Strange External Drive Problem

pmokover

New member
Local time
9:52 PM
Messages
31
I’m having a strange problem with an external hard drive. I have two of the same model drive and one of them has a problem. I will refer to them as drive #1 (good) and drive #2 (problem). The drives are 1TB, USB3. My PCs are running Windows 7 and they all have USB 3.0 ports.

I have one of these drives connected to my main PC at all times but only one of them at a time - never both at the same time.

Drive #1 always works perfectly.

When I try to write to drive #2, 90% of the time it “stalls” for as much as a minute before it starts writing. (10% of the time it works normally.) This happens whether I manually copy a file to it using Windows Explorer or use a program to save files to it. It just stalls but most of the time it eventually un-stalls and writes.

This is what I have tried so far:

1. Tried drive #2 on two other PCs. Same problem with both other PCs.

2. Tried drive #2 with different cables and different USB3 ports. Same problem with all.

3. Checked Windows 7 security settings. All OK and all are set the same for both drives. I also checked the various properties settings for the drives and everything looks correct there. I also checked for an updated driver and I already have the latest. I also have all of the latest updates for Windows 7.

4. Tried drive #2 (which is USB3) on a USB2 port. Same problem.

5. Re-formatted drive #2 and started from scratch. The problem remains.

6. Contacted the manufacturer (LaCie) and tried everything they suggested. The problem remains and they have no additional clues.

7. I returned drive #2 and ordered another one of the same model from a different vendor. The replacement has the same problem.

8. I returned the replacement and ordered another replacement from the manufacturer (LaCie). The second replacement has the same problem.

All this time drive #1 continues to work perfectly. Again, both drives are the same model.

I’m baffled by this one. Any clues appreciated.

Thanks.
Peter
 

My Computer

OS
Windows 7
baffling indeed.

maybe it doesn't like being referred to as 'number 2' ;)

(sorry it's not much help)

so even when it's replaced with a completely different drive, power supply and cables, it doesn't work?

maybe they made a bad batch of drives, and you were unlucky?

if it were me, i would try getting my money back (plus compensation for all the hassle) and getting a whole new different make of drive.
 

My Computer

Computer Manufacturer/Model Number
mickey megabyte 1234
OS
ultimate 64 sp1
CPU
i5 2500K [email protected]
Motherboard
MSI P67A-GD53
Memory
8 gigs GSkill Ripjaws 1600
Graphics Card(s)
amd hd6950
Sound Card
creative x-fi gamer
Monitor(s) Displays
samsung 24"
Screen Resolution
1920x1080
Hard Drives
ocz vertex 2e 60 gig, samsung f3 1tb, buffalo 2tb ext
PSU
antec 550
Case
antec three hundred
Cooling
i'm a cooling fan
Keyboard
saitek eclipse ii
Mouse
logitech g3
Internet Speed
about 4 Mbps
Other Info
i love win7
maybe they made a bad batch of drives, and you were unlucky?

That's certainly a possibility. I've been through four of these drives. One works perfectly. The other three don't. Each of the other three came from a different vendor. It would have to be a big batch of bad drives to affect three vendors.

Peter
 

My Computer

OS
Windows 7
Back
Top