacturer/Model Number
Self-Built in July 2009
OS
Windows 7 Ultimate x64
CPU
Intel Q9550 2.83Ghz OC'd to 3.40Ghz
Motherboard
Gigabyte GA-EP45-UD3R rev. 1.1, F12 BIOS
Memory
8GB G.Skill PI DDR2-800, 4-4-4-12 timings
Graphics Card(s)
EVGA 1280MB Nvidia GeForce GTX570
Sound Card
Realtek ALC899A 8 channel onboard audio
Monitor(s) Displays
23" Acer x233H
Screen Resolution
1920x1080
Hard Drives
Intel X25-M 80GB Gen 2 SSD
Western Digital 1TB Caviar Black, 32MB cache. WD1001FALS
PSU
Corsair 620HX modular
Case
Antec P182
Cooling
stock
Keyboard
ABS M1 Mechanical
Mouse
Logitech G9 Laser Mouse
Internet Speed
15/2 cable modem
Other Info
Windows and Linux enthusiast. Logitech G35 Headset.
Thank you. Ordering the Caviar Black now.
 

My Computer

Computer Manufacturer/Model Number
Custom Built
OS
Windows 7 Ultimate x64
CPU
Intel Core i5 750 @ 2.67 GHz
Motherboard
ASUS P7P55D
Memory
8 GB - G.Skill DDR3
Graphics Card(s)
Sapphire Radeon HD 4670
Sound Card
VIA Onboard HD Audio
Monitor(s) Displays
LG W2252TQ
Hard Drives
250 GB Western Digital RE3 (X2) - Raid0
1 TB Western Digital RE3
PSU
Raidmax RX-730SS
Case
Rosewill Destroyer
I actually bought a WD RE3 drive for my data drive. Paid $50 more than the Caviar Black. So I'm considering returning the RE3 for a different drive to use for my data, and spend the $50 somewhere else. I like the 5 year warranty that comes with the Caviar Black (just because I've had a few drives that fail a few months after the 3 years) but I noticed the Green has 64 MB cache but is 5,400 RPM.

The RE drives are designed to be used in a Raid setup. The Caviar Green will vary their speed from 5400-7200 RPM depending on need. I prefer the Caviar Black for their speed, size and 5 yr warranty. They do not play nice in a Raid setup. I have two in my system. One is for the OS, programs and working data. The second is for Data storage.

Jim :geek:
 

My Computer

Computer type
PC/Desktop
Computer Manufacturer/Model Number
Home Built
OS
Windows 8.1 Pro w/Media Center 64bit, Windows 7 HP 64bit
CPU
Phenom II X6 1100T
Motherboard
ASUS M5A99X EVO
Memory
Crucial Balistic 8gb DDR3-1866 CL9
Graphics Card(s)
MSI R6850 Cyclone IGD5 PE
Sound Card
On Board
Monitor(s) Displays
ASUS VE258Q 25" LED with DVI-HDMI-DisplayPort
Screen Resolution
1920 x 1080
Hard Drives
Two WD Cavier Black 2TB Sata III, WD My Book Essential 2TB USB 3.0
PSU
Seasonic X650 80 Plus GOLD Modular
Case
Corsair 400R
Cooling
Antec Kuhler H2O 620, Two 120mm and four 140mm
Keyboard
Logitech K120
Mouse
Logitech Marble Mouse USB, Logitech Precision Game Pad
Internet Speed
15MB
Antivirus
Norton IS 2013, Malwarebytes Pro Beta 2
Browser
IE-11, FF-27
Other Info
APC UPS ES 750, Netgear WNR3500L Gigabit & Wireless N Router with SamKnows Test Program, Motorola SB6120 Gigabit Cable Modem. Brother HL-2170W Laser Printer, Epson V300 Scanner
Good choice going with the Caviar Black :thumbsup:
 

My Computer

Computer type
PC/Desktop
Computer Manufacturer/Model Number
Custom built by me.
OS
Windows 10 Pro
CPU
Intel Core i7-4770K (3.5Ghz)
Motherboard
Gigabyte G1 Sniper 5 (F10 Bios)
Memory
32 gig Corsair Dominator Platinum (4x8Gig)
Graphics Card(s)
Sapphire Tri-X R9 Fury
Sound Card
Soundblaster ZXR
Monitor(s) Displays
NEC PA242W 24" LCD Monitor
Screen Resolution
1920 x 1200
Hard Drives
Primary - Samsung 850 Pro (512gig), Samsung 840 Pro (256gig), 2TB WD Caviar Black.
PSU
EVGA Supernova 1000 G2
Case
Cooler Master HAF X
Cooling
Corsair H100i with Corsair Air Series SP120 Quiet Fans
Keyboard
Logitech Wireless Wave
Mouse
Logitech Performance MX
Internet Speed
High Speed Cable
Antivirus
Norton Security
Browser
IE11
Other Info
Memory Timings - 1866MHz @ 9-9-9-27-1T @ 1.5 volts
Back
Top