Which one?

ICIT2LOL

Confusion Therapist
Guru
Gold Member
VIP
Local time
7:47 PM
Messages
20,778
Location
Central West NSW
After Christmas I a thinking of building a basic general use machine for my partner and I cannot choose between an Ivy or Haswell build.
The two processors I was looking at were Intel Pentium G3220 or the Intel Pentium G2130Haswell and Ivy respectively.

The problem is of course the lack of any Z77 boards and the expense of the Z87 boards at reasonable prices as I not wanting to get too carried away.
The two I had picked out were the Gigabyte GA-B75M-D3H (1155 socket) or the ASUS H81M-E (1150) socket both are around the same price.
 

My Computer

Computer type
PC/Desktop
Computer Manufacturer/Model Number
Own build (new) Desk1 / Asus ROG Win 7 / Desk2 1st build
OS
Desk1 7 Home Prem / Desk2 10 Pro / Main lap Asus ROG 10 Pro 2 laptop Toshiba 7 Pro Asus P2520 7 & 10
CPU
Desk1 i5 3750K / Laptop i7 GTX 860M / Desk2 i5 2500
Motherboard
Desk1 Asus P877-V / Desk2 Gigabyte H67 UD3H / Laptop ?
Memory
Desk1 8GB (1866) / Desk2 16GB (1333) / Laptop 8Gb DDR3
Graphics Card(s)
Desk 1& 2NVidia GTX 650 & Laptops on board Intel
Sound Card
Desk 1 & 2 -XONAR DG Realtek High Def audio Laptop
Monitor(s) Displays
Desk 1 Benq HD 2450 / Desk2 Philips 24" / Laptop 17.5"
Screen Resolution
1920x1080 D1 & D2 & Laptop 1
Hard Drives
Desk1 Samsung 120GB 830 SSD
Asus ROG 256GB 850 Pro SSD
Desk2 Samsung 840 256 SSD
Toshiba 120GB EVO
PSU
Desk 1 Corsair HX 1050/ Laptop ? / Desk 2 Corsair HX 650
Case
Desk 1 Cooler HAF XM ? Toshiba laptop / Desk2 Coolermaster
Cooling
Fans on all Desk1 -2 Desk2 - all Coolermasters 5 Laptop ?
Keyboard
Desk 1 MS Sidewinder X6 Desk 2 MS Sidewinder X 4
Mouse
Desk 1&2 - Gigabyte MS 900 gamer - laptop - Logitec wireless
Internet Speed
ADSL2+
Other Info
One other Desktop (tester) and spare Toshba laptop both with SSD's
Running Kaspersky 2016 ISS on all machines config'd identically
Logitec audio stereo systems on each machine (x3)
Canon MG5250MFC
Router/modem TP-Link running WPA2SK

My Computer

Computer type
PC/Desktop
Computer Manufacturer/Model Number
Custom
OS
10 Pro x64
CPU
Ryzen 9 3900X
Motherboard
Asrock x370 Tachi
Memory
64GB(4x16GB) DDR4
Graphics Card(s)
EVGA 1080ti FTW3
Sound Card
ASUS Xonar Essence STX (V4 Bursons), ODAC rev B, NFB-11, O2
Monitor(s) Displays
3xASUS PB278Q/R, Optoma HD142X
Screen Resolution
3x1440p, 1080p
Hard Drives
512GB 850 EVO(OS, Programs)
4TB (Movies)
3TB (Downloads)
3TB (Programs)
1TB HDD (Games)
2x6TB R1 (videos)
PSU
AX760
Case
Fractal Define R5
Cooling
NH-D15S
Keyboard
Massdrop Ctrl with Box Navy's
Mouse
G903, Alioth XXL Mat
Internet Speed
280/40
Antivirus
MBAM, ESET
Browser
Canary 64 Bit
Other Info
I also own a Thinkpad P50 Xeon 4K, X220T, X1C5
Yep RVC I might just do that with an AMD instead as the Z77 boards out here are horrendously expensive and in very short supply thanks to Intel:mad:
Newegg doesn't ship to here or I would go with the 77 as there have been fair bit of bother with the 87 boards. The build I am not really that limited by budget I suppose I just didn't want to go more the $500 or thereabouts so it is why I chose the Pentium over say the i3 because it is about half the price of the base i3 core.
I suppose she isn't in that much of a hurry so perhaps I should keep looking round for the alternatives I just thought maybe the Pentiums would be ok.
 

