Which is Best Image or Clone

My Computer

Computer Manufacturer/Model Number
HP, Dell, Gateway, Toshiba - 4 laptops and 2 desktops
OS
Vista, Windows7, Mint Mate, Zorin, Windows 8
CPU
from 1.6GHz Duo to i7
Monitor(s) Displays
2x HP w2207
Hard Drives
5x HDD, 7x SSD, 12x Externals
Keyboard
with trackball - no mices
Mouse
Trackball mice
Internet Speed
DSL 6000
A sector by sector image might include the page file or restore points and can be preferable if you were, for instance, a law enforcement officer interested in data recovery at a forensic level---where you had an interest in deleted files. But I can't recall reading of any reasons it might otherwise be preferable. I don't know why one method or the other would be less likely to lose game history.
Restore points...that is one of the things that I had forgotten about. Personally, I don't feel that this would only be of interest to law enforcement...actually, I don't know why it would be of use to them, but then I'm not into that sort of thing.
 

My Computer

Computer Manufacturer/Model Number
DIY
OS
W7x64 Pro, SuSe 12.1/** W7 x64 Pro, XP MCE
CPU
Phenom II 1090T w/Noctua NH-D14 /**4400+ X2 w/CM Hyper TX 3
Motherboard
ASRock 890FX Deluxe 4/**A8N-SLI
Memory
2 x 2GB Patriot PGS34g1600LLKA/**4x1GB Corsair VS
Graphics Card(s)
EVGA GTX460 SC/**EVGA 8800GTS
Sound Card
Asus Xonar D2X/**Xonar D1
Monitor(s) Displays
Acer X233H, Dell E152FPc /**LG M237-WD
Screen Resolution
1920x1080 & 1024x768/**1980x1080
Hard Drives
WDC 2TB, 1.5TB, 1TB, 500GB,Seagate 500GB , Maxtor 80GB /**500GB Seagate & WDC 1TB Black
PSU
CM RS600 w/ APC BX1000G/**Antec 500 TP w/ APC BX1000
Case
HAF922/**Antec 1040IIB
Cooling
3x200mm, 1x140 and 1x120mm/**5x80mm fans
Keyboard
Logitech Media USB/**Saitek Eclipse
Mouse
Cordless Trackman Wheel/**Ditto
Internet Speed
3.3Mbps
Other Info
SB 560 5.1 w/ Sennheiser RS140/**Creative T20 speakers, Dvico FusionHDTV7 Gold RT, Cisco E3000, HP 5510V AIO, Linksys E3000, Belkin F5U237 hub and **F5D8055 adapter
(** = 2nd rig)
seekermeister, if you want to make your life real easy, use this program (works HDD to HDD too) Paragon Paragon Migrate OS to SSD - Overview

Thanks, but I'm fairly happy with True Image. What is there about this program that makes you feel it is easier?
It transfers the OS and the 100MB partition with 2 clicks. I use it mostely for transfer to SSDs. There is makes also all the settings (alignment, etc.).

Since I don't have that 100mb partition, and am not yet into SSDs, I guess it would come down to a few less clicks, but then what's a few clicks when one has nothing better to do.
 

My Computer

Computer Manufacturer/Model Number
DIY
OS
W7x64 Pro, SuSe 12.1/** W7 x64 Pro, XP MCE
CPU
Phenom II 1090T w/Noctua NH-D14 /**4400+ X2 w/CM Hyper TX 3
Motherboard
ASRock 890FX Deluxe 4/**A8N-SLI
Memory
2 x 2GB Patriot PGS34g1600LLKA/**4x1GB Corsair VS
Graphics Card(s)
EVGA GTX460 SC/**EVGA 8800GTS
Sound Card
Asus Xonar D2X/**Xonar D1
Monitor(s) Displays
Acer X233H, Dell E152FPc /**LG M237-WD
Screen Resolution
1920x1080 & 1024x768/**1980x1080
Hard Drives
WDC 2TB, 1.5TB, 1TB, 500GB,Seagate 500GB , Maxtor 80GB /**500GB Seagate & WDC 1TB Black
PSU
CM RS600 w/ APC BX1000G/**Antec 500 TP w/ APC BX1000
Case
HAF922/**Antec 1040IIB
Cooling
3x200mm, 1x140 and 1x120mm/**5x80mm fans
Keyboard
Logitech Media USB/**Saitek Eclipse
Mouse
Cordless Trackman Wheel/**Ditto
Internet Speed
3.3Mbps
Other Info
SB 560 5.1 w/ Sennheiser RS140/**Creative T20 speakers, Dvico FusionHDTV7 Gold RT, Cisco E3000, HP 5510V AIO, Linksys E3000, Belkin F5U237 hub and **F5D8055 adapter
(** = 2nd rig)
I guess you are right. I just like the easy routes.
 

