So much depends on how you use your printer. Do you need all in one features (print, scan, copy, fax)? Can you make do with just B&W? How many copies per month do you make?
For several years I used a Lexmark X1150 all in one. But I didn't print a lot each month. I found out the ink cartridges dried out rather quickly and replacments were costing me a small fortune. Based on my personal needs I switched to a monochrome refurbished
Brother HL2240D laser printer. I paid about £50 for the printer (which came with a "sample" toner cartridge good for about 400 copies.) High-yield toner cartridges cost about £18 and they easily give me 2,000 full sheet (single spaced) copies. The toner powder never dries out and gets almost completely used up. Unlike ink jet cartridges that seem to have about 25% of the ink left.
Canon, Brother, Samsung, HP and Lexmark seem to consistently get good user reviews here in the Colonies for reliability, service and cost per sheet whether ink jet or laser. Sorry I can't be more specific on a particular model.