Firewall

[bagavan]

I have MSE and Malwarebytes PRO..Which firewall is better the default windows one or comodo?

 

[Golden]

Hi,

Windows Firewall will work well with MSE and MBAM. I'm unsure about Comodo, although I suspect you won't have any problems.

On the question of which one is "best", thats a hard one to answer....how do you test that? Leak tests? I think you will be quite OK with Windows Firewall.

Regards,
Golden​

 

[bagavan]

In the leak test with windows firewall it scored 190/340

 

[ken9122]

For most users the default windows firewall is fine. Comobo is a good alternative.

 

[bagavan]

Even When I switched the firewall to comodo I got the same score..why?

 

[Borg 386]

If you want to do a little bit of investigating and see all the connections on your sys when your online, you can d/l this utility:

TCPView is a Windows program that will show you detailed listings of all TCP and UDP endpoints on your system, including the local and remote addresses and state of TCP connections.

TCPView for Windows

Also if you would like an in depth guide to configuring Comodo, d/l this, it's a long read but it'll answer your questions about configurations, set ups, etc. Give it a read, see if anything is configured wrong and after making adjustments, if need be, run the test again

http://personalfirewall.comodo.com/Comodo_Internet_Security_User_Guide.pdf

On thing I would not recommend is zone alarm. Based on what I have read on various posts, it does not play well with Win 7.

 

[CanIHaz]

Even When I switched the firewall to comodo I got the same score..why?

Because you got to configure comodo to make it stronger. To get a perfect score on the CLT w/ comodo, you gotta put the configuration of comodo to Proactive security. Then you gotta disable the sandbox of comodo and run the CLT. Block everything that pops up.

 

[Borg 386]

That's why I posted the link for the user guide CanIHaz.

It's actually got quite a plethora of settings and the read is over 300 pages long, but it will give you the knowledge to configure it the way you want and the way it should be.

My test scored 340/340

 

[Maxxwire]

I've been using Comodo since v3.8 and the settings needed to get a 340/340 score on the Leak Tests change slightly from version to version as the features change. After I updated to the latest Comodo v5.3 with the Firewall in custom Policy Mode and Defense+ HIPS in Safe Mode I simply reset it to Proactive Configuration using the Comodo Tray Icon, Disabled the Sandbox, ran the Leak Tests denying all requests and got a 340/340 score.

~Maxx~

 

[Creer]

In the leak test with windows firewall it scored 190/340

But it's really not a firewall job I mean that what you see in your CLT test results.
There are only few test for FW in CLT all other test mainly testing HIPS/SRP/policy based... security layer.
The same story is with Matousec tests.

 

[Maxxwire]

the fact that comodo doesn't seem to suck up so many system resources and has a pretty straight forward gui and easy to understand for even the novoce to setup....At least I would think so....

Joules- when I read this I went to Win7 Task Manager and took a screen shot of the Comodo v5.3 Firewall and Defense+ RAM usage...

~Maxx~