Kari,
I respect your opinion.
They are a lot of things windows 8 does right, like the improved task manager (my fav thing), the improved usb 3.0 native support, ssd support, the improved security and faster boot times. etc.
People who like windows 8 are not poke and go people, people can like what they like. Some people love 8, and that's great. The average public does not though. I am one of them.
But for users like me who have tried it and honestly used it for several months and still do not like it, that says something. My opinion. For windows 8, a majority of people do not like it.
Yes quite a few people hate it without actually using it, but that happens.
To me it still takes longer to do simple tasks. Don't get me wrong, they have made tremendous improvements. Shutdown has now improved with an easy button right on the start screen so that has helped. As well as easy right click in the bottom right and shut down also listing more advanced commands.
But windows 8 is not made for average users. It is not made for power users. It is a ugly morph of both.
Windows 8 needs to be where it belongs-on a tablet.
Windows 8 needs to decide on it's identity. It is trying to hard to meet both needs, when it should develop into 2 different operating systems. Windows 8 should be re-named windows mobile or something, and then have windows 9 be the full desktop/laptop experience.
I don't need every app taking up my entire screen. I want to multitask. Yes you can snap apps, yes you can resize. But everything is ridiculous giant and cumbersome. It speaks volumes that it has such as low market-share as it does.
Ether way you look at it, while there are a lot of things I like about windows 8, There is a lot more I do not like.
A lot of features are removed in windows 8 that I use. Previous versions is a perfect example. It is a fantastic tool and is gone and replaced with the dumber file history. That requires a external hard drive hooked up at all times to restore previous versions of files. What good is that? Why make it harder to do something?
It is not enough to upgrade for me as it makes it more frustrating to use my pc, even though I learned the "new way" of doing things.
I do like it on tablets though, played around with it for awhile on a asus and lenovo tablet. It is very cool to have the whole windows experience in a tablet. And the surface is not bad at all. The price is but that is a different topic.