Which Linux distro will you use for a Portable Operating System?

Imrankhan

Enthusiast
Power User
VIP
Local time
7:50 PM
Messages
206
Location
Chennai, India
There are lot of Portable Linux Operating Systems. Its difficult to choose one. I just want to know what linux distro do you prefer...
My requirements are...
*Should be preloaded with VLC, Firefox/Chromium, LibreOffice and some basic apps.
*Should have easy GUI.
*Should boot in few seconds even with old pentium 3 hardware.
*Should be lightweight (less size)
*Should be error free (less crashes, hangups)
*Should not be a battery sucker(low power consumption)...
*Should support newer wireless (Intel, Atheros & Ralink) hardwares.
I am going to use it in a CD/DVD.

Suggest your preferance to me...
 

My Computer My Computer

Computer type
Laptop
Computer Manufacturer/Model Number
Dell XPS L502x
OS
Windows 7 Home Premium 64bit
CPU
Intel Core i7 2670QM
Motherboard
Intel HM67 Mobile Express Chipset
Memory
Samsung 8GB 1333Mhz
Graphics Card(s)
nVidia Geforce 540M GT 2GB
Sound Card
Realtek High Definition Audio
Monitor(s) Displays
15.6" Dell Standard RGB-LED Backlit Display
Screen Resolution
1366x768
Hard Drives
Seagate Momentus 2.5" 750GB HDD 5400rpm
Internet Speed
3.1 Mbits/s
Antivirus
AVG Free, Kaspersky
Browser
Google chrome

My Computer My Computer

Computer Manufacturer/Model Number
HP, Dell, Gateway, Toshiba - 4 laptops and 2 desktops
OS
Vista, Windows7, Mint Mate, Zorin, Windows 8
CPU
from 1.6GHz Duo to i7
Monitor(s) Displays
2x HP w2207
Hard Drives
5x HDD, 7x SSD, 12x Externals
Keyboard
with trackball - no mices
Mouse
Trackball mice
Internet Speed
DSL 6000
There are lot of Portable Linux Operating Systems. Its difficult to choose one. I just want to know what linux distro do you prefer...
My requirements are...
Since I'm a key contributor to the Ubuntu forums and now, to the Mint forums, I'd provide my views ...
*Should be preloaded with VLC, Firefox/Chromium, LibreOffice and some basic apps.
Mint tends to come preloaded with more apps than Ubuntu. Both of these constantly argue about which is most popular, but Mint popularity soared last year and continues to grow. It retained the "legacy" menu style interface that lots of folks (including me) like, as opposed to the cell-phone-like desktop of Unity.

You will probably have to install apps yourself, regardless of which Distro you choose.
*Should have easy GUI.
Sorry, but this is impossible to address -- what's "easy" for one person might be "hard" for another. Requirements worded like this are useless. You should go to DistroWatch.com, and look through the Distros yourself, and decide which of the desktops you like.

Ubuntu comes with Unity (cell-phone-like) by default, but also has Xubuntu (with Xfce) and other desktops. Mint comes with Cinnamon (menu-like) but also has Mate.
*Should boot in few seconds even with old pentium 3 hardware.
Again, what does "few" mean? And, let's get REAL here -- any recent Linux distro is NOT going to boot in a "few" seconds on anything but powerful hardware. I have a 6-core, 3.2GHx AMD processor with high-speed memory, and it still takes 40 seconds to boot into Ubuntu or Mint -- and with Mint, I'm using a SSD!

Both Ubuntu and Mint have minimum hardware requirements, which an old Pentium 3, with very limited memory, is NOT going to meet.

If you want something to run on that hardware, you will be relegated to something like Lubuntu or Damn Small Linux, or Puppy Linux -- which are NOT going to give you the rich experience of something more powerful like Ubuntu or Mint.

*Should be lightweight (less size)
Sigh ... all these vague terms... What is "lightweight"? Less size -- less than what amount?

The true "lightweight" Distros are the three I mentioned above with the "size" shrinking in their order from left to right in the list.
*Should be error free (less crashes, hangups)
Then, you want an OS that is NOT written by human beings -- because anything written by human beings is, by definition, NOT capable of being error-free.

That said, in terms of Linux distros, the longer it has been out, the more bugs have been found and fixed. So, in terms of Ubuntu, if you were to install 13.04, that came out only in April this year, and still is working through fixing serious bugs. Ubuntu 12.10 came out last October and is more stable. Ubuntu 12.04 came out last April and is even more stable.

In stark contrast, the pre-release versions (Like Ubuntu Saucy) are riddled with bugs because they are still being written and won't be ready for release until October.

