Good Idea, Poorly Executed
IMO they are a typical MS idea.
B+ for imagination.
C- for execution.
They'd be more useful:
- If more programs linked to them properly (or could be easily associated with them).
- If they were easier to control.
- If you could add folders in bulk, instead of one-at-a time.
Some examples.
Even though I have a Music Library, when I try to save a playlist (in Winamp) the default save location is the Documents Library.
Also there was a problem with WMP12.
It constantly loaded in all Library locations, despite being told not to.
I don't need 10,000+ pictures being loaded, when I just want to play a mp3.
That's one of the reasons that I use Winamp.
If you have Indexing disabled, you can't perform searches in the Library on local folders.
You have to go to the folder itself.
I have placed Shortcuts (to my most used folders) in the associated Library locations.
When trying to open/save a file, Windows Explorer opens the Document Library, I just use the Shortcut to go to the folder I want, instead of swapping to the "correct" Library location.
IMO, Libraries work best for disorganised people, who scatter their folders about their HDDs at random.
Unfortunately they probably can't use them anyway (they aren't organised enough).