My Computer

Computer type
PC/Desktop
Computer Manufacturer/Model Number
Own build (new) Desk1 / Asus ROG Win 7 / Desk2 1st build
OS
Desk1 7 Home Prem / Desk2 10 Pro / Main lap Asus ROG 10 Pro 2 laptop Toshiba 7 Pro Asus P2520 7 & 10
CPU
Desk1 i5 3750K / Laptop i7 GTX 860M / Desk2 i5 2500
Motherboard
Desk1 Asus P877-V / Desk2 Gigabyte H67 UD3H / Laptop ?
Memory
Desk1 8GB (1866) / Desk2 16GB (1333) / Laptop 8Gb DDR3
Graphics Card(s)
Desk 1& 2NVidia GTX 650 & Laptops on board Intel
Sound Card
Desk 1 & 2 -XONAR DG Realtek High Def audio Laptop
Monitor(s) Displays
Desk 1 Benq HD 2450 / Desk2 Philips 24" / Laptop 17.5"
Screen Resolution
1920x1080 D1 & D2 & Laptop 1
Hard Drives
Desk1 Samsung 120GB 830 SSD
Asus ROG 256GB 850 Pro SSD
Desk2 Samsung 840 256 SSD
Toshiba 120GB EVO
PSU
Desk 1 Corsair HX 1050/ Laptop ? / Desk 2 Corsair HX 650
Case
Desk 1 Cooler HAF XM ? Toshiba laptop / Desk2 Coolermaster
Cooling
Fans on all Desk1 -2 Desk2 - all Coolermasters 5 Laptop ?
Keyboard
Desk 1 MS Sidewinder X6 Desk 2 MS Sidewinder X 4
Mouse
Desk 1&2 - Gigabyte MS 900 gamer - laptop - Logitec wireless
Internet Speed
ADSL2+
Other Info
One other Desktop (tester) and spare Toshba laptop both with SSD's
Running Kaspersky 2016 ISS on all machines config'd identically
Logitec audio stereo systems on each machine (x3)
Canon MG5250MFC
Router/modem TP-Link running WPA2SK

My Computer

Computer type
PC/Desktop
Computer Manufacturer/Model Number
Custom
OS
10 Pro x64
CPU
Ryzen 9 3900X
Motherboard
Asrock x370 Tachi
Memory
64GB(4x16GB) DDR4
Graphics Card(s)
EVGA 1080ti FTW3
Sound Card
ASUS Xonar Essence STX (V4 Bursons), ODAC rev B, NFB-11, O2
Monitor(s) Displays
3xASUS PB278Q/R, Optoma HD142X
Screen Resolution
3x1440p, 1080p
Hard Drives
512GB 850 EVO(OS, Programs)
4TB (Movies)
3TB (Downloads)
3TB (Programs)
1TB HDD (Games)
2x6TB R1 (videos)
PSU
AX760
Case
Fractal Define R5
Cooling
NH-D15S
Keyboard
Massdrop Ctrl with Box Navy's
Mouse
G903, Alioth XXL Mat
Internet Speed
280/40
Antivirus
MBAM, ESET
Browser
Canary 64 Bit
Other Info
I also own a Thinkpad P50 Xeon 4K, X220T, X1C5
Well our prices RVC are well a lot more than what is available in the US which is why I chose that Pentium to give you some idea
Intel Core i3 3220T [BX80637I33220T] - $155.00 : PC Case Gear

AMD FX 4130 4-Core Black Edition Processor [FD4130FRGUBOX] - $109.00 : PC Case Gear

Gigabyte GA-Z77-HD3 Motherboard [GA-Z77-HD3] - $119.00 : PC Case Gear

Gigabyte GA-970A-D3P Motherboard [GA-970A-D3P] - $115.00 : PC Case Gear

So throw in a case HDD RAM PSU - really just the basics and it quickly adds up $500 is pretty conservative and probably means having to go a cheap Pentium and board :(
 