My Computer

Computer Manufacturer/Model Number
HP, Dell, Gateway, Toshiba - 4 laptops and 2 desktops
OS
Vista, Windows7, Mint Mate, Zorin, Windows 8
CPU
from 1.6GHz Duo to i7
Monitor(s) Displays
2x HP w2207
Hard Drives
5x HDD, 7x SSD, 12x Externals
Keyboard
with trackball - no mices
Mouse
Trackball mice
Internet Speed
DSL 6000
It has been said, but bits and pieces here and there, to clarify:


A Cloned Drive (often refereed to as a clone for simplicity & confusion:)) Is a second drive written sector-by-sector (empty space and protected system files, etc) - and DOES require "tyeing up" a Full extra HDD - But on the good side, it is possible to literally use it as a instant replacement, and can be tested to be assured that it copied correctly.

A Cloned Partition - is likewise copied from the original drive's part. to another HDD's part. sector by sector, everything including blank space and system files is copied (I have never know of this allowing the from and to partitions to be on the same drive)

A Raw Image - is just like a clone in many ways - and comes in both flavors (part or drive) depending on the S/W used (it copies sector by sector - and again includes all sectors regardless of content or lack thereof.) It can be stored, albeit a huge file, and later written to the original or a new drive or partition for an exact copy that, yes is similar to a clone, but more versatile to move to desired final location of choice, but cannot be "tested" like a cloned drive can.

And Image file - Is the most commonly used implementation of the four mentioned types of backups, It copies all the files excluding protected system files (pagefile.sys, restore pts, etc) Because it does not copy blank sectors or certain system files it is substantially smaller and can be compressed (unless the drive of origin was compressed prior to backing it up) It is versatile,able to be used on any HDD as needed, on the downside, there are indeed instances that a problem during the shadowing process (which picks the drive/volume apart into copies so it doesn't change in the middle of the op) are either not realized by the software, or damaged after the copy, leading to a corrupt image. It can sometimes be "pseudo-quasi-tested by going through a catalog of files and checking them, but without being installed on the final mass storage media/HDD like a clone would be, there is more processing to be done to reassemble the drive and offers an opportunity for problems to occur. But small and versatile and quick!



So in the end, it depends on your intend purpose for making the backup and amount of extra HDD's you have.

  • I have used True Image many times (hundreds) and only once was an image corrupt that I can remember anyway!
  • O & O is a similar or identical engine with a different UI.
  • And I honestly have never used Paragon Paragon Migrate OS to SSD that had you have had so much luck with, so I can't help, It may be better, equal, or worse, you do have one good opinion of it though so ask around if you might use it, to make yourself feel more confident (although you sound like your mind is made up)
Hope this helps at least consolidate!

Mike:D
 
Last edited:

My Computer

Computer Manufacturer/Model Number
Custom self build - Desktop
OS
MS Windows 7 Home Premium SP1 64-bit (Family Pack Lic.) Upgrade
CPU
AMD Phenom II X6: Black Ed 1090T - AM3 / 3.2GHz / 8MB
Motherboard
Biostar TA790XE3
Memory
2 dual ch sets OCZ DDR3 PC3-10666 Platinum 1333MHz 8GB total
Graphics Card(s)
Onboard
Sound Card
Onboard 5.1 channel HD
Monitor(s) Displays
SyncMaster "Legal-sized" LCD (rotatable)
Screen Resolution
unknown (8.5"x15")? pixels are not known
Hard Drives
HDD1: WD RE3 Enterprize [p/n: WD500ABYS-NDW]
________SATA-II (3Gb/s) 500GB/7200rpm/16MB

HDD2: Deskstar 7K1000.C [p/n: HDS721010CLA332]
________SATA-II (3Gb/s) 1TB/7200rpm/32MB
PSU
Antec 900W mATX 20+4 w/6-8SATA;2MLX;4x6(+2)PCIe[p/n HCG-900]
Case
Mid 10-bay tower - free space design interior & well vented
Cooling
CPU HS cooler, 14.5" Case-sysfan1, dual sysfan2, exhaust
Keyboard
Blue Star Ergonomic - ps/2
Mouse
LED coorded w/v. roller wheel - ps/2
Internet Speed
GbLAN 10/100/1000 & WLAN - on T1 (Peer Network)
Other Info
Harmon-Karden speakers (L,R @ sub)

APC (Lead/Acid Batt backup UPC+Surge protector+etc)

Sony DVD SATA(300) - RW DVD/CD SATA-II(300)
Macrium Reflect has a product that allows you to "migrate" a Win7 install from a hard drive to a SMALLER SSD -- by allowing you, as part of the migration effort, to exclude specific file types (i.e., pictures, videos, data files). Sorry, don't remember the product name -- but you might want to look into this.
 

My Computer

Computer type
PC/Desktop
Computer Manufacturer/Model Number
Custom
OS
Win7 Pro 32-bit, Win8 Pro 32-bit
CPU
AMD Phenom II X6 1090T
Motherboard
Gigabyte
Memory
4GB ddr3 1300
Graphics Card(s)
AMD HD 4290 onboard
Sound Card
Builtin Realtek HD Audio
Monitor(s) Displays
Samsung 24" widescreen, LG 23" widescreen
Screen Resolution
1920x1200/1920x1080
Hard Drives
Kingston 256GB SSD
Keyboard
Logitech Illuminated Keyboard
Mouse
Logitech M705 wireless mouse
Antivirus
Norton Av 2013
Browser
IE v10
Macrium Reflect has a product that allows you to "migrate" a Win7 install from a hard drive to a SMALLER SSD -- by allowing you, as part of the migration effort, to exclude specific file types (i.e., pictures, videos, data files). Sorry, don't remember the product name -- but you might want to look into this.
Are you sure you talk about Macrium and not Paragon - like this one: Paragon Paragon Migrate OS to SSD - Overview It can do what you described.
 

