I've actually tried both. Something seems wierd with the windows 7 file sharing from what I'm used to.
If I make a folder on either machine (they both have the same two username/passwords as well), set it to shared, and have full access to the user. I can read, but not write, unless I make the "Everyone" account have full control, which is not quite secure, nor how I would think it should work.
Both systems are running windows 7, same version, same username/passwords. Something just isn't working correctly.
Right now, to change files, I am having to use RDP, which kicks my wife off her session (about to apply the terminal patch for that now that I've read enough about it). Have to copy in rdp, minimize, paste, go back to rdp, delete the file... its a pain. Making me want to chuck win7 and go back to XP professional. This is killing productivity.
But yes, the homegroup feature is what I'm trying to use, mainly for simplicity's sake. My wife understands "Share with>Homegroup (Read/Write)" much better than setting up a share manually