My Computer

Computer type
PC/Desktop
Computer Manufacturer/Model Number
Own build (new) Desk1 / Asus ROG Win 7 / Desk2 1st build
OS
Desk1 7 Home Prem / Desk2 10 Pro / Main lap Asus ROG 10 Pro 2 laptop Toshiba 7 Pro Asus P2520 7 & 10
CPU
Desk1 i5 3750K / Laptop i7 GTX 860M / Desk2 i5 2500
Motherboard
Desk1 Asus P877-V / Desk2 Gigabyte H67 UD3H / Laptop ?
Memory
Desk1 8GB (1866) / Desk2 16GB (1333) / Laptop 8Gb DDR3
Graphics Card(s)
Desk 1& 2NVidia GTX 650 & Laptops on board Intel
Sound Card
Desk 1 & 2 -XONAR DG Realtek High Def audio Laptop
Monitor(s) Displays
Desk 1 Benq HD 2450 / Desk2 Philips 24" / Laptop 17.5"
Screen Resolution
1920x1080 D1 & D2 & Laptop 1
Hard Drives
Desk1 Samsung 120GB 830 SSD
Asus ROG 256GB 850 Pro SSD
Desk2 Samsung 840 256 SSD
Toshiba 120GB EVO
PSU
Desk 1 Corsair HX 1050/ Laptop ? / Desk 2 Corsair HX 650
Case
Desk 1 Cooler HAF XM ? Toshiba laptop / Desk2 Coolermaster
Cooling
Fans on all Desk1 -2 Desk2 - all Coolermasters 5 Laptop ?
Keyboard
Desk 1 MS Sidewinder X6 Desk 2 MS Sidewinder X 4
Mouse
Desk 1&2 - Gigabyte MS 900 gamer - laptop - Logitec wireless
Internet Speed
ADSL2+
Other Info
One other Desktop (tester) and spare Toshba laptop both with SSD's
Running Kaspersky 2016 ISS on all machines config'd identically
Logitec audio stereo systems on each machine (x3)
Canon MG5250MFC
Router/modem TP-Link running WPA2SK
yeah i see what you mean i built this up for you real quick and you could get a cheaper case and psu but I always go kinda overkill on the psu since you might need to add to the system later and want a decent brand so that when it says it has over volt protection it actually does lol, and at least some 80 scale rating. but yeah basically 500 wow. EDIT: went back to build same thing with intel and omg that is overpriced as hell for those chips! stick with the amd as the intel imo is not worth what your paying for them and that's just the cpu before a motherboard. Also that MB you picked with the 970 chip is much better than the one i picked and i would get it instead if you can eat the cost.
 

Attachments

  • setup.PNG
    setup.PNG
    70.9 KB · Views: 3

My Computer

Computer type
PC/Desktop
Computer Manufacturer/Model Number
Custom
OS
10 Pro x64
CPU
Ryzen 9 3900X
Motherboard
Asrock x370 Tachi
Memory
64GB(4x16GB) DDR4
Graphics Card(s)
EVGA 1080ti FTW3
Sound Card
ASUS Xonar Essence STX (V4 Bursons), ODAC rev B, NFB-11, O2
Monitor(s) Displays
3xASUS PB278Q/R, Optoma HD142X
Screen Resolution
3x1440p, 1080p
Hard Drives
512GB 850 EVO(OS, Programs)
4TB (Movies)
3TB (Downloads)
3TB (Programs)
1TB HDD (Games)
2x6TB R1 (videos)
PSU
AX760
Case
Fractal Define R5
Cooling
NH-D15S
Keyboard
Massdrop Ctrl with Box Navy's
Mouse
G903, Alioth XXL Mat
Internet Speed
280/40
Antivirus
MBAM, ESET
Browser
Canary 64 Bit
Other Info
I also own a Thinkpad P50 Xeon 4K, X220T, X1C5