In terms of crashes and hangups, again, any OS written by humans is going to have these. Just visit the Ubuntu or Mint forums on any day and scroll through the posts about such problems.
*Should not be a battery sucker(low power consumption)...
Then, you've pretty much ruled out any recent Linux distro. Why? Because there are known Linux kernel bugs in which processor idling is not handled properly. Once again, read through the Ubuntu or Mint forums about hardware and you will see post after post with folks complaining about their laptop overheating, and their batteries running down, since they installed a Llinux distro. And, while there are some utilities (like Juniper and TPL) that can sometimes offset some of the overheating, they don't always work -- especially on recent laptops that use Hybrid Graphics.
*Should support newer wireless (Intel, Atheros & Ralink) hardwares.
Here's where you run into the infamous Linux "catch-22": the newer the kernel version, the newer the drivers built into it. So for new hardware, you want the latest kernel. But the newer the kernel, the newer the release, the more buggy (i.e., unstable) it is. So, you trade improved drivers for instability. And, once you start hacking a Linux distro to force a new kernel into an old version, you ask for major problems down the road.
I am going to use it in a CD/DVD.
Not only a bad idea, but for all but the very smallest Linux distro installations, not nearly enough space. You might be able to force a minimalist install onto a DVD (4GB), but you would then encounter really POOR performance, as you will be doing reads from the DVD almost constantly.

If you really want to run from a DVD, you would do better simply burning a Linux distro ISO to a DVD and running from that (something historically known as LiveCD mode, although USB sticks are most often used today) -- without trying to install it. But be prepared to wait several minutes for it to boot to a desktop, and after that, wait again every time you try run something.

Good Luck.
 

My Computer My Computer

Computer type
PC/Desktop
Computer Manufacturer/Model Number
Custom
OS
Win7 Pro 32-bit, Win8 Pro 32-bit
CPU
AMD Phenom II X6 1090T
Motherboard
Gigabyte
Memory
4GB ddr3 1300
Graphics Card(s)
AMD HD 4290 onboard
Sound Card
Builtin Realtek HD Audio
Monitor(s) Displays
Samsung 24" widescreen, LG 23" widescreen
Screen Resolution
1920x1200/1920x1080
Hard Drives
Kingston 256GB SSD
Keyboard
Logitech Illuminated Keyboard
Mouse
Logitech M705 wireless mouse
Antivirus
Norton Av 2013
Browser
IE v10
I prefer PCLinuxOS KDE 64 as it has a nice looking Grub. I also like Mint 15 , but I am waiting for Mint 15 KDE to come out as Mate and cinnamon are not my cup of tea.
 

My Computer My Computer

Computer type
PC/Desktop
Computer Manufacturer/Model Number
Custom Build
OS
Win 10 Pro 64
CPU
Intel Core i7 960 @3.20 GHz
Motherboard
MSI MS7522
Memory
24.0 GB DDR3
Graphics Card(s)
EVGA GTX 750Ti
Monitor(s) Displays
LG E2341 23 Inch
Screen Resolution
1920x1080
Hard Drives
1TB Western Dgital 1002FAEX-00Y9A0
1TB Hitachi HDS721010CLA322
PSU
700 Watt
Case
Haf 912
Cooling
Fans
Keyboard
Logitech MK710
Mouse
Logitech M705
Internet Speed
Cable
Antivirus
AIS 2015 .10.0.2225
Browser
Firefox 49
Other Info
MalwareBytes Anti-Rootkit utility
yes i am using pclinuxos kde 64 and i like it better then window 7 .
you have to play with quit a bet to find every thing but after you do it is really easy to use and customize also really fast .
 

My Computer My Computer

Computer type
PC/Desktop
Computer Manufacturer/Model Number
custom build by me
OS
window 7 home premium 64 bits
CPU
amd a6 5400k
Motherboard
gigabyte fm2+ f2a88x-up4
Memory
gskill 4 gbs 1333 7-7-7-21
Graphics Card(s)
none
Sound Card
none
Monitor(s) Displays
32 inc sony bravia ex340 hdtv
Screen Resolution
1360x768
Hard Drives
ssd corsair gtx 128 gbs
PSU
rosewill 600w performance serie
Case
aerocool strike x very nice case and very big
Cooling
5 120mm red fans plus a 220 mm red fan
Keyboard
logitech mk 320
Mouse
logitech 320
Internet Speed
????????
Antivirus
malwarebytes- security essensial- spywareblaster
Browser
firefox 28
Other Info
new build about 4 months ago restart time is 19 secs
Back
Top