My Computer

Computer Manufacturer/Model Number
HP, Dell, Gateway, Toshiba - 4 laptops and 2 desktops
OS
Vista, Windows7, Mint Mate, Zorin, Windows 8
CPU
from 1.6GHz Duo to i7
Monitor(s) Displays
2x HP w2207
Hard Drives
5x HDD, 7x SSD, 12x Externals
Keyboard
with trackball - no mices
Mouse
Trackball mice
Internet Speed
DSL 6000
Not sure I'd bother with Paragon Migrate OS to SSD, it's a pretty poorly written bit of software. On my Win7 64 bit system it goes through all the motions, reboots to continue copying the data to the new SSD partition and then comes up with 'Some Error Occured: Bad parameter of function'... and an 'OK' box which doesn't accept any input. On a reset when windows finishes booting it runs and tells you it's successfully copied your drive and you should now change the boot order...but of course it hasn't. not terribly helpful.

I've mailed support but they haven't replied yet and scanning the net there are lots of people having problem swith this software and support isn't very good.

Looking at the partition layout of the SSD after the failure it's copied the 83MB or so system partition but hasn't even created the primary partition, much less copied it.
 

My Computer

OS
Windows 7 Home Premium 64bit
Macrium Free v5 has the ability to do either an "intelligent" sector copy or a sector by sector copy. This applies both to Imaging and Cloning.
 

My Computer

Computer type
Laptop
Computer Manufacturer/Model Number
Hewlett-Packard/G62-107SA Notebook
OS
Microsoft Windows 7 Home Premium 64-bit Service Pack 1
CPU
Intel(R) Core(TM) i3 CPU M 330 @ 2.13GHz
Motherboard
Hewlett-Packard 1425
Memory
8 GB DDR3
Graphics Card(s)
Intel(R) HD Graphics
Sound Card
Realtek High Definition Audio
Monitor(s) Displays
Builtin
Screen Resolution
1366 x 768 x 32 bits (4294967296 colors) @ 60 Hz
Hard Drives
250 GB SATA Hard Disk Drive 7200 rpm
2TB Seagate GoFlex USB 2 Drive
1TB Iomega Prestige USB 2 Drive
1.5TB Iomega Prestige USB 2 Drive (Samsung)
2TB WD MyBook Live NAS.
Mouse
Logitech Anywhere MX
Internet Speed
152 Mbs download 10 Mbs upload
Antivirus
Norton 360
Browser
Chrome
To answer the previous question -- YES, I'm sure it was Macrium Reflect. The product is known as RoboRestore.
 

My Computer

Computer type
PC/Desktop
Computer Manufacturer/Model Number
Custom
OS
Win7 Pro 32-bit, Win8 Pro 32-bit
CPU
AMD Phenom II X6 1090T
Motherboard
Gigabyte
Memory
4GB ddr3 1300
Graphics Card(s)
AMD HD 4290 onboard
Sound Card
Builtin Realtek HD Audio
Monitor(s) Displays
Samsung 24" widescreen, LG 23" widescreen
Screen Resolution
1920x1200/1920x1080
Hard Drives
Kingston 256GB SSD
Keyboard
Logitech Illuminated Keyboard
Mouse
Logitech M705 wireless mouse
Antivirus
Norton Av 2013
Browser
IE v10
Not sure I'd bother with Paragon Migrate OS to SSD, it's a pretty poorly written bit of software. On my Win7 64 bit system it goes through all the motions, reboots to continue copying the data to the new SSD partition and then comes up with 'Some Error Occured: Bad parameter of function'... and an 'OK' box which doesn't accept any input. On a reset when windows finishes booting it runs and tells you it's successfully copied your drive and you should now change the boot order...but of course it hasn't. not terribly helpful.

I've mailed support but they haven't replied yet and scanning the net there are lots of people having problem swith this software and support isn't very good.

Looking at the partition layout of the SSD after the failure it's copied the 83MB or so system partition but hasn't even created the primary partition, much less copied it.
Too bad you had so much trouble. I have migrated several systems with the program and never had any trouble. I have also communicated with the Paragon people and always got prompt responses. Hope you can sort it out.
 

My Computer

Computer Manufacturer/Model Number
HP, Dell, Gateway, Toshiba - 4 laptops and 2 desktops
OS
Vista, Windows7, Mint Mate, Zorin, Windows 8
CPU
from 1.6GHz Duo to i7
Monitor(s) Displays
2x HP w2207
Hard Drives
5x HDD, 7x SSD, 12x Externals
Keyboard
with trackball - no mices
Mouse
Trackball mice
Internet Speed
DSL 6000
Back
Top