My Computer

Computer type
PC/Desktop
Computer Manufacturer/Model Number
Own build (new) Desk1 / Asus ROG Win 7 / Desk2 1st build
OS
Desk1 7 Home Prem / Desk2 10 Pro / Main lap Asus ROG 10 Pro 2 laptop Toshiba 7 Pro Asus P2520 7 & 10
CPU
Desk1 i5 3750K / Laptop i7 GTX 860M / Desk2 i5 2500
Motherboard
Desk1 Asus P877-V / Desk2 Gigabyte H67 UD3H / Laptop ?
Memory
Desk1 8GB (1866) / Desk2 16GB (1333) / Laptop 8Gb DDR3
Graphics Card(s)
Desk 1& 2NVidia GTX 650 & Laptops on board Intel
Sound Card
Desk 1 & 2 -XONAR DG Realtek High Def audio Laptop
Monitor(s) Displays
Desk 1 Benq HD 2450 / Desk2 Philips 24" / Laptop 17.5"
Screen Resolution
1920x1080 D1 & D2 & Laptop 1
Hard Drives
Desk1 Samsung 120GB 830 SSD
Asus ROG 256GB 850 Pro SSD
Desk2 Samsung 840 256 SSD
Toshiba 120GB EVO
PSU
Desk 1 Corsair HX 1050/ Laptop ? / Desk 2 Corsair HX 650
Case
Desk 1 Cooler HAF XM ? Toshiba laptop / Desk2 Coolermaster
Cooling
Fans on all Desk1 -2 Desk2 - all Coolermasters 5 Laptop ?
Keyboard
Desk 1 MS Sidewinder X6 Desk 2 MS Sidewinder X 4
Mouse
Desk 1&2 - Gigabyte MS 900 gamer - laptop - Logitec wireless
Internet Speed
ADSL2+
Other Info
One other Desktop (tester) and spare Toshba laptop both with SSD's
Running Kaspersky 2016 ISS on all machines config'd identically
Logitec audio stereo systems on each machine (x3)
Canon MG5250MFC
Router/modem TP-Link running WPA2SK
Jeez thanks for going to that trouble for me RVC that looks about what I want and as you say I think I would go a Corsair PSU even if it means bit more cash as I would have added in all probability an Asus Xonar DG card ($29) and an Asus GeForce GTX 650 ASUS GeForce GTX 650 1GB [ENGTX650-E-1GD5] - $129.00 : PC Case Gear
as she is a pretty special person to me.
The PSU Corsair VS650 ATX Power Supply [CMPSU-VS650] - $79.00 : PC Case Gear your thoughts mate.:)

Looked up corsairs spec table and it seems plenty for what your building and i would say its okay, my HX620w that i replaced with the ax still works and its almost 8 years old (just wanted to make sure i wasn't stressing it to much as it was starting to run really hot with all my oc'ing). that one has a three year warranty idk if that matters to you. it looks imo better than a cx-600 minus the 80 rating though so i say its the best bang for your buck at that site. is that the only place you can get your parts from?
 

My Computer

Computer type
PC/Desktop
Computer Manufacturer/Model Number
Custom
OS
10 Pro x64
CPU
Ryzen 9 3900X
Motherboard
Asrock x370 Tachi
Memory
64GB(4x16GB) DDR4
Graphics Card(s)
EVGA 1080ti FTW3
Sound Card
ASUS Xonar Essence STX (V4 Bursons), ODAC rev B, NFB-11, O2
Monitor(s) Displays
3xASUS PB278Q/R, Optoma HD142X
Screen Resolution
3x1440p, 1080p
Hard Drives
512GB 850 EVO(OS, Programs)
4TB (Movies)
3TB (Downloads)
3TB (Programs)
1TB HDD (Games)
2x6TB R1 (videos)
PSU
AX760
Case
Fractal Define R5
Cooling
NH-D15S
Keyboard
Massdrop Ctrl with Box Navy's
Mouse
G903, Alioth XXL Mat
Internet Speed
280/40
Antivirus
MBAM, ESET
Browser
Canary 64 Bit
Other Info
I also own a Thinkpad P50 Xeon 4K, X220T, X1C5
Yes mate I have done three builds and always buy from these people as I know and trust them plus they are usually the cheapest around for products and shipping - they are in Melbourne and me in NSW about 700km away.

My last build the Ivy has a HX 1050 in (was on special) and the Sandy before I used a HX 650 both brilliant PSU's so I know the Corsairs are good..

PS Check your notifications at top:p
 

My Computer

Computer type
PC/Desktop
Computer Manufacturer/Model Number
Own build (new) Desk1 / Asus ROG Win 7 / Desk2 1st build
OS
Desk1 7 Home Prem / Desk2 10 Pro / Main lap Asus ROG 10 Pro 2 laptop Toshiba 7 Pro Asus P2520 7 & 10
CPU
Desk1 i5 3750K / Laptop i7 GTX 860M / Desk2 i5 2500
Motherboard
Desk1 Asus P877-V / Desk2 Gigabyte H67 UD3H / Laptop ?
Memory
Desk1 8GB (1866) / Desk2 16GB (1333) / Laptop 8Gb DDR3
Graphics Card(s)
Desk 1& 2NVidia GTX 650 & Laptops on board Intel
Sound Card
Desk 1 & 2 -XONAR DG Realtek High Def audio Laptop
Monitor(s) Displays
Desk 1 Benq HD 2450 / Desk2 Philips 24" / Laptop 17.5"
Screen Resolution
1920x1080 D1 & D2 & Laptop 1
Hard Drives
Desk1 Samsung 120GB 830 SSD
Asus ROG 256GB 850 Pro SSD
Desk2 Samsung 840 256 SSD
Toshiba 120GB EVO
PSU
Desk 1 Corsair HX 1050/ Laptop ? / Desk 2 Corsair HX 650
Case
Desk 1 Cooler HAF XM ? Toshiba laptop / Desk2 Coolermaster
Cooling
Fans on all Desk1 -2 Desk2 - all Coolermasters 5 Laptop ?
Keyboard
Desk 1 MS Sidewinder X6 Desk 2 MS Sidewinder X 4
Mouse
Desk 1&2 - Gigabyte MS 900 gamer - laptop - Logitec wireless
Internet Speed
ADSL2+
Other Info
One other Desktop (tester) and spare Toshba laptop both with SSD's
Running Kaspersky 2016 ISS on all machines config'd identically
Logitec audio stereo systems on each machine (x3)
Canon MG5250MFC
Router/modem TP-Link running WPA2SK
I have no notifications showing lol. Oh thanks for the REP!
 

Attachments

  • uh.PNG
    uh.PNG
    2.2 KB · Views: 12

My Computer

Computer type
PC/Desktop
Computer Manufacturer/Model Number
Custom
OS
10 Pro x64
CPU
Ryzen 9 3900X
Motherboard
Asrock x370 Tachi
Memory
64GB(4x16GB) DDR4
Graphics Card(s)
EVGA 1080ti FTW3
Sound Card
ASUS Xonar Essence STX (V4 Bursons), ODAC rev B, NFB-11, O2
Monitor(s) Displays
3xASUS PB278Q/R, Optoma HD142X
Screen Resolution
3x1440p, 1080p
Hard Drives
512GB 850 EVO(OS, Programs)
4TB (Movies)
3TB (Downloads)
3TB (Programs)
1TB HDD (Games)
2x6TB R1 (videos)
PSU
AX760
Case
Fractal Define R5
Cooling
NH-D15S
Keyboard
Massdrop Ctrl with Box Navy's
Mouse
G903, Alioth XXL Mat
Internet Speed
280/40
Antivirus
MBAM, ESET
Browser
Canary 64 Bit
Other Info
I also own a Thinkpad P50 Xeon 4K, X220T, X1C5

My Computer

Computer type
PC/Desktop
Computer Manufacturer/Model Number
Own build (new) Desk1 / Asus ROG Win 7 / Desk2 1st build
OS
Desk1 7 Home Prem / Desk2 10 Pro / Main lap Asus ROG 10 Pro 2 laptop Toshiba 7 Pro Asus P2520 7 & 10
CPU
Desk1 i5 3750K / Laptop i7 GTX 860M / Desk2 i5 2500
Motherboard
Desk1 Asus P877-V / Desk2 Gigabyte H67 UD3H / Laptop ?
Memory
Desk1 8GB (1866) / Desk2 16GB (1333) / Laptop 8Gb DDR3
Graphics Card(s)
Desk 1& 2NVidia GTX 650 & Laptops on board Intel
Sound Card
Desk 1 & 2 -XONAR DG Realtek High Def audio Laptop
Monitor(s) Displays
Desk 1 Benq HD 2450 / Desk2 Philips 24" / Laptop 17.5"
Screen Resolution
1920x1080 D1 & D2 & Laptop 1
Hard Drives
Desk1 Samsung 120GB 830 SSD
Asus ROG 256GB 850 Pro SSD
Desk2 Samsung 840 256 SSD
Toshiba 120GB EVO
PSU
Desk 1 Corsair HX 1050/ Laptop ? / Desk 2 Corsair HX 650
Case
Desk 1 Cooler HAF XM ? Toshiba laptop / Desk2 Coolermaster
Cooling
Fans on all Desk1 -2 Desk2 - all Coolermasters 5 Laptop ?
Keyboard
Desk 1 MS Sidewinder X6 Desk 2 MS Sidewinder X 4
Mouse
Desk 1&2 - Gigabyte MS 900 gamer - laptop - Logitec wireless
Internet Speed
ADSL2+
Other Info
One other Desktop (tester) and spare Toshba laptop both with SSD's
Running Kaspersky 2016 ISS on all machines config'd identically
Logitec audio stereo systems on each machine (x3)
Canon MG5250MFC
Router/modem TP-Link running WPA2SK
Back
Top